Nonhuman Animal Studies Animal Testing Research Paper

Download this Research Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Research Paper:

UK legislation requires that researchers refine their procedures to keep suffering to the minimum, ensure the number of animals is reduced to the minimum required for meaningful results, and seek to replace the use of animals with non-animal alternatives where appropriate" (the Royal Society, 2004). This argument is valid from the point-of-view of the necessity of animal testing. The attempts to reduce the pain and discomfort of animals are significant for their added value to science. That is to say that even the research conducted to limit the discomfort can provide important information for scientists.

Some of the most common animals on which tests are being conducted are the monkeys that are considered to be relatively close in terms of structure and behavior to humans. Therefore, the question is often related to the ethical and moral nature of testing on monkeys. However, in terms of the added value provided by the information retrieved from tests, a cure for the Parkinson disease for instance was developed as a result of such tests (Ringach, 2011). As per the Americans for Medical Progress, "In the past few years, Parkinson's research has advanced to the point that halting disease progression and even preventing Parkinson's are considered realistic goals" (2012)

Depending on the type of animals used for laboratory testing, the advantages for this practice are varied. The major convenient for animal testing is related to the short life span of the animals. More precisely, "Rodents are the animal model of choice for modern medical researchers because they have a naturally short life span -- two to three years -- that allows scientists to observe in "fast forward" what happens during the progress or pathogenesis of a disease."(Trull, n.d.) This comes to point out that laboratory testing on animals do not necessarily imply or aim for short-term effects and conclusions, but rather they try to follow long-term effects that can afterwards be described and adjusted to human beings. The short life span of animals used for such testing ensures that medicine advances at a faster pace largely because it allows the possibility to observe immediate results as opposed to less painful yet longer in terms of duration for conclusions on certain tests.

The discussion over the moral nature of animal testing goes even further to stress that under certain conditions more analysis must be conducted in order to fully address all moral dilemmas. For instance, "consider a patient with severe aortic stenosis, which has a mortality rate of approximately 75% 5 years after diagnosis. The patient's life can be saved by replacing the valve in his heart with one from a pig. Is it morally permissible to carry out such a procedure? In some respects, we are facing a burning house scenario: it is either a pig or a human. Those that consider the moral status of the pig equal to that of the patient must effectively condemn the patient to death for the same reasons we would not take the heart valve of another human as a replacement" (Ringach, 2011). Therefore, the argument of equality between a human being and an animal, which has been often suggested in this type of debates, opens the door for more thorough analysis on the actual situation of the animal. Although animals tend to share the same existence as human beings, in a situation of choice, most likely an animal would be sacrificed to save a human life. From this point-of-view, the argument of equality cannot be always defended.

Conclusion

Despite the constant arguments between the representatives of the medical world and the organizations and individuals defending animal rights, there are obvious reasons to consider that the results of animal testing have significantly improved human health and well-being. Although we live in an ever changing and developing world, there are few substitutes for animal testing particularly because this type of testing allows the medical world to experience in a short period of time, all the necessary effects and side effects of certain medical drugs being tested, fact which provides information in a more rapid way. On the other hand, the discomfort and pain experienced by the animals is not to be neglected. Even so, the medical advancements have enabled the human being to save lives that would have otherwise be lost.

References

AAVVS (2012) "Problems with animal research" Accessed 02 November 2012, from http://www.aavs.org/site/c.bkLTKfOSLhK6E/b.6456997/k.3D74/Problems_with_Animal_Research.htm

Americans for Medical Progress (2012). "Animal Research Means Medical Progress." Accessed 02 November 2012, from http://www.amprogress.org/animal-research-benefits

Ringach, D. (2011). "The Use of Nonhuman Animals in Biomedical Research" the American Journal of the Medical Sciences, Vol 342, No 4.

The Royal Society. (2004) "The use of non-human animals in research: a guide for scientists." Accessed 02 November, 2012 from http://royalsociety.org/policy/publications/2004/non-human-animals/

Trull, F. (n.d.) "Animal-test research has saved many human lives" Accessed 02 November…[continue]

Cite This Research Paper:

"Nonhuman Animal Studies Animal Testing" (2012, November 03) Retrieved December 8, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/nonhuman-animal-studies-testing-76279

"Nonhuman Animal Studies Animal Testing" 03 November 2012. Web.8 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/nonhuman-animal-studies-testing-76279>

"Nonhuman Animal Studies Animal Testing", 03 November 2012, Accessed.8 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/nonhuman-animal-studies-testing-76279

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Animal Research Is a Necessity Today and

    Animal research is a necessity today, and has afforded us the opportunity to create lifesaving drugs and vaccines, new surgical procedures and improved diagnosis of disease. Despite the bad press animal activists have given, institutions are given guidelines that guarantee the safe and ethical treatment of research animals. Most scientists agree that continued animal testing is essential to develop new vaccines and medicines, and that computer and mathematical models are

  • Omnivore s Dilemma

    Omnivore's Dilemma The research question to be approached in this paper: Is there a link between morality and vegetarianism? The answer is: Yes there is a link between ethics and moral values when it comes to substituting healthy vegetables for meat raised in hideously unclean, unhealthy, inhumane conditions. Thesis: More Americans are turning away from red meat because of the appalling conditions under which cattle are raised and slaughtered on factory

  • Ape Speech Research Has Been

    Another theorist with a different view is Chomsky (1988). Chomsky sees the acquisition of language as a process of input-output, what he calls a Cartesian view of language acquisition and language structure. He states: "We have an organism of which we know nothing. We know, or we can discover, what kind of data is available to it, and the first question we must try to answer is: what kind of

  • Ecofeminism In Search of Universal

    143). Moreover, the global neglect of women (in terms of science) is reflected in the fact that women have been excluded as experimental subjects in drug research, Rosser continues. Certainly pregnant women have been excluded from experiments with pesticides and radioactive materials, but beyond that Rosser explains that "…these drugs and materials are then used without ever having been tested on women" (1991, p. 143). And yet notwithstanding their exclusion

  • Huntington s Disease and Laboratory Investigation

    HD is extremely debilitating, and if the patient lives long enough, the symptoms can become extremely severe. It is not uncommon for patients who suffer from the disease to suffer extreme depression and sometimes suicide, so developing medications that could delay or slow the disease are extremely important, and laboratory testing should definitely continue in this area. Laboratory work in the past decades has helped develop a much deeper understanding

  • AIDS Immunity What Is AIDS

    Some of the illnesses linked with AIDS can be prevented or cured through other treatments ("What is the difference" par, 5). Symptoms of HIV / AIDS: Depending on the phase of the infection, the symptoms of HIV and AIDS vary. In early HIV infection, a person may have no signs or symptoms at all. Nonetheless, a person may develop a brief (two to four-week) flu-like illness when first infected with HIV.


Read Full Research Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved