This paper examines Irvin Yalom's therapeutic work with Carlos, a terminally ill cancer patient presented in Love's Executioner and Other Tales of Psychotherapy. Drawing on the case narrative, the paper analyzes how Yalom employs a multi-modal approach that integrates psychodynamic therapy, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), Adlerian therapy, and Rogerian principles. Key concepts explored include transference neurosis, countertransference, unconscious processes, dream analysis, unconditional positive regard, and the use of irrational belief confrontation. The paper demonstrates how ambitious therapeutic goals remain achievable even with end-of-life patients whose presenting behaviors are socially objectionable, showing that multiple theoretical frameworks can converge toward meaningful psychological and relational change.
The opening phase of dynamic psychotherapy helps the therapist understand why the patient is seeking treatment, what kinds of triggers to current problems are present, and how troubled the patient is in terms of both physical and psychological health (text p. 41). Yalom (1989) allows for several sessions of introductory therapy, also in keeping with the psychodynamic model. During this introductory phase, the therapist forms an idea of what treatment options to present and how to proceed. Yalom (1989) also determines the frequency of treatment during the introductory phase (text p. 41).
The core way that the relationship between Yalom (1989) and Carlos exemplifies psychodynamic therapy is in regard to the transference neurosis, which intensifies in therapy (text p. 53). However, transference is worked through as a core element of the therapeutic process. In the case of Carlos, neurotic transference is exemplified most clearly in the way Carlos goads the therapist in relation to his sexual desires. When he speaks about rape, he eggs on Yalom (1989) as if to get him to admit that he also wants to rape women. As Yalom (1989) puts it, there is likely "some Oedipal competition going on between the two of us which was making communication more difficult" (p. 70). Yalom (1989) recognizes that Carlos's graphic descriptions of what he would do — and his goading question about whether Yalom would also rape if he could — are signs that Carlos projects rivalry onto him. This rivalry transforms itself during the therapeutic process into a relationship of mutual respect and healing.
Yalom's (1989) willingness to explore Carlos's unconscious reveals techniques rooted in psychoanalysis and psychodynamic therapy, both of which honor the role the unconscious mind can play in the development of neuroses and coping mechanisms. The therapist repeatedly returns to Carlos's dreams, notably the dream of the green Honda. Similarly, Yalom (1989) refers to Carlos's fear of death and his compensation for it through a belief in reincarnation. The green Honda dream allows a convergence between the role of the subconscious and the fear of death.
However, Yalom (1989) does not confine himself to a singular therapeutic model. Especially with Carlos, the patient's complex issues require a multifaceted approach. In addition to the dynamic psychoanalytic model, Yalom (1989) draws on Adlerian, Rogerian, and Ellis's Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT). With regard to REBT in particular, Yalom (1989) relies heavily on its techniques. As the Corsini and Wedding (n.d.) textbook notes, REBT "holds that people are biologically and culturally predisposed to choose, create, and enjoy, but that they are also strongly predisposed to overconform...hate, and foolishly block their enjoying" (p. 231).
Throughout Yalom's (1989) analysis and narrative, it is clear the therapist believes that Carlos has tremendous potential to "choose, create, and enjoy," which is why he engages Carlos in sessions with "ambitious" treatment goals. This is also the area in which Yalom's (1989) therapy combines REBT principles with those of Rogerian therapy, as Rogerian therapy advocates unconditional positive regard. Yalom (1989) exhibits nothing but unconditional positive regard for a patient who, he admits, would be difficult to refer to another therapist given his disruptive behavior in group sessions.
"Patient background, misogyny, and countertransference issues"
"Dreams, symbolism, and therapeutic progress"
"REBT breakthroughs and Adlerian equal-relationship therapy"
Yalom's (1989) multi-modal approach allows Carlos to come to terms with mortality in his own way. Drawing from Rogerian therapy, Yalom (1989) uses unconditional positive regard to care for the patient with empathy and an understanding of Carlos's internal frame of reference, even when the client is highly distasteful and socially reprehensible. Overcoming Carlos's dysfunctional coping mechanisms, denials, and defenses requires a comprehensive intervention that is ambitious in scope, demonstrating that end-of-life patients can achieve meaningful therapeutic change when multiple theoretical frameworks are applied with skill and genuine regard for the patient's humanity.
You’re 39% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.