World War II and the Battle to Preserve Humanity
This paper argues that the "real war" of World War II, beyond its political and ideological objectives, was the daily struggle soldiers faced to preserve their humanity and moral values under conditions of extreme violence. Drawing on E.B. Sledge's With the Old Breed and Studs Terkel's The Good War, the paper examines how combat desensitized soldiers to brutality, eroded conventional morality, and fostered dangerous learned behaviors. At the same time, it explores how loyalty, love, and the influence of veteran comrades — the "old breed" — served as counterweights, helping some soldiers resist moral corruption and maintain their humanity throughout the conflict.
- Introduction: Defining the Real War: Framing WWII's true conflict as moral and human
- The Battle for Humanity in the Pacific Theater: Sledge's memoir as lens for soldier morality
- Desensitization and the Loss of Moral Restraint: Gold teeth incident and celebratory friendly fire
- Learned Behavior and the Rules of War: How soldiers adopted brutal norms from peers
- The Old Breed: Loyalty, Love, and Moral Resistance: Veteran marines as guardians of soldiers' humanity
- Conclusion: Humanity as the True Battlefield: Love and loyalty as the ultimate moral weapons
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses primary source quotations purposefully — each excerpt from Sledge and Terkel is directly tied to the paper's central thesis about the struggle to preserve humanity, rather than being cited as historical background.
- Maintains a clear, sustained argument throughout: rather than cataloguing war events, every paragraph returns to the same analytical lens — the tension between moral corruption and moral resistance.
- Balances close textual analysis with broader interpretive claims, showing how individual anecdotes (the gold teeth incident, the celebratory shooting deaths) illuminate a larger philosophical point.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic literary analysis applied to historical nonfiction. Rather than summarizing the sources, the writer extracts specific episodes and quotations, then interprets them as evidence for a conceptual claim — that "the real war" was internal and moral, not merely military. This technique requires clearly stating the interpretive framework in the introduction and consistently measuring each piece of evidence against it.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad framing of the war's official objectives before pivoting to its central thesis: the true conflict was each soldier's battle for their humanity. It then introduces Sledge's memoir as the primary lens, walks through two key anecdotes (plundering teeth, celebratory friendly-fire deaths), draws a structural parallel between the two, and closes by positioning loyalty and love — embodied by the "old breed" — as the moral counterforce. The conclusion restates the thesis through Sledge's own words.
Introduction: Defining the Real War
When attempting to discern what the "real war" was in a conflict involving as many international powers as those represented in World War II, it is tempting to examine the issue in terms of the goals sought by each side. For Hitler and the other Axis leaders, those goals were the implementation of fascist, totalitarian governments and the eventual conquest of the world. For Franklin Roosevelt and the other Allied leaders, the war was a means of preserving democracy and a free market. All of these ends are complicated by the economic value of the conflict for the participants involved, as well as by pressing social concerns related to genocide and a host of other evils. Yet when one examines the question of the war's true nature through first-hand sources — primarily those of combatants and other direct participants in military engagements — a different picture emerges.
World War II was easily the most devastating war of the 20th century, occurring at precisely the moment when new technology converged with the global aspirations of all participants involved. The deliberate carnage and destruction inflicted had a profound effect upon many of those who lived through it, regardless of which side ultimately prevailed. A thorough analysis of multiple first-hand accounts of the war makes clear that the true war was a daily battle to preserve one's humanity and morals under conditions that were anything but conducive to doing so.
The Battle for Humanity in the Pacific Theater
One of the principal texts that illuminates this aspect of World War II is E.B. Sledge's With the Old Breed. Sledge's credentials for interpreting the nature of the real war are beyond dispute — he saw combat on numerous occasions with the 3rd Battalion, Fifth Marines of the First Division's mortar team in Okinawa. The location of his service is particularly important, as many U.S. combatants viewed Japanese soldiers as more evil and less human than their European Axis counterparts.1
Sledge's memoir emphasizes three things: the inherent brutality and sheer magnitude of the violence rendered during the war, the intense camaraderie that such conditions fostered among American soldiers, and the confluence of both. It is this confluence that primarily concerns the present discussion, since it is in the merging of wanton violence and savagery with the intense loyalty and love soldiers felt for one another that the true nature of the conflict — the battle for one's humanity — is best seen.
References
Sledge, E.B. With the Old Breed. New York: Presidio Press, 2007.
Terkel, Studs. The Good War. New York: The New Press, 1997.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.