Conflicting Studies On The Attitude Article Review

Another concern is the lengthiness of the survey -- 35 items -- that may have fatigued some of the respondents and may have resulted in rushed and insufficient care in answering the questions.

Furthermore, attributions may have been incorrectly placed. The participant, too, may have erred due to subjective bias (i.e. A 'falling out' with the principal may have led her to incorrectly accusing administrator of reluctance to integrate); furthermore, few teachers would readily admit to negative attitudes in integrating children, teachers may over-rate or under-rate their abilities (as, for instance, with the question: "I find that my knowledge about teaching pupils with physical disabilities in PE class is satisfactory"), and teachers may have deliberately or unwittingly deviated in order to protect their identity and their identity of the school.

Finally, although the survey was built on earlier studies of inclusion, it would be interesting to know amongst which population these surveys were held. Differences in condition might call for different questions.

My concerns with Spencer-Cavaliere and Watkinson (2010) include the smallness of the sample (only 11 children). The same limitations as are applicable to all qualitative studies exist here, too, namely that the perspectives of the authors may have infiltrated the study with interpretation of data or interactions with the children being two possibilities amongst other means of possible corruption.

Interviewer interferences may, also, exist here (i.e. The characteristics of the interviewer may have inhibited children or caused them to respond in a particular manner). Other possible confounding elements include the manner in which the questions were asked, the tenor of the questions, whether -- and to which extent they were understood, and how honest and open the children were in responding. Even though they seemed honest enough, children may have been driven by peer influences to respond in a certain manner, or their response may have been impelled by their particular mood (or tiredness) at that particular moment.

The mean age, too, is centered around 10 years, a period in...

...

Peer pressure is a huge challenge at this age, and peer competition may be an enormous threat, when middle school individuals may strive their utmost to conform to the mean of the group rather than deviate from it in any way. Perspective of slights may have been exaggerated; they may have been unintended or non-existent in the first place. Hormonal and physical changes occurs during this stage causing a confusion because of imbalance between what their bodies feel and between their maturity level. In fact, it is during this period that children go through this most challenging and definitive period of all: adolescence, and for many this can be particularly traumatic and confusing (Pruitt, 2000). For that reason, a more diverse age sample, as well as large diversity and cross-sectional sample of children would have been helpful as well as providing a more balanced and, possibly, more accurate response.
Since cultural attitudes, too, play a part in perspective of disability; it would have been interesting to have sampled a population of children from diverse ethnic / cultural backgrounds.

Finally, as the researchers themselves point out, only two of the 11 participants were female, and almost half of the sample had cerebral palsy possibly lending itself to shared experience.

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Jerlinder, K., Danermark, B., & Gil, P. (2010). Swedish primary-school teachers' attitudes to inclusion - the case of PE and pupils with physical disabilities, European Journal of Special Needs Education, 25, 45 -- 57

Pruitt, D. (2000). Your adolescent: Emotional, behavioral, and cognitive development from early adolescence through the teen years. Washington, DC: American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

Spencer-Cavaliere, N. & Watkinson, E.J. (2010). Inclusion Understood From the Perspectives of Children With Disability, Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 27, 275-293

The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) (2007). Promoting the Rights of Children with Disabilities Innocenti Digest No. 13


Cite this Document:

"Conflicting Studies On The Attitude" (2011, February 23) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/conflicting-studies-on-the-attitude-4535

"Conflicting Studies On The Attitude" 23 February 2011. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/conflicting-studies-on-the-attitude-4535>

"Conflicting Studies On The Attitude", 23 February 2011, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/conflicting-studies-on-the-attitude-4535

Related Documents

Part One The primary theoretical models of conflict include the cooperative model, principled negotiation, human needs model, conflict transformation, and conflict transmutation (Dixit, 2004). Theoretical bases for conflict resolution include both macro-level and micro-level frameworks that guide understanding of human behavior and decision-making (Cunningham, 1998). Many theories of conflict resolution at some point refer to human needs theory, which helps clarify sources of conflict as being traceable to unmet needs. Conflict

" (Halpin and Burt, 1998) DuBois states: "The history of the American Negro is the history of this strife -- this longing to attain self-conscious manhood, to merge his double self into a better and truer self. In this merging he wishes neither of the older selves to be lost. He would not Africanize America, for America has too much to teach the world and Africa. He would not bleach

The other person will feel inferior; the complex will increase from having a feeling of injustice. In this way you will turn to be a hard task master than a cooperative Boss who tends to understand the people and their abilities. 3.5. Conciliatory Approach: This is the approach that helps in retaining the long-term relations where sometimes you agree with people and sometimes make them agree with you. Human behavior has

Conflict in the Workplace: While not all conflict is negative, conflict is an inevitable aspect of the modern business life and working environment because where there are people, there is conflict. When considered as a positive measure, conflict in some workplaces can be regarded as healthy since it is an opportunity for the business to effect positive change. On the contrary, unhealthy conflict can also occur in the workplace when it

Conflict in DRC (Case Study) Conflict in DRC Conflict in the Democratic Republic of Congo Background of DRC Conflict The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), otherwise also known as Republique Democratique du Congo from their French masters and formerly Zaire is a nation situated in Central Africa boasting of a very brief coastline that runs approximately 37 Kms. DRC is the third largest country in the entire Africa and stands at 12th position in

Conflict Management and Negotiation, Case 8 Sick Leave Kelly, Mark and Suzanne -- two Canadians and a British citizens, respectively -- are working as Assistant Language Teachers (ALTs) within the Japan Exchange and Teaching Program (JET) in Soto, Japan. In an effort to improve the English education standards used in Japanese schools, the national government designed the JET program to facilitate the exchange of English teachers from international locales. Government agencies