Verified Document

Informal And Formal Reading Assessments Essay

¶ … standardized tests and there is math association with the results. On the other hand informal reading assessments do not have the same formal data requirements and is based more on performance. These two kinds of assessments will be critiqued in this paper. Formal Reading Assessments

Parents should know and understand not only why their children are being accessed, but through which process the assessment is being conducted. The more parents are involved in the education of their children, the closer parents will be to opportunities to participate and contribute to those important years of education. Brenda Weaver writes in Scholastic magazine that first of all, whether it is informal or formal, assessments need to match up with the purpose of assessing any particular student. Formal assessments are generally used to assess "overall achievement" and to "compare a student's performance with others at their age or grade."

Parents should be informed as to the purpose of reading assessments, and they should be assured this is not an intelligence test but rather it is used to determine "…the level of text that will challenge students" and will "…motivate them to read rather than causing frustration" (Rubin, 2011, p. 606). Formal Reading assessments are standardized tests, designed to evaluate elementary students based on formulae designed by a corporation or a scholastic organization, and they tend not to be specific to any location or nationality or ethnicity.

Disadvantages of Formal Reading Assessments

Jim Rubin notes that many school districts use standardized (formal) assessment tests, and generally those standardized tests are designed to assess: "phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension" (Rubin, 606). However, Rubin questions "the wisdom" of a teacher who uses only one formal assessment test; using "only one tool" (test) to pass judgment on a student's reading ability is not the smartest or best way to make an accurate assessment, the author of this article asserts. Rather than a standardized assessment test of a student's reading ability, Rubin suggests using an informal test like the "cloze test" or the "Informal Reading Inventories" assessment...

Either one of those informal assessment tests "…offers a classroom teacher an opportunity to exert control of the process," after all, the teacher knows best which reading material is appropriate for each student in his or her classroom (Rubin, 606).
Researches have been questioning the "reliability" of settling on standardized assessment tests from commercial publishers for some time because the "validity" of assessment based on a single standardized test "…can be questionable," Rubin continues (607). To get a valid picture of the reading comprehension of a student, teachers should not rely "…exclusively on the scores from a single standardized test" -- in particular, when a teacher has a diversity of ethnicities and cultures in his or her classroom (Rubin, 606).

What should a teacher do regarding formal vs. informal assessments? For one thing, since teachers have little or no say in the administration of formal tests, they can break out of that conundrum and instead they can "…feel empowered" when they use alternative -- or their own -- assessment strategies (Rubin, 607).

The Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS) -- a formal assessment test that is given to 4th graders in forty countries very five years -- has its disadvantages, according to the Center for Public Education (Ogle, CPE, 2007). A first pertinent question is, why test 4th graders? The CPE answer to that question is this: because 4th grade represents a "key transitional point in children's development as readers" worldwide, and at this point in a child's education, formal reading instruction is either ending or about to end (Ogle, CPE).

There are several negative aspects of the PIRLS project: a), it is a "huge, complex undertaking, costing millions of dollars and involving thousands of people worldwide"; b) the PIRLS is "fraught with technical challenges" and because it is international, "problems exist"; and c) in order to present accurate assessment results, there must be translations from German to English, French to English, and myriad other translations, and this process can be fraught with challenges and errors (Ogle, CPE).

Informal Reading Assessments

Writing…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Nilsson, Nina L. (2008). A Critical Analysis of Eight Informal Reading Inventories. The Reading Teacher, 61(7), 526-536.

Ogle, Laurence T. (2007). The Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS): a description. Center for Public Education. Retrieved June 13, 2012, from http://www.centerforpubliceducation.org.

Rosado, Luis A. (2006). TExES (103) Bilingual Generalist, EC-4 (REA) -- The Best Test Prep /

Best Test Preparation and Review Course Series. Piscataway, NJ: Research & Education
Informal Assessments. Scholastic. Retrieved June 14, 2012, from http://www.scholastic.com.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Reading Improvement of Third Grade Students
Words: 6946 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

Reading Improvement in Third Grade Students Applied Dissertation Proposal for the Degree of Doctor of Education Making resources available to the third grade students and teachers lends itself to the appropriate data, types of instruments, and instructional strategies used to enhance education. Wilson School leaders are getting acquainted with reading resources that are beneficial in order to provide teachers with test data, reading instruments, and specific strategies to assist them in raising

Improving Student Reading Skills
Words: 1921 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Curriculum and Instruction Compare and contrast the bottom-up curriculum and the top-down curriculum. Discuss instructional objectives, materials, learning environment, instructional strategies, and assessment. The top-down belief system related to curriculum centers on reading for meaning. Teachers who hold this philosophy of reading instruction stress engaging language arts activities that students find relevant and interesting. Indeed, teacher with this top-down perspective of reading curriculum are likely to encourage students to select their own

Coping with Covid by Using Informal Institutions
Words: 24565 Length: 82 Document Type: Conclusion Chapter

Coping Through the Use of Informal Institutions during COVID-19 in South Africa, Nigeria, and SwazilandChapter 1: IntroductionThe global outbreak of COVID-19 raises many concerns regarding how individuals and communities who live in African countries, with fragile health systems, cope with the pandemic. During past pandemics, individuals and communities in Africa have relied on customary practices and traditions, also commonly referred to as informal institutions (Moore, 2020). Informal institutions have continued

Why Are Portfolio Assessments the Best Tools to Use in Education
Words: 2840 Length: 9 Document Type: Literature Review

performance assessments. There will be a determination concerning how it assists in attaining educational goals. Educational assessment background will be presented and information on the way performance assessments are made use of in achieving goals will be analyzed. Assessing Student Performance The effect professional development has on improving mathematics instruction was examined in a few studies. The first study was carried out and involved thirty-six teachers who took up professional development

Lesson Plan Weekly Assessments in Reading and Writing
Words: 3443 Length: 11 Document Type: Lesson Plan

2LESSON PLAN/ASSESSMENT/WEEKLY PLANLesson Plan/Assessment/Weekly PlanThis paper aims at devising a weekly reading and writing plan and workshop outline for grade 1. It is a five-day plan in which reading and writing goals and objectives will be identified each day. One reading and writing lesson plan would be selected to elaborate in-depth for which clear learning objectives would be stated following the New York State Common Core Standards. For each lesson,

Differentiated Learning & Assessment -- PLC Presentation
Words: 1743 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Differentiated Learning & Assessment -- PLC Presentation Differentiated instruction and assessment recognizes that the individual needs, strengths and weaknesses of students must drive learning (Wormeli, 2007). Changing the outcomes of traditional lesson plans to account for differentiated learning is a fundamental part of ensuring student success. Each student's readiness, interest and learning profile is at the core of this approach. Students are diverse; therefore, instructional and assessment practices should be as

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now