Verified Document

Fault: An Alternative To The Current Tort-Based Thesis

Fault: An Alternative to the Current Tort-Based System in England and WalesThe United Kingdom

statistics regarding claims

THE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM

OBSTACLES TO DUE PROCESS

THE CASE FOR REFORM

THE REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT

THE RISING COST OF LITIGATION

LORD WOOLF'S REFORMS

MORE COST CONTROLS

THE UNITED STATES

PAUL'S PULLOUT

THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY

TORT REFORM IN AMERICA

FLEEING PHYSICIANS

STATISTICS FOR ERROR, INJURY AND DEATH

THE CALL FOR REFORM IN 2003: A FAMILIAR REFRAIN

THE UNITED STATES SITUATION, IN SUMMARY

NEW ZEALAND CASE STUDIES

THE SWEDISH SCHEME

COMPARISON: WHICH SYSTEM IS BETTER?

FIRST: UNDERLYING DIFFERENCES

TALKING TORT: AMERICAN PECULIARITIES

AMERICANS CONSIDER NO-FAULT

BRITAIN CONSIDERS NO-FAULT

CONCLUSION

Works Cited

Appendix A THE UNITED KINGDOM

INTRODUCTION

At issue is the economic effectiveness of tort law in the common law legal system of England and Wales, as applied to medical and clinical negligence and malpractice cases. In response to economic concerns and a continual rise in cases, an examination of the consideration of a proposed no-fault alternative to the current system is underway. We will explore the basis of the current system, the impetus for change, and the characteristics of no-fault reform as experienced by other countries and its pros and cons. The principal aim of tort reform is to limit the legal or financial exposure of the NHS (National Health System) to liability for damages and to streamline the process of compensation for plaintiffs.

The common law legal system is germane not only to England, Wales and Northern Ireland, but also the Irish Republic which constitutes a major part of the mixed legal system of Scotland. The concept of Enterprise Liability was introduced in England in 1991 with Crown Indemnity and the establishment of the Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts, now run by the NHS Litigation Authority. There are similar schemes in Scotland and Wales. In the U.S. almost all hospitals whether self-insured or placing their insurance in the open commercial market do so on an "enterprise" basis. "Enterprise Liability extends the essence of liability of health boards and hospitals to the doctors and dentists in the same sense as they incur liability for the acts of other health care providers such as nurses and administrative staff.

A medical practitioner's conduct is generally measured by what is considered accepted medical practice. That means that a doctor will not be found negligent if a patient is treated in accordance with a practice accepted by a responsible body of medical opinion. Under the current system, by definition a "tort" is a breach of duty by negligence or malpractice leading to a liability for damages. A medical negligence trial will therefore focus on defining what accepted medical practice is in the circumstances of a particular case. Often the only experts qualified to make that determination are medical personnel.

Under the current system, the proper channel of redress for the patient is civil litigation, which contrary to no-fault solutions is founded on the principle of fault, responsibility and liability and resulting compensatory awards that reflect the nature of such findings. Since the cause of action is based in civil negligence, the burden of proof, and much of the financial burden until a determination and/or award is reached falls on potential plaintiffs, often including securing a bond equal to a significant percentage of alleged monetary damages.

The nature of a trial often boils down to the strength of the testimony of opposing experts: experts which can be a challenge for plaintiffs to retain. Doctors are reluctant to testify against peers, in the event they themselves one day are in the unattractive position of defendant. Cases can be complex and lengthy in nature during which time the victim remains uncompensated for their loss and awaits an uncertain outcome. Alan Milburn, in a BBC News Health broadcast on July 20, 2001, stated: at present the average time it takes for claims to be settled is 5.5 years.

A modicum of blame must be established before compensation for injury or loss can be rendered. In the meantime, an individual can suffer permanent and irreversible injury that, contrary to appearances, may be an exception to a normal expectation of a successful treatment, in which case there would be no blame. As a result, either no compensation is available, or an attempt is made...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

The nature of the process of civil litigation evokes a defensive attitude in all parties, as it is a black and white, "right or wrong" arena for issues that are often gray.
One of the worst imaginings of the human mind is to seek medical assistance and to be harmed as a result. Yet there lies a difference between harm due to negligence or a harm due to a set of accidental circumstances that could not have been foreseen. The medical field does not inherently provide guarantees for the outcome of all treatment. Today, the patient plays a greater role in his or her own care through the concept of informed consent. It is no longer the doctor's role as God and exalted ruler to deem whether or not the prescribed patient care will be administered as he or she sees fit; the patient must agree based on the alternatives provided and give consent for the care. It is of course within the concept of acceptable practice for the doctor to inform the patient of all risks and alternatives. It stands then that under common law, the principles are well established in that when an adverse effect is the result of third party misconduct or negligence, it is the right of the victim to seek compensation.

STATISTICS REGARDING CLAIMS

While accurate statistics are largely unavailable regarding the rise in litigation, a Harvard Medical Malpractice Study, which examined 31,000 hospital records in New York State, provides a possible measure of the size of the rate of medical error in hospitals. The Harvard Study has become the institutional standard for a methodology to estimate medical error, perhaps because to do so independently is such a humongous undertaking. The primary conclusion of Harvard's study pinpointed a rough estimate of approximately one in twenty-seven patients who suffered an "adverse event" as a result of their hospital experience. The study further exclaimed that one in four of these events resulted from negligence. Overall it was estimated that one adverse event occurred for every 100 patients hospitalized. The Harvard methodology has been replicated throughout the United States, Ireland and the United Kingdom.1

According to a report Commissioned by the Department of Heath and Children entitled "The Road to Enterprise Liability" in February of 2001, when the Harvard methodology was applied to demographics in Ireland, the results were as follows:

Inpatients

Inpatients & Day patients

Total treated

Adverse Events

Negligent Injuries

Claims

Successful Claims

The table data translates to 3.7 in 100 inpatients who suffered adverse events. The ratio remained the same when day patients were added to the mix. The ratio for negligent injuries translates to.92 of every 100 patients, results startlingly similar to the Harvard estimates. The rate of claims in these cases was.1156 in 100, or one in eight negligent injuries and one in thirty two adverse events. While the possibility that one in one hundred patients on average will suffer an adverse event due to negligence during a hospital stay, only one in eight will pursue a claim, lays testimony to the obstacles posed in the tort process for prospective plaintiffs. Causation is more difficult to establish in clinical negligence than in other personal injury cases, primarily because the result of the negligent treatment must be set apart from the patient's underlying condition that necessitated the treatment in the first place. The burden of proof is entirely up to the patient, which can be difficult to establish because the patient often has the least information. Hospitals possess the patient records, which can be difficult to obtain, and the medical opinions and particulars rest with the doctors and medical practitioners. The patient must rely on the testimony of outside experts and the advice of lawyers in hoping to first gain acknowledgement for harm done, then just compensation.

From October to November of 2001, the MORI Survey was conducted by the English Advisory Committee on the Review of Clinical Negligence.2 The survey tried to quantify the frequency and/or severity of adverse effects through a population sampling experienced as a result of their medical treatment. The respondent sample consisted of 3638 men and 4568 women, or a total population of 8,206.

395, or 4.8% (4.8 in every 100) patients felt that they had suffered some illness, injury or impairment, which directly resulted from their medical treatment or care. This figure is slightly higher than the estimates derived using the methodology…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Irish Republican Army It Is
Words: 3855 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

The solution is easy. According to Eddie Boyle IRA'a primary objective is to upset the opponent's routine of life and the economy of the North. They will act in a manner to make certain the Army is all the while endeavoring to second guess the IRA and ascertain what is scheduled to occur the forthcoming moment. It is the objective of the IRA to restore social equality, self-rule, equity,

IRA: Irish Republican Army the
Words: 1266 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Roman Catholics, who made up around one-third of the population of Northern Ireland, were largely opposed to the partition (Intelligence pp). The IRA declined swiftly from internal dissentions and due to a loss of popular support because of its violence and pro-German agitation during World War II (Irish 2004). The attainment of republican objectives in 1949 and government measures against its illegal activities also contributed to its decline (Irish 2004).

History of the Irish Republican
Words: 2320 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

It has also set off bombs in towns in the North of Ireland. The group is said to be the only military group in Ireland never to have yet killed or targeted a civilian. As of 2004, the CIRA is not believed to have an established presence or capability of launching attacks on the island of Great Britain. In 2004 the U.S. government believed the CIRA to consist of

Irish Emigration to America &
Words: 1171 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

After the period of the Irish Famine, nearly a quarter of the people in Ireland had left for America. Most of the Irish coming to America had been poor and could not afford to travel further inland. Thus, most of the Irish settled in the cities near the ports where they arrived. Those that had raised enough money to meet the expense of traveling and buying land moved to

Irish Economics Economic Systems and
Words: 392 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

The economy is market-oriented, and highly technologically advanced. Primary sectors include petroleum, steel, motor vehicles, consumer goods, aerospace, and telecommunications (CIA the World Factbook, United States). Both Ireland and the United States have a high degree of economic freedom. The Heritage Foundation ranks Ireland as the world's 7th freest economy, with high levels of investment, financial, business, and property rights freedom. However, labor freedom is the weakest area for Ireland

IRA and Farc the Irish
Words: 1876 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Proposal

The RIRA on occasion attacks a British army base, or bombs a civilian site just to show it is still out there while FARC is a powerful force that the government has no choice but to negotiate with. Also, the RIRA does not recruit young children for its violent terrorist activities, while FARC recruits and kidnaps thousands of young boys and trains them in guerrilla warfare. The RIRA does

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now