Elementary Education Mathematics Is One Thesis

Length: 10 pages Sources: 17 Subject: Teaching Type: Thesis Paper: #13573879 Related Topics: Algebra, Tennessee Williams, Early Childhood Education, Pro And Con
Excerpt from Thesis :


2005, 2)."

The article asserts that students benefit greatly from the use of calculators at the elementary school level. The research also explains that calculator use should be used in addition to traditional techniques from problem solving.

McAuliffe (2004) reiterates the aforementioned belief that the use of calculators at the elementary school level can be quite beneficial. The authors asserts that the majority of research has found that there are not any harmful effects that occur as a result of early calculator use. The author explains that the use of calculators simply serves as an enhancement to elementary school mathematics curriculum, when they are properly used. The author insists that this enhancement can be seen in the fact that students have more time to solve problems on a conceptual level. McAuliffe (2004) expounds upon this idea stating

"a simple four-function calculator will allow students to use whatever operation is appropriate in a problem, regardless of whether they are confident of their own skill at carrying out that operation." Here, the students experience a computational advantage and become more secure in their abilities. Computation is important specifically because it is necessary to solve many mathematical problems. The particular method used, however, whether it involves mental math, paper and pencil, or a calculator, is just one part of the computation process (McAuliffe

2004, 3) ."

The author goes on to explain that the other aspect of the computational process necessitates that students fully and have the capacity to determine the right numbers to use while completing computations. The author explains that really understanding mathematics requires proficiency in using different strategies to solve mathematic problems. As such the use of calculators permits students to think of mathematics in more abstract terms. That is "It allows children to solve problems whose solutions are within theoretical, but not computational, grasp (McAuliffe 2004, 3)."

Discovery is also seen as another benefit associated with the use of calculators in the classroom. In many cases students are introduced to aspects of mathematics that they never knew before. For instance, an article entitled "Clearing up the Confusion over Calculator Use in Grades K-5" explains that in the classroom setting some elementary students have discovered such things as negative numbers. The author explains.

"One student entered 6-8 and was curious about the displayed result, which was -2. The teacher used the opportunity to model negative numbers by extending the number line to .the left of 0 ("Clearing up the Confusion over Calculator Use in Grades K-5)." In this instance, the teacher was able to introduce students to a totally new concept. This concept would not have been discovered without the presence of a calculator.

There are also arguments for the use of calculators for very young students. This argument asserts that young students benefit greatly from the use of calculators because it allows them to recognize numbers in a new way. According to de Walle (2003) in small children "The calculator is a good instructional tool for numeral recognition. In addition to helping children with numerals, early activities can help develop familiarity with the calculator so that more complex activities are possible (de Walle 2003, 3) ." This particular author contends that calculators are beneficial to small children when they are beginning to learn about numbers and numerical recognition.

Overall the pros of using calculators in elementary school are inclusive of a knowledge of calculator usage, increased ability to solve mathematics problems, discovery, higher levels of abstract reasoning, and recognition of numbers. The research indicates that elementary school students that use calculators in combination with traditional forms of math instruction have higher levels of proficiency in math than those that rely on traditional instruction...


The overall consensus seems to be that the use of calculators is beneficial when properly implemented in the elementary school curriculum.

The Middle

In addition to those that advocate or oppose the use of calculators in elementary school, there are also those that believe that calculators should only be used in certain elementary school grades. That is they believe in the use of calculators in elementary school but they disagree that children as young as kindergartners should be allowed to use calculators.

These individuals believe that students should learn the fundamental facts of math before they are allowed to use calculators. In treating the use of calculators in elementary school in this manner, there is exposure to calculators but students also understand the processes behind mathematical computation. As it relates to this particular argument it is asserted that the emphasis should be on traditional practices as it pertains to mathematics education. However, once a fundamental understanding of numbers and basic mathematical processes are developed calculators can and should be introduced (Varol F. & Farran, 2007). A study conducted by Vanderbilt university found that "it is important children first learn how to calculate answers on their own, but after that initial phase, using calculators is a fine thing to do, even for basic multiplication facts (Vanderbilt University)." The study also found that students; fundamental understanding of mathematics was the key indicator in determining whether or not they were harmed or hurt by the use of calculators in mathematics. This particular study insists that the use of calculators is only harmful if the student has knot established how to find answers without the use of a calculator. That is the calculator simply enhances understanding, it is not responsible for gaining the understanding.

This particular stance is rather popular among parents and also many educators. One of the major problems with elementary school students and students at all levels is reliance upon technology. There is nothing wrong with the technology itself, in fact the technology can be quite beneficial, however there has to be a foundation present if the technology is to present any type of advantage. Teachers and parents alike seem to embrace this belief and in many school districts this is the approach that has been embraced.


The purpose of this discussion was to examine the various sentiments that exist as it pertains to the use of calculators in elementary school. The research found that the use of calculators at the elementary school level is an extremely controversial issue. There are those that support the use of calculators in elementary schools and those that oppose their use. On the one hand students can come to depend to much on calculators. On the other hand calculators can assist students in becoming more proficient math students. There is plenty of research to support both arguments.

The research specifically focused on the pros and cons of using calculators in elementary school. The cons of calculator use include dependency, the lack of mastery of fundamental arithmetic skills, inappropriate use of calculators and the effect of false progress. The most significant of these problems seems to be the lack of mastery of fundamental skills. The evidence seems to suggest that many students begin to depend on calculators to solve math problems and as such they do not master fundamental math skills. The research asserts that this leads to poor test scores and can have a negative impact on students as it pertains to their academic careers.

In addition to the cons of calculator use in elementary school we also examined the pros of the practice. The research suggest that calculator use at the elementary school level includes a knowledge of calculator usage, increased ability to solve mathematics problems, discovery, higher levels of abstract reasoning, and recognition of numbers. The most important of these advantages seems to be an increased ability to solve mathematics problems. The research indicates that calculator use increases student understanding of mathematics.

Works Cited

"Allowable Accommodations." http://tennessee.gov/education/assessment/doc/tsallowaccin.pdf

Brown, E.T., et. Al. (March 2007) Crutch or Catalyst: Teachers' Beliefs and Practices

Regarding Calculator Use in Mathematics Instruction. School Science and Mathematics v. 107 no. 3 p. 102-16

Cavanagh, S. (2008). Use of Calculators. Education Week, Vol. 28 Issue 7, p5-5,

Chval, K.B., Hicks, Sarah J.(Mar2009), . Teaching Children Mathematics, Vol. 15


7, p429-437,

de Walle J.A.V. (2003) Elementary and Middle School Mathematics. Teaching Developmentally.

Ellington. A.J. (Nov., 2003). A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Calculators on Students'

Achievement and Attitude Levels in Precollege Mathematics. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, Vol. 34, No. 5, pp. 433- 463 Author(s):

Goya, S. (2006) The Critical Need for skilled math Teachers. Phi Delta Kappan. Vol. 87

Issue 5, p370-372

Hoff, D.J. (2003) Math Divisions Have Chance of Lessening. Education Week. Vol. 22

Issue 19, p1,

Hoyles, C., Noss, R. And Kent P. (2004) On…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

"Allowable Accommodations." http://tennessee.gov/education/assessment/doc/tsallowaccin.pdf

Brown, E.T., et. Al. (March 2007) Crutch or Catalyst: Teachers' Beliefs and Practices

Regarding Calculator Use in Mathematics Instruction. School Science and Mathematics v. 107 no. 3 p. 102-16

Cavanagh, S. (2008). Use of Calculators. Education Week, Vol. 28 Issue 7, p5-5,
FOUNDATION. http://www.math.ksu.edu/~pietro/M320/Math05Intro.pdf
Know The Facts First, Study Finds. ScienceDaily. Retrieved April 22, 2009, from http://www.sciencedaily.com-/releases/2008/08/080819160203.htm

Cite this Document:

"Elementary Education Mathematics Is One" (2009, April 22) Retrieved December 8, 2021, from

"Elementary Education Mathematics Is One" 22 April 2009. Web.8 December. 2021. <

"Elementary Education Mathematics Is One", 22 April 2009, Accessed.8 December. 2021,

Related Documents
Elementary Education and Math Research
Words: 1119 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 24937253

The premise where the methods of instruction were carried out was a K-5 elementary school campus in Texas hosting 338 students. The other instrument was the portable mathematics and science lab, which provided the venue for methods course instruction. The adequacy of the data analysis procedures was captured. This is because the process of analyzing data involved all the stakeholders of the research. The use of diverse sources in

Education Is One of the Critical Aspects
Words: 1558 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 84392918

Education is one of the critical aspects in the society especially in the case of the United States. The success of education relates to the ability of the relevant authority to adopt and integrate effective and efficient educational policy with the aim of addressing goals and targets in relation to elements of the society such as economy, politics, and social spheres. One of the critical federal educational policies is

Elementary Education Field Putnam/Boces Science
Words: 2671 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 51147544

("Science 21-Update Grade 6, Unit 4," 2009) There is important background information in store for the teachers in this area. This particular activity concentrates on the notion that the natural system of the earth possesses a balance and the different components or members of any one system should react and work in close association in order to achieve and keep the balance. It is important to understand that an ecosystem

Elementary School Instruction
Words: 2275 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 66525870

Student Achievement at the Elementary Level Elementary education is one of the most important stages of schooling today. This is so because this level of education provides students with important basis points that they can use throughout their lives, not only during their secondary and tertiary education, but also in their adult lives and the workplace. Hence, ensuring a top level of achievement at the elementary level is highly important. The challenge

Education of Abbasid
Words: 4250 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 57391060

Education of Abbasid Today, the majority of high school students hope to finish college one day. This is a realistic dream for many, as there is an established education system that gives students a choice of career paths and training. The modern world if full of universities and training centers. However, the world was not always like this. Many centuries ago, education was limited to the privileged and even the privileged

Education Review It Is Now
Words: 4295 Length: 14 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 27545561

It is now recognized that individuals learn in different ways -- they perceive and process information in various ways. The learning styles theory suggests that the way that children acquire information has more to do with whether the educational experience is slanted toward their specific style of learning than their intelligence. The foundation of the learning styles methodology is based in the classification of psychological types. The research demonstrates that,