Verified Document

Circumcision The Benefits And Risks Article Critique

Unfortunately, in an issue where support exists for both sides, the nurse must often make a difficult decision as to how to present information on the decision of whether to circumcise or not to circumcise to the parents. The current body of information provided to patients, if any information is provided at all, does not present a balanced view of the issue, the rather reflects the cultural opinions of physicians of in the United States. Recommended Actions

It is not the role of the nurse to make cultural decisions for patients. Yet, the nurses have an obligation to help of patients make informed medical decisions about the care of their newborn. Therefore, it is recommended that nurses implement plans to help provide parents with valid information on both the for and against side of the circumcision issue. The information should include empirical evidence that supports both sides of the issue.

This recommendation suggests that the hospitals prepare informational packets for parents that include evidence to support both sides the issue, at least until sufficient evidence is found to definitively support one side or the other. Hospitals need to develop a stance that is neutral and that is culturally sensitive. Hospitals that present a one-sided approach to the circumcision issue are not demonstrating that they are culturally diverse, but rather that they are reflecting the views of the dominant society.

Unlike research found during this literature review, it is recommended that evidence-based policy guidelines be developed that do not take a stance on the circumcision issue, but rather that present information on both sides. A hospital needs to develop policy guidelines that are based on solid evidence, rather than personal opinion. This guideline recommends that hospitals develop information that can be provided to parents that reflects the most current views on circumcision. According to the literature found during this exploration of the topic, the information contained in these materials should be neutral and present evidence on both sides of the issue. Only in rare medical cases, does the information favor circumcision.

However, it is their place to provide parents with sufficient information and a balanced approach to the topic so that parents can make their own decisions based on research and their own cultural preferences. Many nurses, currently disagree that circumcision is the best choice for newborns. The stance of the AAP on the issue is based on research that suggests that the practice of circumcision is not necessary and that it has no medical basis. However, new research is beginning to come into light that suggests that prophylactic circumcision can have a positive effect on preventing certain serious diseases such as HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases. For parents who choose not to circumcise, nurses need to be prepared to provide the information on how to care for the foreskin and penis so that UTIs do not occur in the future.
References

Dickerman, J. (2007)in . Circumcision in the Time of HIV: When Is There Enough Evidence to Revise the American Academy of Pediatrics' Policy on Circumcision? Pediatrics. 119 (5): 1006-1007.

Fortier, S. (2009). Debating Circumcision. RN. April 2009.

Jia, L., Hawley, S., & Paschal, a. et al. (2009). Immigrants vs. Non-Immigrants: Attitudes Toward and Practices of Non-Therapeutic Male Circumcision in the United States of America. Journal of Cultural Diversity. 16 (3): 92-98.

Provencio-Vasquez & Rodriguez, a. (2009). Circumcision Revisited. Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing. 14 (4): 295-297.

Provencio-Vasquez & Rodriguez, a. (2010). Circumcision Revisited. Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing. 15 (2): 97-98.

Schoen, E. (2006). Ignoring Evidence of Circumcision Benefits. Pediatrics. 118 (1): 385-387.

Sprunger, Jon (2009). Debating Circumcision. RN. April 2009.

Steadman, B. & Ellsworth, P. (2006). To Circ or Not to Circ: Indications, Risks, and Alternatives to Circumcision in the Pediatric Population with Phimosis. Urologic Nursing. 26(3):…

Sources used in this document:
References

Dickerman, J. (2007)in . Circumcision in the Time of HIV: When Is There Enough Evidence to Revise the American Academy of Pediatrics' Policy on Circumcision? Pediatrics. 119 (5): 1006-1007.

Fortier, S. (2009). Debating Circumcision. RN. April 2009.

Jia, L., Hawley, S., & Paschal, a. et al. (2009). Immigrants vs. Non-Immigrants: Attitudes Toward and Practices of Non-Therapeutic Male Circumcision in the United States of America. Journal of Cultural Diversity. 16 (3): 92-98.

Provencio-Vasquez & Rodriguez, a. (2009). Circumcision Revisited. Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing. 14 (4): 295-297.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Infant Male Circumcision Male Infant
Words: 1955 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

According to this professional, circumcisions that are competently performed under local anaesthesia cause no more pain or harm than an immunisation injection. Furthermore, male circumcision ahs shown benefits such as the reduction of sexually transmitted infections such as the human pailloma virus, chancroid and syphilis. She also cites studies that indicated a reduced risk of HIV infection in males who have been circumcised. Indeed, there are quite humane ways to

Female Circumcision Varying Conceptions of
Words: 4822 Length: 18 Document Type: Term Paper

Because of the private nature of the tradition and because the methods can range so greatly, it is difficult to adequately assess the details of female genital cutting in Africa. The history of the tradition goes back thousands of years and is often (incorrectly) associated with religious dictates (von der Osten-Sacken & Uwer, 2007). It has long been associated with Islam, though there has been active opposition from many Islamic

Ethics and Female Circumcision
Words: 2307 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Female Circumcision and Ethics The female circumcision practices are found to be followed by a number of regions and tribes in the world where this practice is considered to purify and provide health benefits to the females of that particular society. However, this practice is considered to be immoral and unethical by the ethical feminist and clinical experts who imply that female circumcision practices violate the autonomy of an individual and,

Breast Ironing in Cameroon Sexual
Words: 4350 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

In most societies, FGM is considered a cultural tradition, which is often used as an argument for its continuation. Though a tremendous range of practices fall under the title of female genital mutilation, understanding what is involved in the process really helps one understand why it is internationally condemned as a violation of human rights. The most drastic type of female genital mutilation is infibulation. A standard infibulation process is

Sociology - Sex & AIDS
Words: 1710 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

In its current form in the U.S., prostitution is associated with high rates of criminality, but that is likely a function of its illegal status more than of anything inherent in prostitution. Prostitution is also associated with high risks of STDs, but a closer examination of the specific factors to which that is attributable strongly suggest that legalizing prostitution can effectively eliminate that negative element. Ultimately, prevailing negative attitudes

Stopping of Female Genital Mutilation
Words: 1707 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Female genital mutilation should be stopped Female Genital Mutilation or FGM can be explained as a procedure that is performed or inflicted on women and girls in some developing countries (Klein et al., 2018). FGM entails the altering or cutting of female genitalia. There are many known consequences of inflicting FGM on women including viral and bacterial infections, psychological problems, and obstetrical complications. The FGM topic has been taken up by

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now