Aristotle Plato Term Paper

PAGES
2
WORDS
793
Cite
Related Topics:

¶ … Aristotle and Plato the books are as under: Aristotle's "The Politics"

And "Nicomachean Ethics"

Plato's "The Republic."

These are the names of the three books, which will be considered and viewed in the paper as a guide and reference to various questions related to Aristotle's and Plato viewpoint on the questions, which are as follows:

What mistake do oligarchs and democrats make in thinking about Justice, according to Aristotle?

To what extent would Plato agree with Aristotle's analysis?

What explains the similarities and/or differences in their approaches?

The paper will analyze and observe the viewpoints of the theorists and their relative opinions regarding these questions. In order to answer these questions the paper will introduce the background regarding these books and their relative themes. The paper will be presented in a compare/contrast format according to which the similarities and differences in the opinions of the theorists will be discussed and analyzed in the paper.

COMPARISON/CONTRAST OF PLATO'S "REPUBLIC" AND ARISTOTLE'S "POLITICS":

Aristotle's politics has defined the theories and concepts related to politics and society. Aristotle has presented his views and opinions on the...

...

Aristotle has defined the value of observation and analysis to determine the truth and reality. He has further assisted on the point that a government, which overlooks the interest of its people, is not based on good values but the entire framework of such government runs on evil values. The second book of Aristotle, which is used in this paper, is "Nicomachean Ethics," in this book the author has described the importance of good deeds and virtues and he has defined this practice as a means of gaining true peace and happiness.
According to Aristotle the oligarchs think that those who are superior in wealth and power should possess the entire control and they should be treated as kings of the state and the right of making judgments should be given to these oligarchs while the democrats think that democrats are free to act according to their own wishes and therefore they should make judgments and should have equal political rights. According to the theories of Aristotle, both these groups are mistakenly wrong in their thinking. Both these ideas of political justice are vague. Both these conceptions are based on false assumption of the ultimate end of city-state. The city-state is not…

Cite this Document:

"Aristotle Plato" (2004, April 23) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/aristotle-plato-167283

"Aristotle Plato" 23 April 2004. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/aristotle-plato-167283>

"Aristotle Plato", 23 April 2004, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/aristotle-plato-167283

Related Documents

The rulers correspond with the mind/soul- just as the mind directs the body in the individual, the rulers direct the body of the state (i.e. The guardians and workers.) Part Two: Aristotle on Pride Aristotle claims that pride is not a vice, but a major moral virtue. He opens his argument by saying that the word pride itself implies gratness, and therefore a proud man is one who considers hiomself-worthy of

It is learned and is the outcome of both teaching and practice and the force of habit. Discuss Aristotle's doctrine of the mean The mean is the result of moral virtues being balanced within the individual. Aristotle saw the mean as the middle road to happiness. He argued that all of life is really an attempt to find the highest good. Pleasure is momentary, but happiness is an ethical state of

theorists regarding political stability, the ideas and opinions of Aristotle, Plato, and Thucydides will be mentioned by thoroughly analyzing the viewpoints of these theorists in their books such as: Aristotle's "The Politics" And "Nicomachean Ethics," Plato's "The Republic," and Thucydides "The Peloponnesian War." The analysis and observations of the viewpoints of these theorists will be included in the paper. The question on which the analysis will be based is as

Aristotle Plato
PAGES 2 WORDS 648

Aristotle v. Plato Compare and contrast the metaphysical position of Aristotle and Plato. Does Aristotle's work constitute a sharp break with the position laid down by his teacher? Or is the old saying true that he apple does not fall far from the tree? Although their positions are often elided, the focus of Aristotle and Plato's metaphysical emphases is quite different. Ironically, given that one of his most famous works is called

Plato Vs. Aristotle It Is
PAGES 7 WORDS 2194

Justice equalled virtuosity. The goal was a rather pragmatic one since what the philosopher had in mind was the ideal functioning of the city (where a happy city would mean happy people). It is important to understand the fact that a city can reach the ideal state of virtue only if all of the citizens living in it are virtuous. Therefore the main focus is directed towards the individuals.

This is Aristotle's launching pad for his discussion of politics. To him, ethics and politics are matters of rational judgment, stemming from the natural inclinations of individual humans. This notion is reflected in Aristotle's analysis of the constitutional doctrines of some 158 cities. Essentially, he recognized that every state -- necessarily city states -- exist in unique sets of circumstances that act upon the universal forms of ethics in ways