Era Vs. New Deal Progressivism Essay

Still, he remained eager to balance the budget -- although his attempts to do so in 1937, accompanied with the Federal Reserve Bank's decision to raise interest rates and thus discourage borrowing and investment on the part of citizens and businesses caused the nation to spiral into recession once again (Norton 705). Some of Roosevelt's programs did seem more like direct extensions of Progressive Era programs, such as Social Security. Just like the progressives had a particular interest in protecting the most defenseless of society, including children and disabled workers, Roosevelt supported the idea that people who worked for their entire lives and supported the American system should receive something back in kind (Norton 697). But Social Security was a government-administered, but privately 'paid' entitlement, not a pension as is sometimes given in more progressive, European liberal states today. Perhaps Roosevelt's Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) project was really more progressive -- bringing science and the benefits of technology to an underserved rural population so they could enjoy in the comforts of the rest of the nation.

In terms of which movement seems more attractive, both suited their ages. The Progressive Movement was a response to an overly complacent attitude regarding the abuses of capitalism by the middle and upper classes that were enjoying industrialism's consumer benefits, but suffering none of its ills like the workers. In...

...

Franklin Delano Roosevelt diagnosed the problem with the American economy as fear, hence his famous phrase that 'The only thing we have to fear is fear itself.' People were afraid of losing their jobs, so they did not spend, which caused businesses to lay off workers, generating more unemployment. Roosevelt wanted to curtail fear, not stimulate outrage and anger like the radical progressives.
Roosevelt's moderate reforms that got workers working again and injected capital back into the banking system under tight regulation was what the nation needed to revive its capitalist system. Roosevelt, unlike the progressives, was not just responding to a humanitarian crisis of injustice, but a great systemic crisis that threatened global economic and political stability. He was also the President of the United States, working from inside the system. The radical movements of the progressives were striving to change the system and shake its foundation. During the Great Depression, however, the system could withstand no more 'shaking' and the people of America, starving and desperate, could not either.

Works Cited

Norton, Mary Beth. A People and a Nation. 7th Edition. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2008.

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Norton, Mary Beth. A People and a Nation. 7th Edition. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2008.


Cite this Document:

"Era Vs New Deal Progressivism" (2009, February 20) Retrieved April 20, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/era-vs-new-deal-progressivism-24664

"Era Vs New Deal Progressivism" 20 February 2009. Web.20 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/era-vs-new-deal-progressivism-24664>

"Era Vs New Deal Progressivism", 20 February 2009, Accessed.20 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/era-vs-new-deal-progressivism-24664

Related Documents

" But, was that what the New Deal promised - to solve all America's social problems? Not at all; in fact, the New Deal was initiated to a) help pull America out of the Great Depression, which it did; b) to put people back to work, some kind of temporary work at least, to give them dignity and food on the table, which it did; c) to help rebuild infrastructure, roads,

Minimizing Poverty Is a Government Initiative The Progressive Era Poverty reduction has remained a central debate in periodical democratic societies. Schemes have been established to enable citizens to be economically viable either at paid-employment or self-employment level. Activists, philosophers, and politicians have suggested technical, liberal, and legal approaches towards poverty eradication. In fact, most of the debate in relation to the field of poverty examines whether poverty is a natural phenomenon associated

The progressive era in American political culture set the stage for President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal. Starting in the 1890s, the Progressive Era drew upon Marxist theory of labor exploitation to help balance unbridled capitalist growth during the Gilded Age of industrial development. Progressivism welcomed social and technological progress both by suggesting reforms in both government and business to reduce corruption and ensure a higher quality of life for all

U.S. History The History of the United States Discuss America's place in the world just before and then a change after WWII. Explain how and why America got into WWII? What shaped American foreign policy after that and what were the effects of the Truman Doctrine on the beginnings of the Cold War in the late 1940's? How did a policy of containment work at home and abroad? What did former CIA

U.S. History America As a
PAGES 5 WORDS 1328

Concurrently, while the agrarian sector and movements suffered from the effects of urbanization and the nation's laissez faire form of government, cities flourished as more and more economic progress happened in the area of industrialization. New technology allowed new industries to flourish; increased immigration made possible the increasing mandate of political groups and movements and policies that supported the path towards industrialization and urbanization. Railroads became a cause for faster

Political Science History
PAGES 23 WORDS 6252

conservative intellectual movement, but also the role of William Buckley and William Rusher in the blossoming of the youth conservative movement Talk about structure of paper, who not strictly chronologically placed (ie hayek before the rest) - in this order for thematic purposes, to enhance the genuiness of the paper (branches of the movement brought up in order of importance to youth conservative revolt) For instance, Hayek had perhaps the