Clinical Psychology: Psyd Vs. PhD Essay

Thus, PysD programs prove beneficial in terms of professional expectations. This more practice-orientated path goes beyond research. PsyD programs offer a "Comprehensive, carefully supervised training for practice and thorough training for research cannot both be accomplished in the time allowed," (Walfish & Hess 2001:54).

Preparation for the student within a PsyD program comes from actual practice, rather than simple observation. It is within this scope of practice which allows for more thorough preparation for clinical practice. According to the research, "The PsyD students were to have class work as rigorous as that of their fellow students who were working for a PhD, but instead of doing research-based dissertations, they spent more time in practicum work and submitted a final document focusing more on a clinical demonstration project instead," (Walfish & Hess 2001:48). Students are allowed to go beyond the classroom and experience the reality of clinical practice within a psychology context. The result is better prepared graduates. In PysD programs, "Students are not expected to believe that the best way to prepare for a professional career is to do research. They are trained for practice," (Walfish & Hess 2001:53). Thus, there is an emphasis on more hands-on learning approaches. Yet, this emphasis on practice over research is not the only reason for its superiority.

Lastly, the PsyD proves to provide a much more specialized education which prepares students for more focused professional practice following graduation. According to research, the PsyD is "based in disciplined knowledge," (Walfish & Hess 2001:53). Therefore, these students are trained with a specific focus in mind. Most PsyD programs are taught by working professionals rather than scholars "The faculty in schools adhering to the professional model of training became largely composed of practicing...

...

Additionally, the PsyD program is modern and innovative. It provides a specialized and up-to-date training for practice within a modern and ever-changing world. Therefore, it is superior than the PhD in that it is a progression from it. "Most of your undergraduate professors, regardless of what department they are in, earned a PhD," whereas PsyD graduates are actual clinicians working presently in the field (Keith-Spiegel & Wiederman 2000:44). Thus, these degree programs help mold ready experts who can easily adjust into the actual and real professional world. The emphasis on creating a working-ready educational background then provides a much better opportunity for graduates when they enter the working world.
It is clear; despite the universal appeal of PhD programs, PsyD programs offer a better education within the context of clinical psychology. The PsyD programs then prove the most beneficial in terms of preparing budding psychologists as they enter real world situations in a clinical context. Thus, a PsyD program would be the best choice within the specific situation of pursuing a doctoral degree within clinical psychology.

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Johnson, W. Brad & Mcminn, Mark R. (2003). Thirty years of integrative Doctoral training: historic developments, assessment of outcomes, and recommendations for the future. Journal of Psychology and Theology. 31(2):83-86.

Keith-Spiegel, Patricia & Wiederman, Michael W. (2000). The Complete Guide to Graduate School Admission: Psychology, Counseling, and Related Professions. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Walfish, Steven & Hess, Allen K. (2001). Succeeding in Graduate School: The Career Guide for Psychology Students. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.


Cite this Document:

"Clinical Psychology Psyd Vs PhD" (2010, February 11) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/clinical-psychology-psyd-vs-phd-15152

"Clinical Psychology Psyd Vs PhD" 11 February 2010. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/clinical-psychology-psyd-vs-phd-15152>

"Clinical Psychology Psyd Vs PhD", 11 February 2010, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/clinical-psychology-psyd-vs-phd-15152

Related Documents

clinical psychology as a distinct pursuit and profession emerged in the late nineteenth century. However, a "climate of ideas receptive to the development of clinical psychology" emerged as early as the late 18th century (Reisman, 1976, p. vii). Clinical psychology perspectives reflected trends in Enlightenment thinking and the rise of the scientific method as a primary means of investigating reality. Enlightenment issues like individualism underlie much of clinical psychology.

LICSW and LP Both Licensed
PAGES 12 WORDS 3779

It is true that a LP is required to have a doctoral degree in order to meet one of the requirements for getting a license to practice psychology, while a LCSW only needs to have a MSC, but this is not a criterion to distinguish a LP from LCSW as the former being more academically suited for a job in a health care setting than the other. "A psychology

S., experts estimate the genuine number of incidents of abuse and neglect ranges three times higher than reported. (National Child Abuse Statistics, 2006) in light of these critical contemporary concerns for youth, this researcher chose to document the application of Object Relation, Attachment Theories, and Self-Psychology to clinical practice, specifically focusing on a patient who experienced abuse when a child. Consequently, this researcher contends this clinical case study dissertation proves

Research Vision and Professional CompetenciesAbstractMy goal as a psychology practitioner-scholar is to understand and promote the mental health of individuals in high-stress situations. I am particularly interested in how social and cultural factors can influence the development of mental health disorders. To do this, I plan to work in a setting that provides direct psychological services to individuals, such as a counseling center or a hospital. I would also like

Licensure Plan Rachel Faybyshev Foundations of Mental Health Counseling Dr. Mary Owens My Personal Licensure Plan The process of obtaining licensure as a Mental Health Counselor begins with attending and graduating from an approved NY State Education Department (SED) Master's Program. Having stated that, I am a step in the right direction by attending LIU's Clinical Mental Health Counseling program at the moment. While that is the case, my plan is to further my education

Psychological Testing
PAGES 3 WORDS 989

Psychological Testing When one hears the phrase "psychological testing" one might be inclined to think of a test to determine one's mental health, a test that could tell someone whether she or he was crazy or not. But psychological testing is hardly so clear-cut, nor does it deal with the highly subjective subject of sanity. Psychological tests instead measure a range of qualities and potentials, including one's aptitude for various kinds