Horkheimer/Adorno, Benjamin, Lowenthal Each Of The Writers Essay

PAGES
2
WORDS
877
Cite

Horkheimer/Adorno, Benjamin, Lowenthal Each of the writers in this week's readings -- Horkheimer and Adorno in their essay "The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception," Walter Benjamin in his essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," and Leo Lowenthal in his essay "Historical Perspectives of Popular Culture" -- are writing from a mid-twentieth-century perspective on what new media are doing to "culture" overall. To a certain degree we could summarize their perspectives by suggesting that Horkheimer and Adorno, as well as Benjamin, take an overall pessimistic stance, while Lowenthal takes a moderately more optimistic stance. But in all cases, the issues raised by these authors still seem to be with us more than half a century later.

Horkheimer and Adorno begin with their provocative title, "The Culture Industry." Their purpose is to demonstrate that cultural products have become subsumed in a capitalist -- which is to say industrialist -- paradigm. Their concern is that this new paradigm -- which is concerned with large-scale production and mass consumption -- has replaced the older system of what was called "art." They challenge the notion that popular art -- for example, Hollywood cinema -- is popular because it is in any way good or valuable art. Instead they see it as eliminating all elements of conflict (where the industrial products of Hollywood might...

...

For Horkheimer and Adorno, the dominance of Hollywood is close to the dangerous alliance between national ideology and capitalist-industrial production in a society like Nazi Germany: the passive consumption of Hollywood products conceals a goal of "obedience to the social hierarchy" (131), and they compare Hollywood to explicitly Nazi policies where "advertising becomes art and nothing else, just as Goebbels -- with foresight -- combines them, l'art pour l'art, advertising for its own sake, a pure representation of social power" (163).
Benjamin has a similar critique, but he focuses less on the concealed ideology of mass-produced art (as Horkheimer and Adorno do), and instead focuses on the technological changes. For Benjamin, art once had an "aura" which comprised both a sense of uniqueness but also a sense of authenticity. As the invention of photography starts to have an effect on the art of painting, however, it becomes clear that the "aura" of art has become threatened -- in Benjamin's words, "the instant the criterion of authenticity…

Cite this Document:

"Horkheimer Adorno Benjamin Lowenthal Each Of The Writers" (2012, June 03) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/horkheimer-adorno-benjamin-lowenthal-each-111132

"Horkheimer Adorno Benjamin Lowenthal Each Of The Writers" 03 June 2012. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/horkheimer-adorno-benjamin-lowenthal-each-111132>

"Horkheimer Adorno Benjamin Lowenthal Each Of The Writers", 03 June 2012, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/horkheimer-adorno-benjamin-lowenthal-each-111132

Related Documents

It helps business people to be able to separate business activities from their emotions. This is what is referred to as emotional intelligence. Some of the characteristics of emotional intelligence are confidence, emotional awareness, collaboration and empathy. There is also political awareness and adaptability Bodenhorn, 2003() The business person also needs to be able to read the emotions of other in order to know the right time to push for

To put it in simple terms, Mr. James O. Freedman who has written the book "Liberal Education and the Public Interest" (2003) says in an article in the New York Times that "A liberal education is what teaches people how to write and how to think and makes them much more valuable in the job market over a 40-year career than graduates of a preprofessional program." Further, he adds "All

Liberal Arts Education Should College Students be required to take Courses Outside of Their Major Field of Study? An education that lacks of a world view may be more harmful than meets the eye. One could reasonably argue that the question of whether diversified educational background has value is highly dependent on what you value. There are a multitude of monetary reasons for an incoming freshman to concentrate on a specific field

Debate between Liberal Arts and Job Preparation Skills Liberal arts skills and job preparation or vocational skills are the two categories of the eight essential purposes of higher education. These two categories of purposes have had a significant effect on the curriculum of higher education over the years. Liberal arts skills are one of the most important aspects and central purpose of higher education given that it incorporates seven of the

If one has been "trained" in the ways of poverty, left no opportunity to do other than react to his or her environment, what is needed is a beginning, not repetition. The humanities teach us to think reflectively, to begin, to deal with the new as it occurs to us, to dare. If the multi-generational poor are to make the leap out of poverty, it will require a new

Art Education in America
PAGES 10 WORDS 3423

Bauhaus After World War I, the nation state of Germany under the direction of architect Walter Gropius created a "consulting art center for industry and the trades" (Bayer 12). Called Bauhaus, "house for building," the school combined the role of artisans and craftspeople and included everything from architecture to theater to typography. When the school was forced to close during the Nazi regime in 1932, many of its artists moved to