Diversity Issues In Schools That Term Paper

Length: 12 pages Sources: 12 Subject: Teaching Type: Term Paper Paper: #74862249 Related Topics: Diversity, Workplace Diversity, Chicano Studies, Graduate School
Excerpt from Term Paper :

According to these authorities, "Workplace stressors often have detrimental effects on faculty job satisfaction and may lead to decisions to leave the institution or to leave higher education entirely. Although some degree of turnover is inevitable and perhaps desirable, high rates of faculty turnover can be costly to the reputation of an institution and to the quality of instruction" (p. 776). In many cases, the very faculty members that are adversely affected in this fashion are those the school district can least afford to lose, with a concomitant negative effect on those teachers who remain: "Too often the faculty who leave are those the institution would prefer to retain. Additional negative consequences of faculty turnover include costs for recruiting replacements, reduced integration within the academic department, disruption of course offerings, and diminished morale among those employees who remain in the organization" (Daly & Dee, p. 777).

In reality, the outcomes of inappropriate job performance evaluations extend to both positive and negative ratings. If poor teachers are consistently rated as satisfactory or even superior, they will continue to receive within-grade increases and be retained in teaching positions where they may be doing more harm than good. Conversely, negative performance ratings of superior teachers will likely result in increased job dissatisfaction with its well-documented adverse outcomes, including a higher incidence of absenteeism, lower morale and decline in job performance, all based on the spurious results of subjective performance evaluations of questionable value.

What Can Be Done?

Because resources are by definition scarce, the resources devoted to a school district's performance management system must be constantly reviewed to ensure they are relevant to the district's changing demographics and based on a known set of quantifiable metrics. In this regard, in the public sector, Esty and Rushing (2007) suggest that in order to be successful, "Performance evaluation must be transparent, free of political manipulation, and based on credible and easily understood data. With reliable performance data in hand, it is then possible to make necessary adjustments to government programs. Policies that are producing good results should be extended and expanded. Those that are not should be rethought, with resources redeployed" (p. 67).

One alternative approach to the traditional performance evaluation techniques that have been used in the nation's schools that has shown some promise and represents a better use of resources is described by Becton and Schraeder (2004). These authors reports, "Traditional performance appraisal systems have primarily consisted of supervisor evaluations of subordinate performance. In recent years, however, organizations have increasingly turned their attention toward gathering performance feedback from sources other than immediate supervisors" (Becton & Schraeder, p. 23). The authors cite a number of benefits that have been associated with obtaining feedback from such multiple sources, including:

Better performance information;

More reliable ratings than those from a single supervisor; and,

Improved teacher performance after receiving the feedback (Becton & Schraeder).

Conceivably, this approach would also serve to improve the accuracy of teacher performance in a diverse setting by introducing additional sources of feedback from peers and others. In this regard, identifying the "who" in the evaluation process is as important as the "what" that is being measured. As Becton and Schraeder emphasize, "Effectively choosing a method of rater selection necessitates consideration of the potential effects of participant input on the quality and acceptance of ratings. While allowing participants to have input into this process are advocated, there are numerous factors and potential implications that should be taken into consideration" (p. 23). These factors and potential implications include those outlined in Table 1 below.

Table 1.

Factors to be taken into account in identifying teacher evaluators and implications.




Teachers should have a voice in the selection of raters.

People tend to accept decisions and their consequences if they have participated in making them. Furthermore, research indicates that employees desire voice, prompting them to view procedures into which they have input as fairer than those that do not allow input, regardless of the outcomes.

Feedback is essential to employee development. Feedback in organizations is a fundamental way that employees...


It not only helps employees to address deficiencies or performance problems, but it also reinforces positive work-related behaviors, encourages the development of desirable work habits, and helps employees achieve their goals.

The evaluator must be credible.

The perceived credibility of the feedback source cannot be overstated. Source credibility is a key determinant in a person's reaction to feedback. Source credibility includes a recipient's belief that the source has the ability and appropriate intentions to make effective ratings or evaluations upon which to base the feedback. Teachers who receive feedback from a more credible source view the feedback as more accurate, the source as more insightful, and are more satisfied with the feedback. Additionally, source credibility has been shown to moderate the feedback to performance relationship.

Source credibility may influence how an individual perceives the feedback and whether the individual accepts the feedback as an accurate representation of their performance. The recipient's desire to respond to the feedback and the resulting goals may also be impacted. It is implicit that feedback from more credible sources would be perceived as more accurate, with the potential of more effectively changing performance. Consequently, feedback recipients are more likely to accept and ultimately respond to developmental feedback if they perceive the feedback source as credible.

Teaching goals to be evaluated should be challenging but realistic

Specific challenging goals evoke better performance than vague, unchallenging goals.

Teachers who have more input into the selection of raters and receive negative feedback will set more challenging goals than those who have little or no input into the selection of raters.

Source: Based on Becton & Schraeder, 2004.

Although the body of evidence concerning 360-degree feedback evaluation techniques remains scant, the studies to date indicate that the increasing popularity of this evaluation method have been based on the following reasons:

Dissatisfaction with traditional performance appraisal systems;

Increased focus on empowerment, participation, and students;

Larger spans of control;

Attempts to improve organizational processes and communication;

Increased need to communicate critical organizational behaviors and values; and,

The increased need for administrators to respond to diversity in their geographic settings (Becton & Schaeder).

The multi-source teacher evaluation approach has increasingly included evaluations from the students themselves. For instance, Germain and Scandura (2005) report that, "Today, faculty are being held accountable for how well they serve the U.S. student population, and it has become common practice in universities and colleges for students to 'grade' the professors that grade them. Students' ratings of management faculty... provide faculty with feedback on teaching effectiveness. They are also used for faculty reappointment, promotion and/or pay increase decisions" (p. 58).

When considering feedback from multiple sources for teacher evaluation purposes, though, it is important to keep in mind that many of the same constraints that characterize the traditional superior-employee evaluation process are also inherent in these alternatives. In this regard, Germain and Scandura note that, "Since student ratings of faculty teaching effectiveness are used as one component of faculty evaluation, it seems reasonable to consider these instruments as performance ratings. As such, they are subject to a number of possible biases, as has been shown in the literature on rating accuracy in Industrial and Organizational Psychology" (p. 58).

Notwithstanding these potentials for individual bias, such multi-source evaluation techniques has been shown to be superior to the traditional approach based on the teacher job performance that results from its use. In sum, Becton and Schraeder emphasize that, "Multi-source or 360-degree feedback involves the collection of evaluations of job performance from two or more rating sources, which could conceivably include the rater's self appraisal, supervisor ratings, peer ratings, subordinate ratings or feedback from customers, vendors, and suppliers. This feedback from multiple sources and perspectives is perhaps the most compelling strength of 360-degree feedback" (emphasis added) (Becton & Schraeder, p. 24).


The research showed that the nation's schools have become incredibly diverse settings, characterized by an increasing number of students from a wide range of cultural backgrounds and with different specialized learning needs. The research also showed that while teachers struggle to balance the needs of their diverse student bodies, they are also faced with the mandates of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, as well as increasingly overcrowded and violent classrooms. Diversity issues were shown to extend to demographic composition of the classroom, differences in evaluation techniques and the increasing diversity of the teacher-administrator cadre as well. Evaluating teacher performance in this dynamic environment represents a challenging enterprise by any measure, and there was some bad news and good news on this front. The bad news was that despite enormous advances in recent years, the lingering effects of racial stereotypes and personal biases continues to creep into the…

Sources Used in Documents:


Aper, J.P. & Fry, J.E. (2003). Post-tenure review at graduate institutions in the United States: Recommendations and reality. Journal of Higher Education, 74(3), 241.

Becton, J.B. & Schraeder, M. (2004). Participant input into rater selection: Potential effects on the quality and acceptance of ratings in the context of 360-degree feedback. Public Personnel Management, 33(1), 23.

Broadnax, W.D. (2000). Diversity and affirmative action in public service. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Brownell, M.T., Ross, D.D., Colon, E.P., & Mccallum, C.L. (2005). Critical features of special education teacher preparation: A comparison with general teacher education. Journal of Special Education, 38(4), 242.

Cite this Document:

"Diversity Issues In Schools That" (2008, March 27) Retrieved October 26, 2021, from

"Diversity Issues In Schools That" 27 March 2008. Web.26 October. 2021. <

"Diversity Issues In Schools That", 27 March 2008, Accessed.26 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Diversity Vermont Diversity Issues in Higher Education
Words: 1364 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Sports - College Paper #: 82037679

Diversity Vermont Diversity Issues in Higher Education and the University of Vermont How does this school present its interests in " diversity"(college's mission statement, diversity statement, website) The University of Vermont takes great pride in the diversity of its student population. The school courts students from throughout both the United States and the international community, creating an atmosphere in which all races, religions, ethnicities, nationalities, sexual orientations and genders are made to feel

Expanding Diversity Issues Without Violating the Hopwood
Words: 651 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Sports - College Paper #: 23577639

expanding diversity issues without violating the Hopwood decision. Draft a memo explaining ways to make the student body more diverse. MEMO: MAKING THE STUDENT BODY MORE DIVERSE There are several ways that the university can make the school more diverse without violating the Hopwood decision. The student body currently has 34% of undergraduates even though the university immediately brought its admission policies in line with the Hopwood Decision. The university is

Cultural Diversity Issue of Non-American Employees Communicating
Words: 4611 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 43058477

cultural diversity issue of non-American employees communicating frequently in their own native language creating an environment of sensitivity and bias amongst the non-Hispanic community. Handling Diversity in an Organization The contents of this paper focus on the cultural diversity involving Films Recovery Systems, an American company located at the heart of Chicago, Illinois. The paper takes an insight into the issue and also proposes solutions that can resolve the problem. The

Culture and Diversity Issues in
Words: 2845 Length: 9 Pages Topic: History - Asian Paper #: 13936527

Silence too is an important part of communication in Singapore. It is customary to pause before answering a question, to indicate that the person has given the question the appropriate thought and consideration that is needed. Westerners habit of responding quickly to a question, to Singaporeans, often indicates thoughtlessness and rude behavior. Their demeanor is typically calm, and Westerners more aggressive style is often seen as off putting ("Singapore:

Diversity Defining Diversity Is Defined
Words: 729 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 20002746

When school leadership values diversity and demonstrates the value of diversity the school is more likely to be characterized by diversity in the classroom. IV. Modeling Respect for Diversity Harris (2006) states in the work entitled: "BRAVO Principals" published by Education World that school principals "model respect for diversity when they engage their faculties in addressing issues of identity so that children have successful role models that represent all ethnic groups.

Diversity and Leadership Roles Diversity Typically Plays
Words: 594 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 94024657

Diversity and Leadership Roles Diversity typically plays a major role in leadership and administrative issues in a school setting. Many schools have a widely diverse student body, faculty, and administration, and diversity issues involving gender, ethnicity, religious affiliations, and even basic social perspectives occur on a daily basis (Howard, 2007). As a grade school principal I am often charged with helping different interest groups such as parents, students and teachers navigate