Overrepresentation of Minorities in Special essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

Thus, the relation between students is imperative for determining such disorders (Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development, 2007). As with the previous two categories, this is seen as incredibly subjective in the idea that no medical diagnosis or visible physical symptoms are needed to be placed within the category.

Stratification.

Stratification is essentially the ranking of individuals within a hierarchy based on the structures present in a functioning society. Sullivan and Artiles (2011) define stratification as "the patterned and differential distribution of resources, life chances, and costs / benefits among groups of the population" (p 1529). One's rank on this hierarchy determines one's quality of life and opportunities in relation to the structures and the groups these structures serve.

Literature Review

Overrepresentation and Segregation of Racial Minorities in Special Education.

According to the research, there are much higher rates of overrepresentation of minorities in what is known as high-incidence categories, such as learning disabilities, emotional disabilities, and mental retardation (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011).

Sullivan and Artiles (2011) state that "these categories are regarded as the most subjective of the educational disabilities due to the reliance on professional judgment in identification as opposed to physical markers or medical diagnoses" (p 1527).

These more subjective categories become major sources of disporportionality because they rely so heavily on comparison to others in determining the presence of abnormalities (Anyon, 2009). As such, these categories are the most dominate in terms of how they "serve particular interests of individuals, institutions, and society" (Anyon, 2009, p 46). Essentially, these more mild categories of learning disabilities and conditions have invoked a strong negative response from researchers as tools for the further subjugation of racial groups here in a contemporary American society. This leads Blanchett (2010) to posit that "the American educational system has used mild disability special education categories to sort students on the basis of perceived disability, race, culture, language, and social class."

The general consensus in the discourse today is that minorities are much more represented in special education programs than their white counterparts. Various studies have focused on which particular minority group tends to be overrepresented in more specific areas. For example, African-American students are most often overrepresented in mental retardation and emotional disorders, where as Native American students have more issues with learning disabilities, and Latino and Asian students are often found to actually be underrepresented in these high-risk categories (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011). Not only do Native Americans face issues of being a minority group, they suffer from some of the worst cultural discrimination and misunderstandings, which makes life for students in special education programs even more difficult with fewer resources in small districts (O'Connell, 1987). Still, African-American students tend to have the worst overrepresentation in these subjective categories. Oswald et al. (1999) show that nationally, African-American students made up 16% of the student population in 1990, but over 21% of the student population in special education programs. This is clearly a disproportionate number when compared to general population of school districts across the country. Additional research conducted by Patton (1999) shows that African-American males are the worst minority group hit and make up the largest majority of minority students enrolled in special education programs. Research conducted by Ladner and Hammons (2006) shows that "in Virginia. African-Americans represent 20% of the state's population but 28% of its special education students, including 51% of those labeled educable mentally retarded" (p 86). There definitely needs to be better cultural considerations for students within the African-American minority group (Hollins & Spencer, 1990). Additionally, several studies have related a growing trend in minority poverty rates as being correlated with increasing overrepresentation in special education programs. Here, MacMillan and Reschly (1998) suggest that mental retardation rates in African-American students were seen to raise in correspondence with rising poverty rates for the minority group.

Gaps in Prior Research.

Unfortunately, there are clear gaps in the contemporary discourse that make this phenomenon still very much perplexing to researchers and potentially damaging to students. The research as a whole is generally incomplete, failing to look at more comprehensively at how regional and category patterns transcend into the larger shared problem. Studies examining the issue have previously been very limited, focusing on a specific concept rather than making larger assumptions that may help push towards reform of special education programs on a larger scale (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011).

Moreover, more recent studies show that not all minority groups have been studied in the same extent of detail. African-American students have been the predominate focus of prior research; however, this has left significant gaps in the understanding of how other minorities stand in the situation (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011). Most prior research focuses on understanding risk ratios and how they impact misrepresentation of minorities in special education programs. However, these risk ratios are often limited to individual regions, and fail to compare different regional trends and patterns. As such, Coutinho and Oswald (1999) posit that "in general, research has supported the public concern but the picture is unclear because studies have varied so much with respect to definitions of minority representation in findings across ethnic groups and technical methods" (p 66). Overall, the research shows a clear racial bias in the practices of many special education programs across the nation. Minority students are even forced to endure greater segregation in comparison to similar white students (Anyon, 2009).

Theoretical Framework

The predominate theory that sits at the very foundation of this phenomenon is structural theory. In this theory, social interactions and relations are a product of various structures within society that are correlated to the relationships established among different groups within a society. According to Blau (1977), "people engage in intergroup associations under specifiable structural conditions" which can "be deduced from analytic propositions about structural properties" (p 26). As such, structuralism aims to explain social phenomenon and relationships as they correlate with social structures that stratify our society.

Structural theory can be used as a way to examine the current educational field and how it relates to the structures within society that impact how we all think and act. According to the research, "Race relations are at the heart of educational stratification and disproportionality can be conceptualized as a means of maintaining educational stratification" (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011, p 1529). Structure theory helps add to this concept by formulating educational institutions as another social institution in place to augment the racial segregation and disenfranchisement of minority groups like African-Americans. This theory helps connect the ideas behind increasing poverty rates and enrollment of minorities in special education programs. Anyon (2009) connects the concepts set out in social constructivist theory to the fact that disproportionality serves a function to maintain the racist structural hierarchy of the United States.

As such, structural theory has long tied racialization to the structures within society that aim to continue to place the majority racial group in a position of power. Thus, Sullivan and Artiles (2011) claim that "the racial group in the position of most power benefits from greater social estimation (e.g. being viewed as smarter or better behaved) economic returns (e.g. higher pay), political positions, occupational prospects, and authority in determining social norms and physical boundaries" (p 1530).

Moreover, it is clear that within a very competitive modern environment, racialization is being used as a strategy to keep white racial groups at the highest competitive advantage. Thus, "structural theory also involves the notion of racial competition; that is, there is competition for limited resources, which results in the use of racial ideology to advantage White communities" (Sullivan & Artiles, 2011, p 1530). Structuralism has long posited that competition has fueled the process of stratification that serves to benefit some groups, while disenfranchising others (Burt, 1995). Thus, from this perspective, local LEAs, or local education agencies, are seen to have higher rates of disproportionality than larger state education agencies also known as SEAs (Thorsen et al., 2011). Anyon (2009) agrees that racial competition is a major contributor to the ongoing misrepresentation of minorities in the school environment.

What this implies for the field of special education is that the white majority is purposely allowing minorities to be overrepresented in special education in order to maintain a stigma that white students are innately more capable. Essentially, special education has become a tool for the further stratification and racialization of the United States because it promotes the segregation of students-based predominately on weak conditions of special needs for education (Blanchett, 2010).

White students, on the other hand, enjoy a greater privilege within this particular context. Blanchett (2010) shows how many white students who could be seen as meeting many of the same categories as their minority counterparts are simply labeled as having a learning disability, and are allowed to remain in normal student population, rather than being segregated into special education programs. This provides them with a lesser stigma while continuing to solidify the racialized concept that white groups are more powerful and capable compared to…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Overrepresentation Of Minorities In Special" (2012, July 15) Retrieved December 4, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/overrepresentation-of-minorities-in-special-71480

"Overrepresentation Of Minorities In Special" 15 July 2012. Web.4 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/overrepresentation-of-minorities-in-special-71480>

"Overrepresentation Of Minorities In Special", 15 July 2012, Accessed.4 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/overrepresentation-of-minorities-in-special-71480

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Problem Statement Overrepresentation of Minorities in Special Education...

    Overrepresentation of Minorities Special Education Overrepresentation of Minorities in Special Education The national debate over special education has no easy answers. On one hand, many parents of affected children want more resources catering to their children's special needs. However, the 'mainstreaming' movement, which was and is supported by many parents, stresses the need to place children in the least restrictive environment possible. There is clearly a need to balance placement in special

  • Overrepresentation of Minority Students With

    This study has noted that educators are noting better methods to assist these students rather than placing them in special education classes which fail to assist these students in school or across the span of their lifetime endeavors. RECOMMENDATIONS Recommendations arising from this review of literature in this study include the recommendation that different methods be utilized in assisting culturally and linguistically diverse students in the school setting. Among these methods

  • Overrepresentation of African Americans and Hispanics

    Research Questions The questions that follow will guide the study. By responding to these two questions, the study will have addressed the problem cited in the problem statement and at the same time achieved the purpose of the study: 1). What perceptions are held by school administrators as regards the influence that cultural difference has on the placement of students in the special education programs? 2). what theme informs the perceptions held by

  • Special Ed Disproportionate Representation of Minorities in

    Special Ed Disproportionate Representation of Minorities in Special Education Special Education is intended to function as a powerful resource for giving extra attention, assistance and educational resource to those with severe and irreparable learning deficiencies. However, there is also a danger that situational learning deficits may be perceived as deficiencies, leading to the incorrect classification of young students as special needs. Where improperly classified, the results to one's learning potential and academic

  • Special Education Programs Abound Throughout

    " According to Patton (1998) the overrepresentation of African-American children in special education programs that are intended for students that have serious emotional or behavioral disorders, learning disabilities, and mental disabilities has continued to be a problem even though many researchers have recognized the problems that have occurred as a result of such overrepresentation. In fact there is exhaustive amounts of literature that explains the "causal factors that range from failure

  • Ethical Dilemmas in Special Education

    Ethical Dilemmas in Special Education The ethical issues involved in special education are manifold. In many cases, the students are unable to perform certain activities unimpaired, and in many cases they will not ever attain a legal majority or emancipation. This already puts the educator in a more proprietary position than the mere invocation of in loco parentis could ever hope to capture. Yet this seems to point toward a greater degree

  • Factors That Determine the Increasing Number of African American...

    African-American Children in Special Education Programs The large amount of minority children, specifically African-American children, who have ended up in special education programs for students who have learning disabilities, behavioral disabilities, emotional disabilities, or mental disabilities, has remained a very strong reality even though it has been recognized for more than 20 years (Townsend, Thomas, Witty, & Lee, 1996). After looking at many of these patterns and how often they


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved