Critique Of Article: Health And Safety In Term Paper


Critique of Article: Health and Safety in the Engineering Classroom
1 The type of research is descriptive, to elicit statistics on how prevalent safety and health instruction is in the normal college engineering curriculum.
2. Yes, the problem is clearly stated. "The Professional Engineer's Code of Ethics includes the responsibility 'to hold paramount the public safety, health and welfare,' and yet several recent reports suggest that few undergraduate engineering programs include any structured course material relevant to identifying environmental threats to health and controlling occupational and public health and safety hazards." (Introduction, p. 1, par. 2, lines 1-4)
3. Yes, the research questions are defined, albeit indirectly through the use of tables and "subsets" of the questions asked. One table lists the reasons why professors do include instruction on health and safety in their classes, while the other addresses the reasons they would not include such instruction. While the questions themselves are not spelled out, the information elicited is clearly ranked on these tables (Tables 1 and 2, pages 2-3, pars. 1-4).
4. No, the problem is not deduced from theory but from results of other studies.(Introduction, p. 1, par. 2, line 3, and p. 6 list).
5. N/A. This is not an experimental or relational design, so no independent variables were defined.
6. One dependent variable, as a source of possible error, was that one-third of the respondents previously had attended a National...


4, par. 1, lines 2-3).These faculty, because of their attendance, may have had a stronger focus on safety issues than had all respondents either attended these workshops or been drawn from non-attendees. 7. Yes, the surveys sent to the respondents covered both negative and positive situations, and gave respondents a range of response from "mildly" to "strongly" positive, to neutral or negative.
8. Yes, the population studied was clearly specified. "A questionnaire probing faculty interest in and instructional commitment to occupational and public health and safety was mailed to 324 undergraduate engineering professors in 112 U.S. colleges of engineering." (Methods, p. 1-2, par. 4) 175 surveys were returned, of which 18 were excluded because the professors had either retired or left the university setting. Of the 157 that remained, 97% of faculty responding were from undergraduate programs accredited by the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology, representing 65 colleges of engineering (Methods, p. 2, par. 1, lines 13-16).
9. Yes, the sampling methods were clearly outlined. The samples were divided into three groups; one group had attended National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health workshops; one group was chosen from the same universities and fields as those previous, only from non-attendees; and the third group was random (Methods, page 2, par. 1, lines 1-5).
10. This…

Cite this Document:

"Critique Of Article Health And Safety In" (2002, April 28) Retrieved April 23, 2024, from

"Critique Of Article Health And Safety In" 28 April 2002. Web.23 April. 2024. <>

"Critique Of Article Health And Safety In", 28 April 2002, Accessed.23 April. 2024,

Related Documents

Health Care in the U.S. And Spain What Can the U.S. Learn About Health Care from Spain? In 2009, Spain's single-payer health care system was ranked the seventh best in the world by the World Health Organization (Socolovsky, 2009). By comparison, the U.S. health care system ranted at 37 (Satiroglou, 2009). The Spanish system offers coverage as a right of citizenship that is constitutionally guaranteed. Spanish residents pay no expenses out-of-pocket, with

Healthcare - The Truth About

The experiences of seniors within the healthcare delivery system will alter how all Americans view healthcare. The healthcare delivery systems and overall organizational structure in the United States has been slow to adjust but that rest of the world is currently in flux that will migrate into our system. Technological advances in communication have made telehealth and telemedicine vialbel solutions to our outdated healthcare industry orgainzational structre. While these types

Figure 1 portrays the state of Maryland, the location for the focus of this DRP. Figure 1: Map of Maryland, the State (Google Maps, 2009) 1.3 Study Structure Organization of the Study The following five chapters constitute the body of Chapter I: Introduction Chapter II: Review of the Literature Chapter III: Methods and Results Chapter IV: Chapter V: Conclusions, Recommendations, and Implications Chapter I: Introduction During Chapter I, the researcher presents this study's focus, as it relates to the

Healthcare Information Systems Faculty of Information Technology at the Queensland University Australia, have written this article to point out the need to change the method of access control in the current health care environment. They have introduced this method keeping in the mind the latest information technology system structures, legal and regulatory requirements and the demands of security operation in the Health Information Systems. The authors have proposed "Open and Trusted

Imogene King's Attainment Theory King's Attainment Theory The thrust of Imogene King's theory of goal attainment is a loosely-coupled partnership between the nurse and the patient that enables communication about the patient's condition, their health goals, and a plan of action to achieve the patient's goals. The conceptual framework is based on systems theory -- and King employs the three classic systems in her representation of her theory: (1) the personal system,

Health Literacy CRITIQUE OF CONCEPT ANALYSIS (HEALTH LITERACY) Significance of Concept to Presenter Health literacy is very important to me because the concept is vital when it comes to health care in general specifically in nursing. It has a great impact on the patient's capability to understand and process information necessary for optimal health. As a nurse, it is important to me that I am aware of my patient's literacy level for