Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Buy and Sell Organs for Transplants:
The consideration of the possible negative socio-ethical repercussions of allowing people to buy and sell their non-vital body organs for transplant fortifies the argument of all opponents to the proposition. As stated in the U.S. Constitution, human beings are created equal and given the un-separable rights to life, freedom, and the pursuit of happiness. While in the pursuit of these rights, the American society has learnt that the end does not always justify the means and as such, necessary legislation has been instituted to help protect minorities from majorities, the poor from the wealthy, and the weak from the strong. A society in which people could buy and sell organs for transplant would further ruin the pursuit for equality and frustrate the liberty of generosity needed for living a happy life.
Opposing the proposition does not mean that one believes society bears no duty to preserve life and relieve human suffering, rather it is a stand on the principle that longer life cannot be pursued by any means whatsoever. According to statistics, more than 100,000 individuals find themselves in need of life-saving organ...
While biomedical breakthroughs have greatly increased the capacity of medical institutions to perform successful transplants, most healthy people are unwilling to donate their non-vital organs. As such, an average of 18 such individuals ends up dying each day for lack of an available and matching organ donor ("Statistics," n.d.).
Narrowing the huge gap between the need and availability of transplant organs is the key underlying argument for those advocating the right to sell and buy transplant organs. Proponents argue that money would definitely prove sufficient incentive for many people to sell organs to improve their financial situation. They argue this would greatly reduce the donor-recipient gap and the unnecessary deaths due to lack of organ transplants.
While it seems like the adoption of such a proposition would ease the life and happiness of many organ donors and desperate recipients alike, it is important to note the cons that outweigh the pros of such a reality. In a capitalistic society like America's, simple economics would immediately determine who would have the…
References:
Andre, C. & Velasquez, M. (n.d.). Kidneys for Sale. Retrieved from Santa Clara University -- The Jesuit University in Silicon Valley website: http://www.scu.edu/ethics/publications/iie/v1n2/kidneys.html
Mayes, G. (2003.) Buying and Selling Organs for Transplantation in the U.S.: National Organ Transplant Act of 1984 (NOTA) Bans Buying and Selling. Medscape Education, 4(2). Retrieved from http://www.medscape.org/viewarticle/465200_2
"Statistics." (n.d.). Donate Life America. Retrieved January 31, 2012, from http://donatelife.net/understanding-donation/statistics/
Argumentative essay for organ transplantation Organ transplantation is the donating of one’s organ to another human being for replacing his or her damaged organ (County 2). This procedure has been proven to be successful in children and young adults and the elderly with comorbidities (Grinyó 1). This can prove to be life-saving for patients with terminal organ failures and painful therapies for survival (Grinyó 1). Over the last 60 years, the
Organ Donation There is a space for a small pink sticker on everyone's driver's license which you choose to affix or to leave off of the identification. The sticker signifies that, should you be in a car accident and are declared to be brain-dead with no chance of recuperating, you agree to allow medical professionals to donate your organs to people who are in very dire need of them. When people
Many of the arguments advanced by those in support of organ sales are actually valid: the choice is substantially indistinguishable from other choices permitted for different reasons; and any addition on donor organs to the very tight "market" of available donor organs would likely mean that one additional organ would become available to other potential recipients. However, the principal argument against the permissibility of selling donor organs is not the
Selling Human Organs: The Ethical Issue Selling body transplants is one of the latest ventures that entrepreneurs have devised. Some see it as servicing a public good, whilst others perceive it as one more example of capitalism at its worst. Barry Jacobs is an example of an international broker for bodily parts whose business involves matching up kidney "donors" with patients needing kidney transplants. The donor receives a magnanimous paycheck; the recipient
Ethic - Organ Donation The donation of organs and their eventual transplant have been regarded as a distinct way in which mankind shows and shares its compassion. Cutting out organs from one person and moving them into the body of another is one of the many 20th century medical discoveries that have grown rapidly from a trial and error kind of approach into a medical therapy of choice that treats many
Legalizing Sale Organs. Include a Works Cited page. Writing Tips Academic Essay a. Use present tense MacKay's essay "essay "conclusions . There is presently much controversy regarding the sale or organs, as while society has traditionally adopted unsupportive attitudes regarding this enterprise, many people lobby in favor of legalizing it. Joanna McKay's essay "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" explains why it is wrong to consider that organ sale is an