China's Influence in Africa Though Research Paper

Download this Research Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Research Paper:



This is true not only in African countries with "dictatorial or authoritarian regimes but in fact China's […] commonly shared roots with African nations […] has struck a chord even with those democratically elected leaders in Africa," allowing China access to even those countries that might at first glance appear to natural allies to the United States due to their democratic form of government.

Thus, Africa's colonial past has simultaneously meant that China has a natural cultural, historical, and ideological connection to the continent while any action by the United States is viewed with a degree of inherent suspicion and reluctance; the difficulty the United States has faced in developing close strategic and economic partnerships in the region is evidenced by the fact that it has yet to find a suitable host nation for AFRICOM, the U.S. military command on the continent, even amongst putative allies, at the same time that China has managed to secure crucial deals regarding the extraction of raw materials in order to support its growing economy and military expansion.

China has used its image as a fellow anti-colonialist developing nation in order to secure important economic and military deals for itself, positioning itself as less of a donor or benefactor and more of an equal partner, even if that equality is more rhetorical than practical.

This is in stark contrast to the kind of aid or development offered by the West, which has almost exclusively been given within the context of humanitarian aid or intervention, framed as a wealthy, Western nation magnanimously providing assistance to the poor, seemingly-failing states of the global South. As a result, China is able to use "the pillars of its foreign policy, notably unconditional respect for state sovereignty and its corollary, non-interference," in order to secure alliances for itself, even as it engages in behavior that ultimately undermines the sovereignty of African nations by making them dependent on Chinese investment, development, and military aid.

Of course, this form of hypocrisy or creative rhetoric is not substantively different from the United States' expressed commitment to democracy even as it props up dictators in the Middle East, and once again, the congruency between the two policies demonstrates how although China's rhetoric may differ, its methods are largely the same as the United States, with the only difference being those cultural and historical factors that allow one country to have a natural advantage in a particular region.

The obstacles facing the United States as it attempts to mitigate China's growing influence are substantial, because the lingering effects of Western colonialism and the ostensibly natural cultural, historical, and ideological connection between China and Africa mean that the United States must overcome centuries of ill-will as well as a naturally advantaged rival in order to maintain any sort of economic and military dominance in the region. However, these obstacles are not insurmountable, and recognizing them is actually the first step towards overcoming them. For example, recognizing that China's policy in Africa is strikingly similar to the United States' policy in the Middle East allows one to demystify China's rapid success, and thus move past the kind of myopic attitude that has characterized Western evaluations of China's behavior since at least 1949. Instead of imagining that China represents some kind of subversive, creeping threat, one must begin from the position that China's actions in Africa are simply the reiteration of a strategy that has been deployed elsewhere by the United States. This allows one to focus on those specific cultural and historical factors that benefit China and hinder the United States independent of the particular strategy of aid in return for economic and military favors.

The United States is never going to be able to erase the effects of colonialism, but it can take some important steps to ensure that its activities in Africa do not unnecessarily invoke the specter of colonialism and thus turn public and elite opinion against them. For example, by noting the success of China's focus on "partnerships" rather than "aid," the United States could gradually transition its foreign aid projects into economic development projects. In practical terms the change would actually be insignificant, because much of the United States' involvement in Africa is already geared towards economic development as a means of stabilizing the region, but in rhetorical terms, it would go a long way towards reframing U.S. intervention in the region, because it would reduce the perception that the United States views itself as somehow inherently superior to the African nations it seeks to ally itself with.

In turn, this rhetorical shift would likely make an increased U.S. military presence more palatable to friendly African nations, because it would appear as less of an occupying force and as more of a friendly entity, present only with the blessing of the host nations; the U.S. Naval Base in Bahrain is a prime example of how more equitable-sounding partnerships can precipitate and perpetuate a U.S. military presence in strategically important areas. Altering the rhetoric surrounding the presence of the U.S. military in Africa is especially important, because the central African opposition to AFRICOM, as outlined by the Head of the African Security Analysis Program and the Institute for Security Studies, is born out of the impression that "Africans were never consulted during the conceptualization of AFRICOM [but that] rather, AFRICOM was announced and has been presented as a fait accompli."

In other words, the opposition is not necessarily to a substantial U.S. military presence, but rather the way in which that presence has been framed and presented to the African population.

While "Chinese and American influence in Africa is not a zero-sum game in the near-term," as the continent becomes increasingly developed, its natural resources are extracted, and its population grows, influence and clout in the region will simultaneously become increasingly valuable harder to attain without a preexisting foothold.

China effectively has at least a fifty-year head-start on the United States, because it made efforts to support independence and anti-colonial movements in Africa almost immediately after it underwent its own political revolution. China's influence in Africa has only increased over the subsequent decades, because it has presented itself as a natural ally to African nations wary of Western efforts to control or colonize the continent.

China's success on the African continent is not nearly as mystifying or impressive as many foreign policy analysts would have one believe, because strategically China has essentially just followed the United States' lead by mimicking the latter's policy in the Middle East over the last half-century. Recognizing this allows one to examine China's Africa policy from a more objective position in order to not only understand what has made China so successful, but precisely what has kept the United States from effectively maintaining economic and military dominance in the region going forward. Revealing the lingering cultural and historical factors that have benefitted China while hindering the United States subsequently suggests some relatively straightforward methods by which the United States might mitigate China's growing influence while securing its own economic and military interests. In order to mitigate China's growing influence on the African continent, the United States must engage in a concerted effort to rhetorically distinguish its own actions from the region's colonial past, and in particular attempt to reframe its aid and intervention as equal partnerships, rather than strictly humanitarian assistance or pitying contributions, because even if this reframing is only rhetorical, it would go a long way towards securing American interests in the region. Reframing economic and humanitarian intervention as equal partnership will subsequently increase the likelihood that the United States can increase and maintain its military presence in the region, because it will no longer be regarded as a potential occupying force and will instead be viewed as an example of friendly strategic support. Africa is increasingly becoming one of the most important regions on the globe, and only by making these changes can the United States hope to maintain its economic and military dominance over the course of the twenty-first century.

Bibliography

da Cruz, Jose de Arimateia and Laura K. Stephens. "The U.S. Africa Command (Africom):

Building Partnership or Neo-Colonialism of U.S.-Africa Relations?" Journal of Third

World Studies 27 (2010): 193-213.

de Morais, Rafael Marques. "THE NEW IMPERIALISM: China in Angola." World Affairs 173

(2011): 67-74.

Esteban, Mario. "A Silent Invasion? African Views on the Growing Chinese Presence in Africa:

The Case of Equatorial Guinea." African and Asian Studies 9 (2010): 232-251.

Henk, Dan. "U.S. National…[continue]

Cite This Research Paper:

"China's Influence In Africa Though" (2012, July 20) Retrieved December 8, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/china-influence-in-africa-though-73401

"China's Influence In Africa Though" 20 July 2012. Web.8 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/china-influence-in-africa-though-73401>

"China's Influence In Africa Though", 20 July 2012, Accessed.8 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/china-influence-in-africa-though-73401

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • What Is China s Role in Globalization Why Is it Significant

    AFRICA'S PETROLEUM AND CHINA'S ECONOMIC GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT How Africa's Petroleum Supply Is Important to China's Economic Growth and Development While China continues to grow, its oil demand is poised to grow rapidly. For China to ensure its oil security, it must obtain oil from the global world because it lacks adequate domestic resources to quench the thirsty appetite of the country's rapid economic development. Any approach for growth that the country

  • China and Globalization Three Research Questions on

    China and Globalization THREE RESEARCH QUESTIONS ON FACTORS INFLUENCING CHINA'S RISE TO SUPERPOWER STATUS In evaluating China's prospects for achieving superpower status, especially during this economic crisis, the first research question would take into consideration whether and to what degree the United States is in decline as a superpower, and if it is, then whether China is simply going to achieve superpower status by default. This is what happened to the British

  • Challenging the Beijing Consensus China Foreign Policy in the 21st...

    Foreign Policy of China (Beijing consensus) Structure of Chinese Foreign Policy The "Chinese Model" of Investment The "Beijing Consensus" as a Competing Framework Operational Views The U.S.-China (Beijing consensus) Trade Agreement and Beijing Consensus Trading with the Enemy Act Export Control Act. Mutual Defense Assistance Control Act Category B Category C The 1974 Trade Act. The Operational Consequences of Chinese Foreign Policy The World Views and China (Beijing consensus) Expatriates The Managerial Practices Self Sufficiency of China (Beijing consensus) China and western world: A comparison The China (Beijing

  • Influence of 2007 Economic Crisis on American Car Market

    2007 Economic Crisis on American Car market Effect of the 2008 global economic crisis on automotive industries Crisis in the United States Crisis in Canada Crisis in Russia Crisis in European markets Crisis in Asian markets Effects by other related crisis events In this paper, we will review the effects of 2008 global automotive crisis. Our main focus will be on the American car manufacturers and the negative impact they suffered due to the crisis. We will

  • Power of China From the

    We must not forget, however, that, like most countries, China's economic leaps are tied to her political security. China's new model shows the world that economic security is as important as military security. Presently, though, based on the economic and political model of the world, China is focused on domestic economic issues and a slow but steady rise to socio-political power and role as a strategic player in global

  • U S Automotive Industry Chosen Industry Automotive Industry

    U.S. Automotive Industry Chosen industry: automotive industry is the focus of this analysis. More emphasizes are made on the large -- scale automobile manufacturers. This is because of the inherently interesting industry as a result it being competitive and projected to go through a major restructuring due to globalization in the near days to come. The issue of decreasing oil reserves is the other reason that is going to trigger this

  • Colonization of Africa The Occupation

    Imperialism and African Colonization: Imperialism is empire building and occurs when one state is more powerful than the other state's obstacles (such as peoples, geographic obstacles, physical obstacles and technological obstacles) to expansion. Imperialism became a popular cause for the first time in Western countries in the 1890s due to a significant degree by propaganda that sought to make nationalism and imperialism popular (Pieterse par, 2). Towards the end of the


Read Full Research Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved