Assertive Discipline On Social Relationships Term Paper

Length: 11 pages Sources: 7 Subject: Teaching Type: Term Paper Paper: #3967674 Related Topics: Transformative Learning, Behavior Modification, Classroom Observation, Self Reliance
Excerpt from Term Paper :

(Behavior Management Themes, 2007)

The basic rights of teacher in their classrooms include: (1) the right to establish optimal learning environments; (2) the right to request and express appropriate behavior; and (3) the right to receive help from administrators and parents as needed. (Behavior Management Themes, 2007) the basic rights of students in the classroom include: (1) the right to have teachers who help limit self-destructing behavior; and (2) the right to choose how to behave. (Behavior Management Themes, 2007) These rights and needs of students are most optimally met through use of assertive discipline in which the teacher "...clearly communicates the expectations to the students and consistently follows-up with appropriate actions, but never violates, the best interests of the students." (Behavior Management Themes, 2007) the work of Usha McNab entitled: "The Individual and the Whole Class" states that: "that the teacher needs to work on creating a social and cultural milieu in the classroom to cause positive behavior, where pupils can have control of themselves, and a feeling of empowerment and self-esteem, and problems can be seen as interesting puzzles to be solved through recognizing the network of causes. If there is a disturbance, an immediate mild rebuke is often enough. Planned "ignoring" of some provocative behavior, linked with positive attention for work is often useful." (nd) in fact, this approach is stated by McNab to be use in Assertive Discipline: "where the clear rules, rewards, and consequences are known to all, which enables the teacher to manage behavior inn the classroom without lowering the children's self-esteem or making it a personal issue. Children themselves recently confirmed the benefits of this approach when they described how a code of discipline had improved their school." (nd)

X. Logical Consequences

John Shindler states in the work entitled: "Developing Logical Consequences" that "An essential part of a well functioning system of social relationships" or the 'social contract' is "...a set of logical and related consequences for student behavior. Consequences act to create boundaries and clarity of expectations." (Shindler, nd) in his work, Shindler compares consequences with punishment and states that: "In a punishment condition, the pain and discomfort inflicted on the "punished" is always calculated by an external agent, the "punisher." With consequences, the cost or benefit is determined by natural laws, whereas with the punishment, the price is determined artificially. Consequences teach lessons, punishments teach avoidance of the punisher. Most consequences are understood before decisions are made and actions take place. Punishments are typically reactive." (nd) the following chart lists consequences vs. punishments in making a comparison of the two.

Consequences vs. Punishments: A Comparison



Intend to teach lessons

Intend to give discomfort

Foster internal locus of control

Foster external locus of control

Are proactive

Are reactive

Are logical and related

Are unrelated and personal

Work in the long-term

Work in the short-term

Promote responsibility

Can promote obedience (but more likely resentment)

Source: Shindler (nd)

The following is an example of a common uniform school-wide policy chart listing the levels of consequences for each incident of misbehavior.

Figure 2 - Common uniform school-wide policy chart depicting levels' of consequences for each misbehavior



1st offense


2nd offense

Time at recess or after school

3rd offense

Detention and/or contacting parents

Source: Shindler (nd)

According to Shindler: "Effective consequences are proactively built in to the contract before they are implemented." (nd)

XI.Ascending & Increasing Level of Consequences for Each Problem Behavior

Shindler additionally states that it only makes good sense: " have an increasingly more powerful series of consequences for a particular problem behavior. If the problem behavior is minor and it is infrequent, a small consequence may be all that is necessary. If it is prevalent or is a persistent problem for a particular student, more significant consequences may be necessary to help make the need for more responsible choices more pronounced." (nd) the following is a list of a series of ascending consequences:

1st offense (the student turns to a neighbor to talk while the teacher is talking): consequence - teacher stops talking (when they are interrupted) and says something to the effect "I need everyone's attention, so I will start over with the directions."...


It does not take a lot of time or energy, but it gets the message across.

2nd offense (the teacher notices that the student is talking to their neighbor when they are supposed to be attentive to another student who is contributing): Next level consequence - student comes up with a strategy to make sure they are able to pay attention when it is required.

3rd offense (student does it again): consequence - student is moved to another seat.

4th offense (student has the same problem in the new location): consequence - conference with the teacher after school resulting in a written contract." (Shindler, nd)

The following table lists the possible consequences for the student's offending behaviors.

Figure 3 - Example Ideas for Consequences for Student's Offensive Behavior

Problem Behavior

Related Consequence

Turning in assignment late

Loss of points

Problem lining up

Practice lining up

Frequent talking out of turn

Loss of opportunity to talk

Problem-solve solutions to fix problem

Loss of opportunity to take part in activity

Group can not refrain from conflict that leads to poor performance

Cooperative Learning

1st intervention - clarify task, confirm understanding

2nd intervention - clarify need to resolve conflict - confirm commitment to conflict-free effort

3rd intervention - loss of opportunity to take part in activity, potentially needing to reflect on solutions for future efforts, and/or need to complete work on own time.

Tapping pencils on desks

Have students put everything down and have their hands free while listening

Source: Shindler (nd)

Review of the Literature Reviewed

It has been related in this study the research of Canter and Canter who have stated that the key goal in the Assertive Discipline model is assisting students in understanding that they are responsible for and choose their own behavior. When the students chooses good behavior their self-esteem and academic success increases. Assertive Discipline is characterized by clear communication to students of the expectations of the teacher who not only talks the talks, or points out the consequences that may result from the student's action, but this teacher walks the walk as well by delivering the student unto the consequences, which they choose. This teacher however, has the student's best interest always in mind. The philosophical base of the Assertive Discipline approach is the difficulty experienced historically by teachers in exerting control of the inappropriate behavior of students in the classroom and it is this that resulted in what is a structured and systematic approach in which the teacher grasps control of the classroom and simultaneously influences the student's behavior in a positive manner. This model is one that is inclusive of the concept of corrective discipline through a positive behavioral management in what is a democratic and cooperative environment. Positive consequences were found by the Canters to be more of a factor in determining the behavior of students than negative consequences or in other words, the student would prefer to exhibit good behavior in order to receive the reward promised by the teacher instead of fear of the negative consequences that were set out for exhibiting bad behavior. Review of the literature has also related that it is critically necessary that the teacher develop positive relationships with the students listening intently to what the students are conveying and supporting them and showing respect to them at all times. The teacher who takes the approach of Assertive Discipline is one who provides encouragement, rewards and provide students with instruction that are clear.

Keys to implementing Assertive Discipline include the following steps:

1) Choose clear observable rules for consistent implementation in the classroom;

2) Decide the consequences for both negative and positive behavior in the classroom;

3) Call a class meeting and state the rules plainly, so that all understand what is being said;

4) Inform the parents of students of the program of discipline.

The teacher should always when speaking do so in a firm tone of voice and make eye contact with students being responsive to appropriate behavior exhibited by students. Assertive Discipline is not difficult to implement and is effectively on a general basis. Assertive Discipline provides students who are misbehaving with the right type of attention for exhibiting good behavior. Parents are involved and through cooperation in discipline techniques, unproductive behaviors have been shown to lessen. Critics of the Assertive Discipline approach hold that children should be taught to follow rules simply because it is the right thing to do and further that the techniques of Assertive Discipline are forms of control that do not encourage critical thinking in the child and interferes with the child in development of self-reliance.







Poverty/low income/urban





Sources Used in Documents:


Behavior Management Theories (2007) Online available at

Carey, Timothy a. (2007) What is Different About Different Discipline Programs? Difference in School Discipline and Classroom Management Programs. Online available at

Collier, Denise L. (2006) Sally Can Skip but Jerome Can't Stomp: Perceptions, Practice and School Punishment (Preliminary Results) April 2006. Online available at

McNab, Usha (nd) the Individual and the Whole Class. Online available at UNC Charlotte Behavior and Reading Improvement Center. Online available at
Shindler, John (nd) Developing Logical Consequences - Transformative Classroom Practice. Chapter 12. Online available at
Van Tassell, Gene (2007) Classroom Management. Brains Organization. Online available at

Cite this Document:

"Assertive Discipline On Social Relationships" (2007, March 13) Retrieved November 30, 2021, from

"Assertive Discipline On Social Relationships" 13 March 2007. Web.30 November. 2021. <>

"Assertive Discipline On Social Relationships", 13 March 2007, Accessed.30 November. 2021,

Related Documents
Social Work Supervision of Clinical
Words: 5496 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 54097164

By improving their self knowledge, leaders can change and develop as leaders of people. Clinical supervision for leaders is sometimes called administrative clinical supervision. This is managerial clinical supervision with a focus on problems related to leadership and organization of work, particularly human relations issues. Administrative clinical supervision makes use of experiential learning focused on oneself and one's work (Sirola-Karvinen and Hyrkas, 2008). Administrative clinical supervision means clinical supervision for

Social Cognition
Words: 2651 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 44120545

Social Cognition Influences on Social Cognition in Children and Adolescents Academic Institution Influences on Social Cognition in Children and Adolescents Child development is influenced by many factors. Some of the most important factors that affect the development of a child include heredity, nutrition, parental affection, and culture. Cognition refers to a general processes regarding the principles of thinking in humans, whereas social cognition refers to the study of how people process and use

Who's Controlling Our Emotions Emotional Literacy As a Mechanism...
Words: 8437 Length: 28 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 90031219

CONTROLLING OUR EMOTIONS? EMOTIONAL LITERACY: MECHANISM FOR SOCIAL CONTROL? At the core of becoming an activist educator Is identifying the regimes of truth that govern us the ideas that govern how we think, act and feel as educators because it is within regimes of truth that inequity is produced and reproduced. (MacNaughton 2005, 20) Disorder, addictions, vulnerability and dysfunction...." Disorder, addictions, vulnerability and dysfunction...." These terns, according to Nolan (1998; Furedi 2003; cited by Ecclestone

Extraversion the Relationship Between Leadership
Words: 2906 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 1049688

This leader must have subordinates who are trustworthy and the leader must be able to discern when it is appropriate to use this style. The most effective leader knows how to use a little bit of each style, and conversely the poor leader will stick to only one style despite the situation. A study by Hautala in 2006 investigated the association between personality and leadership style5. In this study, a

Leadership in International Schools
Words: 29649 Length: 108 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 20990082

Leadership Skills Impact International Education CHALLENGES OF INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION Practical Circumstances of International schools THE IMPORTANCE OF LEADERSHIP IN EDUCATION What is Effective Leadership for Today's Schools? Challenges of Intercultural Communication Challenges of Differing Cultural Values Importance of the Team Leadership Style LEADERSHIP THEORIES Current Leadership Research Transformational Leadership Skills-Authority Contingency Theories APPLYING LEADERSHIP IN AN INTERNATIONAL SETTING Wagner's "Buy-in" vs. Ownership Understanding the Urgent Need for Change Research confirms what teachers, students, parents and superintendents have long known: the individual school is the key unit

Self in World Religions Although Religion Is
Words: 3068 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 93716902

Self in World Religions Although religion is primarily a social activity -- even the most solitary and mystical of religious practitioners require an existing creed subscribed to by other people -- to a certain degree religion is required to define the self. In practice, the religious conception of selfhood can work in a number of ways -- either by setting limits to acceptable thought and behavior by the self by establishing