Human Resource Management Introduction "America's possibilities are limitless, for we possess all the qualities that this world without boundaries demands: youth and drive; diversity and openness; an endless capacity for risk and a gift for reinvention. My fellow Americans, we are made for this moment, and we will seize it – so long as we seize it together…" (President Barack Obama, Inaugural Address, 1/21/2013). The job of a human relations manager in the 21st century goes well beyond hiring and training staff. An important part of an HR manager's duties includes working towards the creation of a diversified employee workforce. This paper echoes part of what President Obama asserted: to achieve success the U.S. will depend on "diversity and openness." The diversity of America's workplace in part depends on the role of women, and this paper delves into that issue and references the available literature. In fact an article in USA Today (Petrecca, 2011) points to the fact that women are being recruited to provide executive leadership in some of America's biggest corporations – but they still lag far behind in executive opportunities.
Human Resource Management
"America's possibilities are limitless, for we possess all the qualities that this world without boundaries demands: youth and drive; diversity and openness; an endless capacity for risk and a gift for reinvention. My fellow Americans, we are made for this moment, and we will seize it -- so long as we seize it together…"
(President Barack Obama, Inaugural Address, 1/21/2013).
The job of a human relations manager in the 21st century goes well beyond hiring and training staff. An important part of an HR manager's duties includes working towards the creation of a diversified employee workforce. This paper echoes part of what President Obama asserted: to achieve success the U.S. will depend on "diversity and openness." The diversity of America's workplace in part depends on the role of women, and this paper delves into that issue and references the available literature. In fact an article in USA Today (Petrecca, 2011) points to the fact that women are being recruited to provide executive leadership in some of America's biggest corporations -- but they still lag far behind in executive opportunities.
Thesis: There must be evidence that the workplace is becoming more diverse vis-a-vis women in positions of authority whose compensation is equal to what males are paid to do the same work. However the evidence to date shows that only 3% of Fortune 500 companies have women as CEOs, an unacceptably small number. The U.S.A. Today article is correct when it asserts that women are not getting the respect (nor the compensation) they deserve in the executive field.
Record number of female CEOs in Fortune "500" companies
The USA Today article points out that more women took the reins of Fortune 500 companies in 2012 "than ever before" (Petrecca, p. 1). The author mentions several corporations that placed females in executive positions in 2012, including: IBM's appointment of Virginia Rometty as CEO; and Heather Bresch has been appointed CEO of the pharmaceutical company Mylan. However, while those appointments are impressive, and while a total of 18 women are now running Fortune 500 companies (the previous high was 16), "…the gender gap between men and women in the workplace remains vast," Petrecca writes. Females are "…struggling to get the mentors they need and the pay to equal their male counterparts" (Petrecca, p. 1).
Cynthia Good who is CEO of the women's business newsletter, "Little Pink Book," said the advancement of "…key women in business is stalled" (Petrecca, p. 1). In the 3,049 publically traded companies in the U.S., there were (as of 2012) 98 female CEOs; that is 3.2% of the total number of CEOs in publicly traded companies. "We've really flat-lined," according to Debbie Soon, the senior VP of marketing and strategy of Catalyst (Petrecca, p. 1). Over the past five years, Soon emphasized, "there's been hardly any progress" (Petrecca, p. 1).
Tia Gaynor explains in her PowerPoint that diversity is about "…understanding each other and moving beyond simple tolerance to embracing and celebrating the rich dimensions of diversity contained within each individual" (Gaynor). She goes on to assert that "…there is an underrepresentation of women and minorities in certain positions and/or agencies" due to the "artificial barriers that block the advancement of women" to CEO and other managerial and executive positions (Gaynor).
There are several of those barriers that are holding women back, according to Petrecca's article. First, many companies have had a history of male-only leadership,"…so a masculine management pattern is often the default style," said Quinetta Roberson, who is a professor of management at Villanova School of Business (Petrecca, p. 2). The management style in place at many of those firms is to sanction a certain kind of behavior -- "to be very aggressive, unattached and direct" -- and if a woman doesn't have that aggressiveness she won't be able to climb the corporate ladder and reach the top. In other words, diversity in those kinds of companies depends on following the trends of the workplace culture, not on fairness or quality of effort.
Another reason for the barrier that is keeping women from attaining executive positions is that "…Men…tend to tout their accomplishments more than women," according to Good. Hence men are often promoted and hired "…based on potential," but women tend to be more "reticent" and so they get hired "…based on if they can do the job" (Petrecca, p. 2).
A third reason women tend to be left in underling positions is that men are much more apt to quickly say "yes" to a "…career-enhancing assignment that could affect their personal life" -- but women are more thoughtful when an opportunity is presented. They don't immediately say "yes" until they have given thought to "…how the opportunity could affect home situations" (children need caring and elders are often cared for in the home) (Petrecca, p. 2).
Author Norma Riccucci explains that affirmative action was a program set up to create situations where inclusion and diversity come into play. But affirmative action was (and is) "the cause of endless controversy and public debate" vis-a-vis its use as a tool or as a social policy (Riccucci, 2001, p. 3). And since many states have abandoned affirmative action (calling it "reverse discrimination"), the next step "…on the continuum" is "managing diversity," Riccucci continues. The author explains that "the key" to a diverse workforce (that certainly allows women to advance according to their abilities and experience) is the ability of management to address "communication breakdowns, misunderstandings, and even hostilities" that can result from a diverse workforce (p. 3). What Riccucci is suggesting is that men in many instances may not be comfortable being supervised by a woman. There is no doubt that in some male-dominated workplace environments there would be hostility towards a woman executive or manager.
Meanwhile, Rometty recounts a learning situation that happened during her career. Early in her career, Rometty was offered a "big job" she wasn't sure she was competent to accept. She told her boss that she wasn't sure she had the experience and that she would think it over before saying "yes" to the offer (Petrecca, p. 2). After explaining to her husband about the offer and how she responded her husband said: "Do you think a man would have ever answered the question that way?"
You’re 81% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.