Europe and Africa Understanding the Emergence of Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Europe and Africa

Understanding the Emergence of 'Ethnicity' and the Nation-State

The historical emergence of ethnicities and nation-states in Europe and in Africa is continually questioned and re-interpreted by historians, sociologists, anthropologists, and mass media. Depending on the perspective of the author and the intention of the narrative, ethnicity can be seen as a colonial construct or as an inherent cultural identity through which more similarities with other ethnicities may be noted than differences. However, because of political persuasion and imperialistic practices, especially in the modern era, ethnic emergence has been viewed as something disparate from nationhood. Bruce J. Berman, for example, quotes Samora Machel, "leader of one of the most radically modernist African regimes," as asserting, "For the nation to live, the tribe must die'" (Berman 306). This paper will analyze the play between ethnicity and nationhood, and ultimately show how we can compare the historical emergence of ethnicities and nation-states in Europe with those in Africa.

Carola Lentz observes that ethnicity is a problem that "cannot simply be explained away, neither with modernization theories about stubborn but dying relics of pre-modern mentalities nor neo-Marxist concepts of 'false consciousness'" (Lentz 303). To support her assertion, Lentz cites the "ethno-nationalist movements in post-Communist Eastern Europe" (303) and other exercises in ethnic cleansing that continue to this day. What Lentz implies is that ethnicity and tribalism are not characteristics specific to Africa but are, rather, illustrative of European culture as well. Indeed, the emergence of ethnicity in Europe and in Africa may be directly related to the emergence of nation-states (through power plays) precisely because of the use of the term ethnicity. As Lentz states, "Classifying the most diverse historical forms of social identity as 'ethnic' creates the scientifically questionable but politically useful impression that all ethnicities are basically the same and that ethnic identity is a natural trait of persons and social groups" (Lentz 305). In other words, usage of the term ethnicity has very observable political and social ramifications, but scientifically speaking it is too often used interchangeably with the term tribe.

The importance of understanding the impact of the term ethnicity helps illuminate the issue of ethnic and nation-state emergence. The term itself stems from the ancient Greek term ethnos, which Lentz notes "was above all a political category" (Lentz 305). Gradually, however, as more and more authors began to employ the use of the term, it began to take on different connotations. For example, the Greek philosopher (and tutor of Alexander) Aristotle employed the term when speaking of "both Greek and non-Greek segmentary societies"; and with the advent of Christianity, the term takes on a religious dimension when it "stands for 'heathen', and the adjective derived from it, ethnikos, for 'barbarian' and 'uncivilized'" (Lentz 305). Therefore, the concept of ethnic emergence (whether in Africa or in Europe) is dependent upon perspectives -- whether religious, political, social, or economic. Ethnicity, in other words, is a construct that can be used both to unite and separate. As Lentz observes, after all, ethnicity may "refer equally to Old Testament Canaanites, early medieval Normans and modern-day Basques and Sikhs" thereby making it "no great feat to claim" continuity between ethnicities of old and the nation-states of today (Lentz 305).

Yet, identifying the emergence of ethnicity and nationhood in Europe and in Africa is also dependent upon identifying the ongoing history of both continents. For example, Thomas Spear identifies the Yoruba ethnicity as a distinct creation of the Yoruba peoples themselves. However, despite the fact that "it took place before colonial conquest, and…was articulated by Yoruba linguists and historians who formulated a distinctive Yoruba language, culture, history, politics and ethnicity" (Spear 21), the Yoruba ethnicity continued to evolve according to a wide range of influences that came from halfway round the world.

Thus, Spear could state that ethnicity is "both a historical process…and a process of historical representation, as ethnic identity asserts 'continuity despite change, across contexts' and collective identity facilitates 'common action by shared past experiences'" (Spear 21). In this light, the understanding of how ethnicities and nation-states have emerged in Europe and in Africa is much clearer: the play between ethnicity and nationhood also is situated in a recognizable context. When Samora Machel of Mozambique attests that tribalism must disappear for nationhood to rear its head, one may argue that his meaning is…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Europe And Africa Understanding The Emergence Of" (2012, April 06) Retrieved October 26, 2016, from

"Europe And Africa Understanding The Emergence Of" 06 April 2012. Web.26 October. 2016. <>

"Europe And Africa Understanding The Emergence Of", 06 April 2012, Accessed.26 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Emergence of Colonial Resistance in Things Fall Apart

    Things Fall Apart Chinua Achebe is one of the most influential and powerful writers of today, and he is also one of the most widely published writers today. Chinua Achebe has in fact written more than twenty-one novels, and short stories, and books of poetry as well, and his very first landmark work was "Things Fall apart," which was published in the year 1958, when the author was just twenty-eight years

  • Economics Emergence of the Modern

    The process would take centuries, but by Elizabethan times it had surely begun. Serfdom had all but disappeared from England, and money rents and wages had largely replaced other forms of compensation and exchange. The new importance of trade contributed to a profound change in attitudes, one that was beginning to re-shape society itself. In 1579, Thomas Churchyard defined as nobles, "Merchauntes that sail forrain countreys," a statement that

  • European Union Member States Relations With Their Overseas Territories...

    political framework of EU and OCT European Union (EU) and Overseas Countries and Territories (OCTs) are in association with each other via a system which is based on the provisions of part IV of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU), consisting of detailed rules and measures which are laid down in the document issued on 27th November 2001 title Oversees Association Decision. The expiry date of this

  • Chinese and European Development Programs

    The analysis provided is thorough and bias at the same time. However, Armstrong provides a valuable background and policy analysis. In terms of the relations between Ghana and its major donors, China and the EU, Giles Mohan writes a comprehensive overview of the relations Ghana has with China and the potential political and economic interests that may drive China to indeed become a crucial donor for Ghana. More precisely, the

  • Archaeological Interpretations of Upper Paleolithic Cave Paintings...

    Archaeological Interpretations of Upper Paleolithic Cave Paintings There are many questions related to the chronological spread of Paleolithic tool production and paintings due to geographical differences in the progress of the spread of such tool production. While radiocarbon dating has furthered the ability to identify specific time period information there are still limitations to this type of data. There has been loose identification of chronological periods of production and in

  • Music & Skimmington Riots an

    In this regard, when wage levels fell in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, the standard of living for laborers and cottagers in England declined precipitously and they were compelled to use the majority of their cash, garden crops, and milk just to buy bread and clothing (Kulikoff 2000:19). Not surprisingly, many of these workers found it almost impossible in some cases to even survive, even with the

  • China the New Neo Imperialist Power

    China's massive growth over the last two decades has brought with it a similarly explosive need for energy resources, a need that as of yet cannot be fulfilled by domestic reserves. Thus, China imported 3.5 million barrels of oil per day in 2006, and that number is expected to increase to 13.1 million barrels per day by 2030 (Hanson 2008). Subsequently, "as the world's second-largest consumer of oil, and with

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved