Iraq War Humanitarian Intervention No News Item Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

Iraq War: Humanitarian Intervention?

No news item garners more interest and more debate today in America and around the world than the impending second war against Iraq. President George Bush led a coalition in a war against Iraq over a decade ago after Iraq's leader, Saddam Hussein, attacked and overran the small princely state of Kuwait.

Coalition forces "drew a line in the sand" and forced Saddam Hussein's forces out of Kuwait. Of course, the popular mandate at the time was a liberation of Kuwait, but truly the only rallying cry could have been sovereignty, as the Kuwaiti people - subjects of a princely state - were anything but liberated according to the de Toquevillian version of liberation and democracy under which American and its allies function.

Today, a similar situation has reared its head. After prosecuting a war on terror in Afghanistan, the Philippines, Bali and other distant locales, President George W. Bush and Prime Minister Tony Blair have set their sights unerringly on yet another war in Iraq under the rallying cry of both a war against terrorism and a war for humanitarian intervention.

The subject of this paper is not the war against terror and its merits in Iraq, but the humanitarian intervention prong. Coalition forces - primarily Britain, the United States and Spain - have been urging the United Nations to understand the vast human oppressions Saddam Hussein allegedly has inflicted, is inflicting and will continue to inflict upon his own people. The coalition is asking the United Nations for a general mandate to stop such oppression through force.

However, the humanitarian intervention argument crumbles when placed against the analysis constructed by Richard Falk in "Human Rights Horizons." Falk writes:

This conceptual effort to sort out the issues associated with humanitarian emergencies induced by governmental failure must contend with two further sets of conditions. First of all, an unresolved internal struggle among various factions or regions to reconstitute governmental authority frequently gives rise to the perception that external actors, whether under the auspices of the United Nations or not, are taking sides. This pattern complicated, and some say doomed, the latter phases of the Somalia operation in 1993-94. Second, external actors have been accused of reconstituting governmental authority in a manner that confers benefits on them, a process that seemed to occur in Kuwait after the Gulf War, when lucrative construction contracts were awarded to foreign firms from the main intervening states. In both instances, it can be seen that sovereignty, in its negative aspects, is not necessarily suspended by governmental failure.

In other words, competing factions in a state must clearly be mapped out and understood before any humanitarian intervention can be successful. There are several competing factions within Iraq, as there were in Afghanistan before the coalition forces occupied it.

However, the situation in Iraq is different, as no clear leader has been chosen or has stepped forward to institute humanitarian governing after Saddam Hussein is deposed. In Afghanistan, Hamid Karzai stepped forward and was supported by the coalition forces.

Falk would argue that humanitarian intervention will collapse without a solid plan for further rule in Iraq. Falk also argues that "prevailing international morality is generally respectful towards territorial sovereignty." Here, Falk implies that even though Iraq's human rights schema may seems sub-par to Americans - even unto accusations that Saddam Hussein gasses his own people and will use chemical weapons against the Kurdish minority again if given the chance - Iraq is a sovereign nation, and may act as it pleases within its own borders.

Even though the coalition forces may feel that they have a mandate to enter Iraq's sovereignty and impose a new government, Falk would caution that morality is actually on the side of sovereignty and a healthy distance from humanitarian intervention.

But there is some support for a war of humanitarian intervention in Iraq in the United Nations Charter: "The Charter of the Untied Nations (1945) begins by reaffirming a faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women and of nations large and small."

Under this construct, the coalition forces, if they can prove that Saddam Hussein is not respecting human rights in Iraq, may have a better argument to interfere with Iraq's territorial sovereignty. However, the proof is essential. But once that proof is established, a strong coalition and the support of the United…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Iraq War Humanitarian Intervention No News Item" (2003, March 13) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/iraq-war-humanitarian-intervention-no-145455

"Iraq War Humanitarian Intervention No News Item" 13 March 2003. Web.7 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/iraq-war-humanitarian-intervention-no-145455>

"Iraq War Humanitarian Intervention No News Item", 13 March 2003, Accessed.7 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/iraq-war-humanitarian-intervention-no-145455

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Post War Iraq a Paradox in the Making Legitimacy vs Legality

    Post War Iraq: A Paradox in the Making: Legitimacy vs. legality The regulations pertaining to the application of force in International Law has transformed greatly from the culmination of the Second World War, and again in the new circumstances confronting the world in the aftermath of the end of the Cold War. Novel establishments have been formed, old ones have withered away and an equally enormous quantity of intellectual writing has

  • Post Conflict Peace Nation Building in Iraq

    This includes putting in place international legal systems, dispute resolution mechanisms as well as cooperative arrangements.14 The call this approach social peace-building or structural peace-building. Such peace-building involves "creating structures -- systems of behavior, institutions, concerted actions -- that support the embodiment or implementation of a peace culture."15 This is what the author's call multi-track diplomacy. It involves individuals who are not normally involved in the peace process, particularly business

  • Army Structure From 3 Brigade Division Units to

    Army Structure; from 3-Brigade Division Units to Units of Action At the Pentagon, briefings routinely begin with the old adage that "the only thing constant today is change." Since the age of the Cold War, the United States Army has faced change at home and abroad, experiencing not only a massive transformation in technology and infrastructure, but also in the worldwide approach to warfare. As the end of front-line battles gave

  • Disciple Maker s Message in All Likelihood

    The interpretation of "spiritual truths" can largely influence how a disseminator selects a particular message, and can also be a particular lesson taught to disciples -- to aid them in their own ability to interpret spiritual understanding. This intrinsic sense of what is necessary to be communicated to an audience (Mitchell, 2010) should also be taught to an audience itself, so that it can understand and become closer to

  • International Political Economics The Impacts

    Despite offering particular benefits to post-conflict nations, increased levels of help following civil war also comes with negative upshots that entails a rise in fraud and jeopardizing one of the basic objectives of peacekeeping. Corruption affects the peacebuilding process, institutions and people in a given nation. For instance in Herzegovina and Bosnia, corruption affected the operation of Bosnian judicial institutions (Kahler, 2013). Moreover, the strategy adapted to address fraud in

  • Inter Parliamentary Union and Its Role

    8). Likewise, the Institute of Agriculture required a quorum of two-thirds of its members for voting purposes and for the balancing of votes according to the size of the budgetary contributions (Bowett, 1970). While this analysis of these early forms of public international unions is not complete, it does suggest that they were beginning to identify the wide range of interests involved in modern international commerce and what was required

  • Guantanamo Bay

    Guantanamo Bay and the United States History of Guantanamo Bay, and the U.S. Involvement with Guantanamo Bay The Legality of the U.S. Occupation of Guantanamo Bay Why Do the U.S. Hold Guantanamo Bay? The Legal Position Regarding the U.S. Being in Guantanamo Bay Recent Events at Guantanamo Bay: Camp X-Ray and Camp Delta The Legal Position Regarding Events at U.S. Camps in Guantanamo Bay The Geneva Convention and Guantanamo Bay In the last two years the U.S. naval


Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved