Thesis Doctorate 3,021 words

Dangers of Overcrowding in American Correctional System

Last reviewed: April 4, 2013 ~16 min read
Abstract

The paper performs a discussion of the overcrowding problem in the American Correctional Facilities. It explores on the dangers in the facilities and some of the possible approaches for eradicating the dangers. The paper provides recommendations for dealing with the problem. It considers aspects causing of overcrowding, for example, the crime rates.

Dangers of Overcrowding in American Correctional System

There are several central governments, state and local authority's correctional facilities in the United States. Over the past few decades, the rate of crime occurrence has significantly increased. Also, the correctional facilities have experienced growth in population. There are a huge number of inmates in the various correctional facilities as compared to those in 1990's. For instance, the Bureau of Justice Statistics found the number of prisoners at 665,000 across the country; this is a 159% increase from the jail population of 1985. The correctional facilities have, suffered several setbacks due to the increase in the population.

The capacities of the correctional facilities in the United States are not sufficient to hold the large population of inmates; research from the report released in 2002 indicate that the facilities operate at 108% capacity from the 85% capacity held in 1983. This has made the facilities have a negative reputation and other associated problems. The questions of whether, these facilities are helping the society and the inmates or making the situation worse than it is already, have not been overlooked (T. Franklin; C. Franklin, Cortney & Pratt, 2006). The United States has the world's third largest jail in California, and, therefore, with the influx of the incarcerated; it is not astounding that she has the largest populace of convicts in the world. California's jail had a population of 155,500 in 2002, which is twice its holding capacity. The price for the rising numbers in the correctional facilities is exceptionally high. The problems in the facilities pose a much bigger challenge than the issue of the crime itself. The budgets for these facilities are being stretched to the limits, especially considering the present economic crisis. The fiscal budget of 2012 at the federal government for inmates was $6.6 billion, the second largest ever according to the Department Of Justice. In order to maintain these facilities and tackle the problems, costs have to be incurred. The problem is that the sectors that should handle the problem are facing immense challenges.

The cause of the ever rising population is imperative in understanding the dangers associated with the issue and the possible solutions to the problem. The large number of people taken to the jails is not a fault of the correctional facilities. It results from the society, the government and politics of the nation. The first and critical issue that leads to the issue of rising population is the rise of crime. Crime in the United States has taken a different cause (GAO, 2012). The crimes committed have expanded from the simple, minor crime acts, to more complex and personal crimes, such as drug trafficking, murder, suicide attempts, homicides, theft, cyber crimes and social crimes. The increased crime rate is, therefore, the largest factor that is contributing to the issue of overcrowding in the facilities.

The judicial system is also to blame for the rise of the numbers in jails. The people arrested are always handled by the courts before getting into the correctional systems. The courts, therefore, have the duty to ensure that they give reasonable judgment. Most criminals just plead not guilty because of reasons best known to them. However, the courts, know best how to differentiate a guilty and an innocent person (GAO, 2012). Therefore, long jail terms, are not the best punishing measures for most petty crimes. The policies of the courts should allow other alternatives for punishing offenders. The large populace of people being condemned to prison is, thus, a key contributing factor to the large number of inmates. The third cause is the failing police and security system. There is much room for criminals to engage in criminal acts thus as the police do not keep the offenders from committing the crime, they instead arrest them. Once arrested, these people are taken to the courts, where they are sent to the jails.

Moreover, there is the issue of limited space in the correctional facilities. The many correctional facilities in the country are not adequate to accommodate the rising population. The space is limited, the facilities, the staff and everything that contributes to the well being of the inmates (Franklin et al., 2006). Therefore, as the numbers continue to rise; the facilities become smaller, hence overcrowding problems emerge. The management of these systems is also a key factor that contributes to overcrowding. As the population increases, the management does not expand correctional facilities to accommodate the inmates. Therefore, the issue continues to exacerbate, resulting to overcrowded facilities that are evident in the entire country.

The correctional facilities are for the purpose of accommodating the offenders. They are there to facilitate them with a chance and opportunity to realize that they need to change; so that they can be acceptable in the society (Davis, Applegate, Otto, Surette & McCarthy, 2004). A correctional facility is not a place for punishment and retribution as many would think. This, however, is the case that is unfolding in the society. The inmates are being overlooked and ignored in the thought that they are social outcasts. The inmates are viewed as not being human; therefore they can live like the 'animals'. This has heightened the risks associated with the problem of overcrowding. There are several problems and risks that are experienced due to overcrowding jails. The problems involve the whole correctional system, and the society at large. The staff of the facilities, the inmates themselves, the relatives of the prisoners and the whole country is equally affected. The dangers of overcrowding are immense and affect the whole system of correcting offenders.

The dangers associated with the overcrowding in these facilities are such that the misconduct of the inmate increases, leading to criminal activities in the facilities. According to theoretical frameworks of psychology, the behavior of the individual is highly determined by the environment (Franklin et al., 2006). Therefore, the environment influences correctional facilities in the same way. Subjection of prisoners to harsh environments makes them develop certain characteristics and altitudes, which determine the survival in the facility. Consequently, these conditions influence the behavior of all the inmates. The characteristics developed are as a result of the struggles in the jail. For the inmates to survive in the environment, they must get assimilated into the system. This makes them conduct themselves in a manner that is not right. The inmate, instead of developing positive conduct from the facility, they accumulate and assimilate more of the unwanted survival tactics and behavior from the facility. This is dangerous as it can pose problems when the inmate is released. Overcrowding, therefore, has a direct relation with the discipline of the inmates in the correctional facility. Placing the large number of offenders in the same place, where they have close contact easily develops into negative relations. Influence of human behavior is transferred from one inmate to the other as they interact.

The correctional facilities have several problems that pose a danger to the convicts and the staff from prisons. These are situations such as outbreak and spread of diseases (Franklin et al., 2006). A good illustration is the case observed in the California prisons. The inmates had to sue the authorities and the government for neglect and inhuman treatment for the unhygienic conditions, malnutrition and disease outbreaks in the prisons. It was the overcrowding within the facilities that led to the occurrence of the outbreak. Some facilities, such as the one in West Virginia reported that some inmates do not have space to sleep. They end up sleeping on the floor in the small available cells. The crowded facilities provide the convenient place for disease causing micro-organisms to breed and infect. Overcrowding creates a stuffed environment, in which there is no free circulation of air. Moreover, the overcrowded places usually, do not have a good cleaning system and practice. This consequently contributes to the spread of all communicable diseases within these facilities. Epidemics, such as cholera, tuberculosis among others easily spread through the crowded environment. This is because of the close contact between the infected and uninfected inmates. Thus, overcrowding is detrimental to the health and welfare of the inmates. It is a threat to their lives and can easily lead to unwanted deaths to the inmates and the staff. The well-being of the inhabitants of these prisons and the staff of the facilities are threatened by overcrowding in the correctional facilities.

In addition, mental health problems emanate due to overcrowding in the correctional facilities. The mental health of a person is greatly determined by the environment that the individual lives. An overcrowded place will, probably because it is an environment that is stressful to the inmate. The activities and events that culminate within the overcrowded facilities can cause a lot of stress to the inmates. A good illustration of the effect of overcrowding in the prison facilities is found from the statistics of suicides within the prison facilities (GAO, 2012). Out of every five suicides in jails, one is as a result of stress. The research reports from these correctional houses show that the cases of suicide are most prevalent in the crowded jails. This is further related to the mental health of the prisoners. In the crowded facilities, the mental health of the inmates cannot be efficiently monitored as the population of inmates outweighs that of the staff and professionals who attend to them. Consequently, this leaves the prisoners in position of despair leading to the thoughts of committing suicide. Therefore, the effects of overcrowding on the mental health of the inmates are clearly evident. The danger is a threat to the lives of the inmates. A mentally stressed inmate can commit murder, and also commit suicide.

The issue of drugs and drug trafficking is posing a challenge to the society at large. However, it is most surprising to note that, the problem is not only in the society, but also in the prisons. The place that is perceived to be safe for keeping the drug traffickers is the place that the drugs trade has established itself best than the outside (Exum, 2011). The issue of drugs in the correctional facilities can easily be handled if the population ratio of the inmates to that of the staff is calculated. However, the overcrowding in the correctional facilities is the root of the entire drug related problem in the prisons. Overcrowding allows the traffickers to reach the inmates, and the inmates respond by participating to the illegal practice in the prisons. Therefore, the whole issue of drugs is propagated. The danger of the drugs in the prisons is that, the people in prison are supposed to reform and not become addicts. Therefore, overcrowding and drugs enhance the process that hinders the correction and rectification of the behaviors of the inmates. This is dangerous as when these inmates are released, they are entangled in the society which they are part. This means that they take the same undesirable vice back into society. Therefore, drugs and overcrowding in prison are dangerous to the prisoners and the public at large.

Moreover, overcrowding is not only dangerous to the inmates; it also affects the functioning of the correctional facility staff. Research from the various jail institutions has shown that overcrowding is posing a staid peril to the well-being of the workers. For instance, the cases of the prison wardens that have been killed by inmates in the prisons are at an alarming high number. The staff complains that overcrowding is dangerous to their working environment as the large number of inmates largely outweighs the small population of staff. Therefore, as the staff engages with the inmates, they are easily threatened by the prevalent inmate violence. This is dangerous to the safety of the prison staff. Moreover, the large population of inmates is also posing a challenge to the staff in delivering service. This is stressful to their work. The staff experiences stress due to the large number of inmates that they have to attend to everyday Steiner, 2009). The large population gives them a lot of work, and this is a threat to their physical and mental health. The large population has impaired the job performance of the staff in the correctional facilities; averages of 25 officers are assaulted every month by prisoners. This is not fair to the workers as they deserve safe and quality working environment.

Overcrowding in the correctional facilities and violence, in America, are inseparable. The prevalence of violence erupting in a crowded place is extremely high. This is the case experienced in the American correctional systems (Steiner, 2009). The incidences of violence in the prisons are extremely high, with an average of 504 deaths of inmates being reported every month, according to the statistics released in 2002. The most dangerous fact about the issue of violence in overcrowding is that, due to the large number of people involved, it becomes extremely difficult for the limited staff to handle the problem. The violence can occur between inmates or inmates and staff. In both cases, the effects associated are detrimental to the involved parties. The dangers of violence are inexplicable. The risks of violence erupting in a crowded prison are always higher than where the population is limited.

The danger associated with the violence in these facilities is that, it involves people who are not mentally stable. The inmates are in a state of stress and the desire to inflict pain and also, establishing dominance among the fellow inmates motivates them. The physical fights involve the use of crude weapons among other instruments (Tartaro, 2002). This is dangerous to the lives of prisoners. Moreover, in these crowded institutions, the issues of sexual violence and harassment are always high. 21% of violence in prisons is of sexual nature. This is dangerous to the health of the inmates as they can easily transmit diseases and other infections. Moreover, the issue of sexual violence is a violation of the people's rights.

You’re 82% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.

Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log in
130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant Citation generator Cancel anytime
References
10 sources cited in this paper
  • Davis, R.K., Applegate, B.K., Otto, C.W., Surette, R. & McCarthy, B.J. (2004). Roles and Responsibilities: Analyzing Local Leaders'Views on Jail Crowding From a Systems Perspective, Crime and Deliquency , (50) 1, 458-480
  • Steiner, B. (2009). Assessing Static and Dynamic Influences on Inmate Violence Levels, Crime & Delinquency, (55) 1, 134-158. DOI: 10.1177/0011128707307218
  • Martin, J.L., Lichtenstein,B., . Jenkot, R.B., & Forde,D.R. (2012). ''They Can Take Us Over Any Time They Want'' : Correctional Officers' Responses to Prison Crowding, The Prison Journal , (92) 1, 88-105 DOI: 10.1177/0032885511429256
  • Franklin, T.W. Cortney A. Franklin, C.A., & Pratt,T.C. (2006). Examining the empirical relationship between prison crowding and inmate misconduct: A meta-analysis of conflicting research results, Journal of Criminal Justice, (34), 401 – 412
  • Specter, D. (2010). Everything Revolves Around Overcrowding: The State of California’s Prisons, Federal Sentencing reporter, (22) 3, 194-198.
  • GAO. (September 2012). Growing Inmate Crowding Negatively Affects Inmates, Staff, and Infrastructure, bureau of prisons, United States Government Accountability Office.
  • Huey, M.P., & Mcnulty, T.L. (2005). Institutional Conditions and Prison Suicide: Conditional Effects of Deprivation and Overcrowding, The Prison Journal, (85) 4, 490- 514
  • Exum, J.J. (2011). sentencing, drugs, and prisons: a lesson from ohio. exum_final.doc. Vol.42
  • Wooldredge, J. & Steiner, B. (December 2009). Comparing Methods for Examining Relationships Between Prison Crowding and Inmate Violence, justice quarterly, 26(4), 796-826
  • Tartaro, C. (2002). The impact of density on jail violence, Journal of Criminal Justice 30, 499 – 510
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2013). Dangers of Overcrowding in American Correctional System. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/dangers-of-overcrowding-in-american-correctional-88878

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.