Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Ethics and Experimentation
Ethics and Medical Experimentation
On Staten Island there was an institution for the mentally disabled which operated from 1947 to 1987, but in the period from 1956 through 1971, children at the institution were used for experiments involving hepatitis. Although the experiments are considered to be successful, the involvement of mentally disabled children has brought many ethical considerations to the forefront. Dr. Saul Krugman, the man who ran the experiment, stated that his team took a number of ethical considerations into question before the experiment began. Firstly, Krugman rationalized the use of children by stating that "It is recognized that infectious hepatitis is a much milder disease in children." (Robinson 81) Then, a mild form of the disease was inflicted upon the children under conditions that were the most favorable including special medical personnel and isolation quarters. Krugman specifically stated that only children who's parents consented were used in the experiment and that the level of pathogen used would start small and be increased gradually, but only if there were no serious adverse effects. In short, the scientists involved rationalized their behavior because the experiment "began with...
Even though the scientists performed the experiment with what they considered to be the strictest ethical considerations, there were still some highly questionable acts performed. Firstly, it was the 1950's and there were not the kinds of programs available for mentally disabled children and their families, so most parents were unable to cope with the situation. Therefore, the parents of these children were desperate for some place to put their children and Willowbrook was one of the few places for them; thus the available spaces were few. Parents would do just about anything to get their children into the school, even allow them to be experimented on. Secondly, the parents were not given the specifics of the experiment, nor told how dangerous it could be. They gave their consent, but it was not informed consent. But he most ethically questionable aspect of the experiment is that they used children who were considered to be expendable. At best, hepatitis is still an highly infectious disease and even though mild forms were used, there was still the chance of some of the…
References
Rivers, Eunice, et al. "Twenty Years of Follow-up Experience in a Long-Range
Medical Study." Public Health Reports 68.4 (April 1953). Web. 30 Mar. 2013.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/pmc2024012/
Robinson, Walter, Brandon Unruh. "The Hepatitis Experiments and the Willowbrook
http://science.jburroughs.org/mbahe/BioEthics/Articles/
Ethical Theory Despite the fact that codes of conduct and belief systems permeate everyone's life on an everyday basis, developing a universally acceptable concept of ethics or moral philosophy remains a seemingly impossible task that has plagued philosophers and the world's great thinkers since the beginning of time. Over time a great number of different philosophical theories have arise. Each one has its strengths and weaknesses and each has enjoyed its
Ethical Theories The three basic ethical theories share a number of similarities, because they each attempt to describe and explicate the ethical decisions made by humans as well as the logic (or illogic) that is used to inform any particular behavior. Utilitarianism offers what is perhaps the most sound ethical theory due to the way it chooses for itself the goal of its efforts, but it is hampered by disagreement regarding
Consequently, the underlying concept regarding the two different arguments is the actual point for the beginning of life. Through the application of several ethical theories, stem cell research is unethical because of the following reasons: Respect to All Persons: Based on the utilitarian ethical theory or principle, stem cell research is unethical because it violates the need to respect all individuals and provide the greatest happiness to many people. The emergence
Ethical Theories Describe in detail Teleological, deontological, and virtue ethics: A comparison Teleological ethics are also called consequence-based ethics. Teleological ethical systems emphasize the results of ethical decisions, versus the moral principles behind such decisions. Utilitarianism is an excellent example of teleological ethics. The stress in utilitarianism is doing the greatest good for the greatest number of people, versus setting a precedent for all ethical actions. "It denies that moral rightness depends directly
So long as the employees are aware of the potential on-the-job dangers, which they must be simply by having been hired, they have the right to choose whether or not to work long hours or to wear protective gear. A person who enters an automobile does so knowing that highway accidents are common; a bicycle rider who does not wear a helmet makes s similar choice. To deny the
Ethical Theory and Moral Practice developed as a cohesive field in the late twentieth century, with the establishment of the Ethical Theory and Moral Practice Journal, in 1998. The theory therefore represents a culmination of scholarly thought and analysis in the fields of philosophy, sociology, and psychology. As a cross-disciplinary theory, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice reveals the increasing hybridization of fields that relate to normative ethics. Because Ethical Theory and