Children Act 1989 Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Children Type: Term Paper Paper: #20522907 Related Topics: Child Observation, Book Of Acts, Parental Responsibility, Child Poverty
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Though some have called for the abolition of the substitute parent juvenile justice system, Gardner argues that the punitive model need not result in such an abolition or in the reincorporation of the juvenile justice system into the adult system (Gardner 1987, pp. 129-151).

The earlier American system was based on similar concerns raised more recently about the UK system and was also based on a view of protecting children. The change to a more punitive system came out of fear of youth crime. The UK case followed a series of official reports, including the Department of Health and Social Security review of childcare law in 1985 and the Law Commission report on guardianship and custody in 1988: "The message of these reviews was that the current law was unclear, unnecessarily complicated and characterized by procedural and substantive injustice. The government White Paper described its purpose in bringing forward proposals for change in the law relating to childcare and family services as the achievement of 'greater clarity and consistency' to help 'parents and children who may be affected by the law and those who work professionally within it' (Franklin 2001, p. 60). Franklin also cites the child abuse scandals of the 1980s as they centered on local authority social service practice. Because of these various assessments, "the law was seen as ineffective in promoting appropriate child protection practice and preventive work with families and as failing to involve parents and children sufficiently in decision-making. It was also seen as being too complex and as failing to strike the right balance between family privacy and the power of the state to intervene to protect children" (Franklin 2001, p. 61). As written, the Act intended to create a new model of parenthood as well as a new vision of the responsibility given to the Local Authority.

In addition, the Act can be said to have advanced the idea of children's rights:

There are four aspects of the


First, the Act allowed for the possibility that children themselves may want to make applications for one of the new section 8 orders.

21 Section 10 specifically provided for the eventuality in which a child applied to the court for permission to make an application for a section 8 order. The court can only grant the child leave to apply if "it is satisfied that he has sufficient understanding to make the proposed application." None the less the Act in its contemplation of the possibility of the child becoming a litigant could be seen as advancing and extending the child's autonomy ( 2001, p. 64).

This also departed from the settled rule that a child could not bring or defend an action except through a guardian, while not it was provided that a child could prosecute or defend proceedings in certain situations, notably when the proceedings are not "specified proceedings" and the child has the permission of the court, or where a solicitor has accepted instructions from a child having considered that the child is able to give instructions. These new provisions for the first time meant there was a possibility for the child to have unmediated access to legal service and the courts.

As noted, some changes have been made since the original passage of the Act, and also some critics have noted problems that may pertain. The Act has been complemented by the creation of the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service. The United Nations has also been involved in expanding the rights of children and has offered advice through the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child to the UK's first Report to the Committee, suggesting that the UK address the question of the parental right to chastise the child. Franklin notes that the direction of change has been different as the government has decided to emphasize ideas of parental rights rather than children's rights. It is not clear that the two have to be in opposition, but where the emphasis is placed will make a difference as to how the law is followed and applied (2006, pp. 72-73).

The Children Act 1989 marked a shift in the way children would be treated under law in the UK, and the other laws passed on the subject since have consolidated the idea of shared responsibility between parent and Local Authority and the more paternal aspects of the way children are to be protected by the Local Authority.


Bennett, G. 1989, Crimewarps, New York, Anchor Books.

Children Act 1989-2008. Office of Public Sector Information, the National Archives,

Curran, D.J. 1988, October, Destructuring, Privatization, and the Promise of Juvenile Diversion: Compromising Community-based Corrections, Crime and Delinquency, 363-378.

Franklin, B. 2001, the New Handbook of Children's Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice, London, Routledge.

Hirst, J. 2001, January 22, Another Crumbling Public Service, New Statesman, Volume 130, Issue 4521, 10.

Gardner, Martin R., "Punitive Juvenile Justice: Some Observations on a Recent Trend," International Journal of…

Sources Used in Documents:


Bennett, G. 1989, Crimewarps, New York, Anchor Books.

Children Act 1989-2008. Office of Public Sector Information, the National Archives,

Curran, D.J. 1988, October, Destructuring, Privatization, and the Promise of Juvenile Diversion: Compromising Community-based Corrections, Crime and Delinquency, 363-378.

Franklin, B. 2001, the New Handbook of Children's Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice, London, Routledge.

Cite this Document:

"Children Act 1989" (2008, May 09) Retrieved October 26, 2021, from

"Children Act 1989" 09 May 2008. Web.26 October. 2021. <>

"Children Act 1989", 09 May 2008, Accessed.26 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Child Abuse in England Using Given Scenario
Words: 2697 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 69315184

Child Abuse in England Initial Information The bruises on Clara's upper arms are indicative of something serious that the health visitor, if she, indeed, has been seeing her for two and a half years, should have noted or anticipated. The account given is so scanty that the general information can hardly be gleaned. The other family members should have been asked or given in the account, even if the health visitor does

Bilingualism's Effects on Children in 1989, Howard
Words: 3410 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Communication - Language Paper #: 46557493

Bilingualism's Effects On Children In 1989, Howard Gardner first proposed the theory of multiple intelligences. His theory posits that every human being is equipped with several kinds of intelligence that are interdependent. He developed his theory as a way to improve and challenge current practices in many fields, including education, child development, and even neuroscience. One of the intelligences he proposes is that of linguistic intelligence. To be able to learn

Child Soldiers in Burundi and
Words: 7303 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 1655899

The Convention on the Rights of the Child, established a legal and ethical instrument for promoting and protecting the rights of children. The International Community responded enthusiastically to the Convention, and that type of broad participating "symbolizes something very special about the Convention, something that gives it unique importance and authority." Carol Bellamy with UNICEF believes that this support for the Convention suggests that human rights, particularly child rights, have gained

Child Abuse Maltreatment Limited an Age Occur
Words: 816 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 48382238

Child abuse maltreatment limited an age occur infant, toddler, preschool, school-age years. Choose age groups (infant, toddler, preschool, school age) discuss types abuse age. Discuss warning signs physical emotional assessment findings nurse child abuse. Reporting suspected child abuse: The nurses' dilemma Accusing a parent or other relative of child abuse is a serious allegation, and nurses are understandably often reluctant to take such a step. Common signs of child abuse in school-age

Child Abuse & Erik Erikson
Words: 2148 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 44454492

Child abuse no doubt hampers the victim's personality growth and development, as backed out by various publications, studies and research. During these formative years, we are delicate and breakable. Our environment and our relationships either make or break us. The aggressive, apathetic or withdrawn behavior can be traced to feelings that they hardly anyone can be trusted, or that they are inferior to others. All these are residual effects that

Children and Television
Words: 2051 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 62658697

Children and Television Television may be an almost universal feature on the domestic scene, however it is not sued I the same way by everyone who has access to a set (Gunter 1). The television set has become an integral piece of the household furniture, and practically every house has at least one set, if not more, which means that children are born into a world in which television is present