Experts Believe That The Battle Term Paper

Length: 9 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Drama - World Type: Term Paper Paper: #70592033 Related Topics: Spartan, Military Training, Persian Empire, Physical Fitness
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Thucydides was an Athenian, but had very little reason for offering a distorted view of the war that was eventually won by Sparta.

Jackson states, "Thucydides was an active participant in Athens for a time, he had a network of contacts, while banished to Thrace he observed the war there first hand, and as an Athenian exile he traveled along the Peloponnese" (Jackson, p.175). Thucydides wrote of a Sparta that used an eight deep fighting stance against the Athenians who could not, or did not, adapt to a style that would lead to victory when battling against that type of tactic.

Other army tactics began to be used after the Peloponnesian War, many of which were introduced by the Spartans in order to maintain their military might. One such tactic would play a key role in the battle of Leuctra.

Of particular relevance to Leuctra, however, was the battle of Nemea in 394 B.C. In this action the right wings of both armies began by moving to the right with the aim of encircling their opponents. Encirclement was not new, but the deliberate attempt to prepare for it in the approach march certainly was" (Cawkwell, p. 399)

The Spartan army adapted tactics and techniques designed to overpower, overwhelm or overcome their targeted enemies but their enemies learned from these engagements as well. When Sparta adapted an eight man deep wedge formation that forced their opponents into attacking into the strongest part of the army, other armies adapted the same tactic and took it a step further, sometimes lining up 12 and 16 deep. Sparta in the battle of Leuctra "abandoned their ancient favored depth of eight and formed up twelve deep, and sought to move to their right" (Cawkwell, p. 399) most likely in anticipation of the same movement they experienced approximately twenty years earlier at Nemea. The Thebans, however, did not react accordingly. Instead they piled their army fifty-deep and moved to the left, leaving no room for Spartan encirclement. "It is clear that the Spartans were confronted by a wholly new tactical situation. They fought with great bravery but were utterly out-generalled" (Cawkwell, p. 399).

Where Cawkwell sees the Spartans as being entirely 'outgeneralled" other observers might see a society that had run its course, that had self-destructed by violating its own standards.

An example of one of the primary violations was the one that allowed for no silver or gold currency in Sparta, instead the created iron spits that were to be used as payment for almost every conceivable item. Other societies, however, did not take kindly to iron spits for payment. It became necessary for Spartan government to hold a certain amount of gold and silver in order to send ambassadors, couriers and other individuals outside the country. As Sparta became rich, conquering more territories and city-states the wealth rolled in and many of the officials benefited...


Many of the citizenry wished to participate and share in that wealth. Classes and divisions were formed in Sparta that had previously been disdained. Such divisive actions would likely cause even more greed and envy, and the government's grip on the citizens would be weakened. Sparta was no exception to the rule, it is tough to maintain a lifestyle as demanding as the Spartan one was without complete loyalty. Citizens who are concentrating on gathering wealth are not likely to concentrate on being trained to go off and fight, no matter how honorable it is. The filthy lucre is more beautiful than death.

These same citizens are probably equally likely to send someone else off in their stead, and most of the time it is not going to be a son that they send.

If the lure of wealth is what keeps them at home, it also allows them the opportunity to pay for someone else to protect them, or to find and conquer new territories. Many times those that are sent in a Spartan's stead would be men from other cultures or countries. Their incentive in accomplishing any objective would be to become a free citizen of Sparta, and that is a lot of incentive. However, would it be enough incentive to fight to the death, as most Spartiates had been raised to believe was the most honorable event in one's life? Probably not, and decidedly not if we are to believe that the battle of Leuctra was fought by only 1000 Spartiates, with the rest of the army comprised of citizens from other cultures.

It makes sense that Sparta was defeated at that time and place. They had fallen victim to the baubles of their own success, never realizing until it was too late that society loves to witness the big boy on the block biting the dust, no matter who that big boy happens to be.

Works Cited

Cawkwell, G.L. (1983) the Decline of Sparta, Classical Quarterly, Vol. 33, Issue ii, pp. 385-400

Hind, a. (2006) Weaponry: It took a humiliating major defeat to convince the Spartans to adopt the bow and arrow, Military…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Cawkwell, G.L. (1983) the Decline of Sparta, Classical Quarterly, Vol. 33, Issue ii, pp. 385-400

Hind, a. (2006) Weaponry: It took a humiliating major defeat to convince the Spartans to adopt the bow and arrow, Military History, Vol. 23, Issue 1, pp. 12-14

Jackson, M.W., (2007) Cracking the Thucydides code, Antioch Review, Vol. 65, Number 1, pp. 173-184

Walker, M., (2001) Bush's Choice: Athens or Sparta, World Policy, Vol. 18, Number 2, pp. 1-9

Cite this Document:

"Experts Believe That The Battle" (2007, November 07) Retrieved October 17, 2021, from

"Experts Believe That The Battle" 07 November 2007. Web.17 October. 2021. <>

"Experts Believe That The Battle", 07 November 2007, Accessed.17 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Battle of Midway, a Naval Battle Fought
Words: 3803 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Drama - World Paper #: 40227286

Battle of Midway, a naval battle fought near the Central Pacific island of Midway, was the most important victory for the United States in World War 2. Before this battle Japanese forces were on the offensive, gradually capturing territory throughout Asia and the Pacific. Japan was now the dominant naval force after severely damaging the U.S. Pacific Fleet during the attack of Pearl Harbor six months prior (Newman). Japan

Battle of the Aleutians a Cold Wake Up Call
Words: 12983 Length: 50 Pages Topic: Drama - World Paper #: 45023850

Termed "the forgotten battle," the Battle for the Aleutians represented the only instance during World War II when the Japanese occupied American soil and the campaign exacted a significant toll of American lives and treasure. The Aleutians became strategically significant during World War II for the Japanese as well as the United States, but the American preparations in anticipation of this attack were woefully inadequate. Despite a U.S. naval base

Battles of Gettysburg and Antietam
Words: 1418 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Drama - World Paper #: 82986125

However, Lee won out, and the solid line attacked. It was a fatal decision as Union forces literally mowed down Confederate troops by the thousands. One historian later concluded, "Apparently it never occurred to him that the position [the Union line on Cemetery Ridge] could not be taken" (Wert 101). While the numbers vary, most people agree the South lost between 3,900 to 4,500 men, while the Union lost about

Battle for Hue: Tet 1968
Words: 1241 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Drama - World Paper #: 87516972

He writes, "The M-60 opened up again. Carter steeped through the rubble, found his 3.5, and started putting out rounds" (51). There is no doubt these men were brave in battle and took the brunt of what the war had to offer, but the author often seems to place them on a pedestal or look up to them so much that he is clearly biased toward their actions and

Setting and Conflict in Ellison S Battle Royal
Words: 1562 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 53637258

Battle Royal In Ralph Ellison's "Battle Royal" the narrator states that "all my life I had been looking for something, and everywhere I turned someone tried to tell me what it was" (442). The narrator admits that he accepted their answers even though he knew they were not logical -- and this compulsion to bow down to or to submit to an external force in a setting that is wholly antagonistic

What if History Was Different
Words: 2215 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Archeology Paper #: 17531573

Battle of Waterloo was the concluding and pivotal action of the Napoleonic Wars that successfully put an end to the French control of the European landmass and brought about extreme changes in the political frontiers and control of Europe. Taken place on June 18, 1814, near Waterloo, which is now known as Belgium, the battle levels as a huge turning point in present history.[footnoteRef:1] It is clear that the Battle