Mark Bowden's critical analysis of the Black Hawk Down mission
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
¶ … Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War by Mark Bowden. Specifically it will contain a critical review of the book. This book gained notoriety when it was made into a film, with the author writing the screenplay. The book is a detailed and emotional look into an unsuccessful U.S. mission in Somalia, and it poses the question of what we were doing there and what we actually accomplished.
Author Mark Bowden is a writer and journalist who has written several books, and writes for a variety of publications, including the Atlantic Monthly. He has won several awards, including the Overseas Press Club's Cornelius Ryan Award. He has a degree in English literature from Loyola College of Maryland, and is an adjunct professor of creative writing and journalism at Loyola, as well (Editors. "Mark Bowden: Biography." AtlanticMonthly.com. 2007. (http://www.theatlantic.com/about/people/mbbio.htm)."Black Hawk Down" was also a finalist for the National Book Award in 1999, and spent over a year on the New York Times Bestseller List.
Bowden relates the actions of several "chalks" of soldiers sent into Mogadishu to kidnap two high-ranking lieutenants in General Aidid's Habr Gidr Clan insurgent army. The Army Rangers assigned to the task seem well prepared and trained for the mission, but from the first, everything falls apart and the soldiers are stranded in Mogadishu without backup or rescue. The author's thesis for the book is simple, the mission was flawed from the start, and so was the command that led to the mission in the first place. He notes, "In Washington a whiff of failure is enough to induce widespread amnesia," (331), which indicates his cynicism regarding the mission and the Washington reaction to withdraw the troops just days after the Black Hawk Down raid. He shows the internal problems in the Army that led to the Rangers' stranding in Mogadishu, and generally portrays the Army and government as flawed for joining in the U.N. mission in Somalia at all. He writes, "He [Sergeant Howe] disdained the Rangers in part because he believed hard, realistic, stair-stepped training made good soldiers, not the bull***** macho attitude epitomized by the whole Hoo-ah esprit" (35). Thus, he makes it clear that two very separate commands make up the mission. It is clear they do not respect each other, and this makes it extremely difficult to create unity, teamwork, and good leadership, as the results in Mogadishu show.
The book supports this thesis in a variety of ways, from interviews with the participants to books, articles, and exhaustive notes that are all printed in the back of the book. Bowden interviewed Mogadishu residents as well as Army personnel to gain a more balanced view of what happened and why.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.