Friend Or Foe Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: History - Israel Type: Essay Paper: #41494059 Related Topics: Espionage, Israel, Military Intelligence, Academia
Excerpt from Essay :


Israel collects intelligence on American foreign policy related to Israel and the Middle East, as well as on scientific and technological developments, including those from the private sector. The gathering of intelligence from a foreign ally is neither an unusual nor new practice. Moreover, the United States reciprocates the favor and likewise gathers intelligence on Israel. The Untied States certainly cannot expect Israel or any other nation to refrain from using surveillance, while at the same time gathering intelligence against those very same nations. For Israel, areas of general interest for Israeli intelligence collectors include military and economic policy and of course, intelligence services themselves such as the CIA (Caramela, 2014). Intelligence is used to bolster Israel's own national security, military, and technological capabilities. The methods Israel uses to gather intelligence are varied and range from computer hacking to communications surveillance. Reasons for gathering intelligence on an ally are generally straightforward, such as specific desires for additional or supplemental information not easily or directly attainable through standard diplomatic means. Although critics of the Israeli intelligence gathering against the United States claim the act represents serious threats to national security, Israel remains one of the lowest threat nations to the United States as well as one of its strategic foreign allies. Therefore, the United States can and already does accept Israeli efforts, so long as those efforts do not directly infringe upon the goals of American domestic and foreign policies.



During the Cold War, Israel engaged in several spurious intelligence gathering campaigns against the United States. Some of those campaigns failed utterly, and were potentially dangerous, such as the Zalman Shapiro project, in which a Manhattan Project engineer funneled enriched uranium to Israel for several years (Caramela, 2014). Other high profile efforts include the use of American citizen Jonathan Pollard, who provided the Israeli government with satellite imagery specifically depicting Arab and Soviet states. Given the direct threats to Israeli national security posed by both Arab and Soviet states during the Cold War, it is understandable that Israel would be hungry for the most robust, detailed, accurate, and thorough intelligence possible. Yet because of his collecting and disseminating "tens of thousands of secrets" for Israel, Pollard was sentenced to life in prison in 1986, a move that polarized both Americans and Israelis (Stein, 2014).

There has been recent talk about potentially releasing Pollard from prison early. The Pollard case represents somewhat of a turning point in American-Israeli relations because it highlighted the ongoing issue of mutual espionage. According to Giraldi (2008), the Pollard case led to a "gentleman's agreement" between the United States and Israel to stop mutual intelligence gathering; the agreement has been largely deemed a "farce," as neither nation has stopped. Since being accused of spying on its allies like Germany in the wake of the Edward Snowden leaks, the Obama administration has made a point to acknowledge and defend its policy of spying on its allies (Nakamura & DeYoung, 2013). Obama points out that allies are "seeking additional insight beyond what's available through open sources…And if that weren't the case, then there would be no use for an intelligence service," (Nakamura & DeYoung, 2013). A more honest and open approach such as that suggested by President Obama would be a better approach than to attempt to artificially or hypocritically curtail espionage efforts.

Both the United States and Israel have needs for more robust intelligence. Given this, it is no small wonder why the United…

Sources Used in Documents:


Caramela, S. (2014). The impact of Israeli intelligence collection on the United States. Retrieved online:

Giraldi, P. (2008). The spy who loves us. The American Conservative. 2 June, 2008. Retrieved online:

Ketcham, C. (2009). Israeli spying in the United States. Counterpunch. Retrieved online:

Nakamura, D. & DeYoung, K. (2013). Obama defends U.S. intelligence-gathering tactics. The Washington Post. 1 July, 2013. Retrieved online:
National Counterintelligence Center (2000). Annual report to Congress on foreign economic collection and industrial espionage. Retrieved online:
Stein, J. (2014). Israel won't stop spying on the U.S. Newsweek. 6 May, 2014. Retrieved online:

Cite this Document:

"Friend Or Foe" (2015, March 28) Retrieved January 23, 2022, from

"Friend Or Foe" 28 March 2015. Web.23 January. 2022. <>

"Friend Or Foe", 28 March 2015, Accessed.23 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Internet: Friend or Foe to
Words: 1061 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 92446149

Hence the price to "rent" a book for a semester is about $50 for a $100 book." (Varian, 2005) This means that some author's books, if there is a sure demand for them on the resale market, can benefit from a more accessible second hand book market, where before students would simply share books with one another, or photocopy the necessary pages, despite the inconvenience, because of the textbook's

Navies in American Revolution for Hundreds of
Words: 4742 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Literature - Latin-American Paper #: 12678935

Navies in American Revolution For hundreds of years, maritime expansion represented the only way to reach distant shores, to attack enemies across channels of water, to explore uncharted territories, to make trade with regional neighbors and to connect the comprised empires. Leading directly into the 20th century, this was the chief mode of making war, maintaining occupations, colonizing lands and conducting the transport of goods acquired by trade or force. Peter

Supply and Demand Friend or Foe
Words: 1297 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 78721301

Supply Demand Supply, Demand, Oil and the U.S. Economy Few forces have a greater or more direct impact on the U.S. economy than the global oil trade. The industrial expansion of the American way of life has been largely dependent on an ever-greater consumption of gasoline, the vast majority of which must be imported from other nations. The result is a tumultuous history of oil trade both in terms of economics and

Master & Commander - Patrick
Words: 764 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Weather Paper #: 32348623

'No such passengers aboard, sir,' he reported (243, Chapter 7, last page). Who is admitted to a ship has a strict hierarchy -- and the captain's word is law in terms of who is allowed on board, as is seen in the above quotation. My moneyman wants to send his son to sea -- you have a vacancy for a youngster; it is as simple as that (266, Chapter 8, p.

Winston Churchill's "The Influenza" in
Words: 992 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 60267969

The country's warriors are described as "symbolic of initial human strength." Once again the adjective is of importance. The word "initial" signifies the state before disease. Once the disease has its hold, however, all human strength falters and the struggle becomes futile and indeed fatal. Churchill also uses a number of symbolic assertions in association with the disease itself. These include "loathsome hand and poisonous sting" and "poisonous breath and

Role and Importance of the
Words: 5946 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 47971090

Most individuals fail to appreciate life to the fullest because they concentrate on being remembered as some of the greatest humans who ever lives. This makes it difficult for them to enjoy the simple pleasures in life, considering that they waste most of their time trying to put across ideas that are appealing to the masses. While many did not manage to produce ideas that survived more than them, others