Criminal Justice - Evaluations Evaluation essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

Under the stewardship of Police Commissioner Howard Safir, the NYPD began analyzing daily crime statistics collected from its 40,000 officers throughout the five boroughs of New York City and generating computer modeling of crime trends in a system dubbed CompStat that allowed the accurate identification of crime trends with pinpoint accuracy, often permitting nearly as precise predictive modeling via extrapolation (Safir, 2003).

The other main benefit and purpose of CompStat was that is enabled police administrators to grade the performance of every precinct according to any criteria defined by policy considerations. That aspect of CompStat is relied upon heavily by NYPD administration to the extent that Commissioner Safir reassigned, removed, or demoted fifty-four precinct commanders during his tenure as commissioner between 1996 and 2000 (Safir, 2003). Naturally, the technical means of data collection and analysis techniques differ quite profoundly from those available to previous generations of police administrators, but the actual methodology of the CompStat system is very similar, in principle, to the original pin mapping in use for almost a century and a half throughout modern municipal police organizations worldwide (Schmalleger, 2008).

The Problem with Evaluation via Objective Crime Statistics:

Ideally, crime mapping and predictive modeling also provide police administrators with purely objective data enabling evaluations that are immune from subjective contamination to whatever extent those data are relied upon for evaluations.

Whereas the principle weakness of narrative supervisory evaluations is their subjective nature, the corresponding weakness inherent in the objective results-oriented evaluation made possible by computer-enhanced, up-to-date, pinpoint analyses of crime in each precinct or command area lies in the manipulation of data prior to its entry into the system (Conlon, 2004).

For example, the fact that police administrators used CompStat to identify poorly performing precincts led to numerous instances of deliberate data manipulation, such as in the form of enforcement instructions issued to patrol officers. Specifically, if borough commanders or precinct captains faced negative evaluations and supervisory criticism by virtue of CompStat data indicating high rates of robbery in their areas of command, they learned to tailor their enforcement commands to manipulate the data in their favor (Conlon, 2004).

Typical examples included borough-wide instructions to apply very stringent technicalities to differentiate robbery from petit larceny based on statutory minutia that allowed crimes that had previously almost always been categorized as robberies to be entered into the system as lesser offences. In many cases, outright thefts from persons were downgraded to instances of "abandoned property" infuriating crime victims whose wallets had been snatched from a park bench, but without explicit threats of violence or intimidation that would have met the strictest technical definition of "robbery." The practice become so rampant that NYPD officers came to refer to the CompStat system as "ConStat"(Conlon, 2004).


Because of the potential inadequacies and error inherent in both narrative supervisory review and objective crime mapping methodologies, their advantages are best employed in conjunction with each other rather than relied upon exclusively.



In that regard, a fundamental approach detailed by Dr. W. Dean Lee, the current head of the Organizational Program Evaluation and Analysis Unit at the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) headquarters in Washington, DC. According to Dr. Lee, the most reliable approach to program evaluations consists of a complex analysis of all the elements represented in the figure below, but from right to left, in order to identify specific program and performance goals in terms of their ultimate objectives (Lee. 2007).

The advantage of the comprehensive evaluation system detailed by Dr. Lee is that it addresses every conceivable variable while incorporating the advantages of the other models of police and criminal justice administration. Ultimately, the hope is that the model advanced by Dr. Lee will eventually be combined with the beneficial elements of narrative supervisory review and predictive modeling via crime mapping into computerized formats that allow for the seamless integration of different evaluation methodologies.


Coleman, J.L., Thomas, C.C. (2002). Operational Mid-Level Management for Police. Illinois: Springfield.

Conlon, E. (2004). Blue Blood. New York: Riverhead.

Lee, W.D. (2007). Program Evaluations: Improving Operational Effectiveness and Organizational Efficiency; FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin (Nov/07 Vol. 76

No. 11, pp. 1-6).

Safir, H. (2003). Security: An Inside Look at the Tactics of the NYPD. New…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Criminal Justice - Evaluations Evaluation" (2008, November 15) Retrieved December 9, 2016, from

"Criminal Justice - Evaluations Evaluation" 15 November 2008. Web.9 December. 2016. <>

"Criminal Justice - Evaluations Evaluation", 15 November 2008, Accessed.9 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Criminal Justice Trends the Trends of the

    Criminal Justice Trends The trends of the past, present and future that outline the borders connecting the criminal justice system components and their links adjoining the society is, beyond doubt, an authentic relationship that the law and society have established. Criminal justice has been affected by various trends in the times gone by. This is because trends keep changing with the passage of time. Therefore, it is exceedingly important for the

  • Criminal Acts and Choice Theory Plays and

    Criminal Acts and Choice Choice theory plays and important aspect when accessing reasons contributing to criminal activities. The importance of the theory assist in coming up with strategies for reducing criminal activities. The importance of an understanding to the theory comes out from the contribution that the theory stands to give. It is vital to learn how the theory bears upon the chance that someone will take up or even attempt

  • Justice and Security Free Balance in the

    Justice and Security Free Balance in the Administration of Justice and Security Justice and Security policies have always been at the center of international politics, but their nature has changed due to the advent of nuclear weapons and their proliferation, economic interdependence, the end of the Cold War, environmental problems, technological advancements and vulnerabilities, as well as other material and cultural developments typically linked to globalization. This paper will talk about the

  • Justice Crime and Ethics

    Justice, Crime and Ethics Prepping the President: Ethical Analysis and Future Policy Initiatives Suggesting the Use of Rehabilitation in Corrections The President of the United States has just scheduled a town hall meeting entitled, "Criminal Justice Ethics: Today's News and Tomorrow's Solutions." Many of the country's most interested individuals in the field of criminal justice's present ethical issues are attending the meeting and expect to be informed on the status of some of

  • UN Millennium Development Goals Evaluation

    Goals Adopted by the UN in the year 2000, the UN Millennium Development Goals, in the words of Hopper (2012, 13), sought to synthesize "the various declarations and targets from the numerous international summits and conferences held during the 1990s." Commonly referred to as the MDGs, the Millennium Development Goals are eight in number. They include: "eradicate extreme poverty and hunger; achieve universal primary education; promote gender equality and empower

  • Use and Value of Performance Evaluations

    Value of Performance Evaluations Some people think of the performance evaluation as little more than a waste of time. They believe that given that they are mandatory and generally completed in a relatively short period of time, performance evaluations fail to capture an employee's true performance or give the employee meaningful feedback that would enable him or her to improve performance. As a result, many have suggested that the performance

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved