Verified Document

Immigration Law And Policy: An Article Critique

Workplaces that are dangerous for immigrant workers are equally dangerous for their U.S.-born counterparts who work beside illegal immigrants. Illegal immigrants may come to U.S. shores with the aim of bettering their lives, but instead find themselves in poorly-paid, dead end, and unsafe jobs without access to legal recourse or health insurance -- and increasingly, U.S. workers are finding themselves in the same position. "The immigration controversy revolves around questions of national identity, security in a post-Sept.-11 world and the workings of a $12 trillion economy. Illegal immigrants are essential workers on American farms, in hotels and restaurants and on construction sites. An estimated 7.2 million illegal [immigrants] provide much of the unskilled muscle that the U.S.A.'s Information Age economy requires: 36% of insulation workers, 29% of farm...

All of these industries, not coincidentally, are some of the poorest-paid arenas of the U.S. economy. And not only is the pay poor, but there are few opportunities for workers to advance within such business or to obtain union representation. Unionization is difficult in industries dominated by illegal workers despite the efforts of legal employees to organize. Illegal workers are often, for obvious reasons, unwilling to take a very public stance for higher wages and benefits such as health insurance.
Instead of supporting the 'right' of individuals to work illegally in the U.S., it is more important to ask why workers immigrate in the first place and allow themselves to suffer such unjust conditions. Immigrants almost invariably come from nations where there has been a breakdown of the political

Sources used in this document:
Lax immigration policies allow immigrants to be exploited for their cheap labor. "The broken immigration system has allowed employers to create an underclass of workers, which has effectively reduced working standards for all workers. Immigrant workers are over-represented in the highest risk, lowest paid jobs" of the meat-processing, restaurant, and landscaping industries ("Responsible reform," AFL-CIO, 2006). The U.S. Department of Labor found that American poultry processing plants were 100% non-compliant with federal wage and hour laws. The presence of illegal workers in these industries has effectively created a workforce that is inclined to tolerate often horrific abuses of safety and sanitary precautions, as well as 'missed' paychecks or unpaid overtime. Furthermore, "the Department of Labor also estimated more than half of the country's garment factories violate wage and hour laws, and more than 75% violate health and safety laws" ("Responsible reform," AFL-CIO, 2006). Workplaces that are dangerous for immigrant workers are equally dangerous for their U.S.-born counterparts who work beside illegal immigrants. Illegal immigrants may come to U.S. shores with the aim of bettering their lives, but instead find themselves in poorly-paid, dead end, and unsafe jobs without access to legal recourse or health insurance -- and increasingly, U.S. workers are finding themselves in the same position.

"The immigration controversy revolves around questions of national identity, security in a post-Sept.-11 world and the workings of a $12 trillion economy. Illegal immigrants are essential workers on American farms, in hotels and restaurants and on construction sites. An estimated 7.2 million illegal [immigrants] provide much of the unskilled muscle that the U.S.A.'s Information Age economy requires: 36% of insulation workers, 29% of farm hands and 27% of butchers" (Lynch & Woodyard 2006). All of these industries, not coincidentally, are some of the poorest-paid arenas of the U.S. economy. And not only is the pay poor, but there are few opportunities for workers to advance within such business or to obtain union representation. Unionization is difficult in industries dominated by illegal workers despite the efforts of legal employees to organize. Illegal workers are often, for obvious reasons, unwilling to take a very public stance for higher wages and benefits such as health insurance.

Instead of supporting the 'right' of individuals to work illegally in the U.S., it is more important to ask why workers immigrate in the first place and allow themselves to suffer such unjust conditions. Immigrants almost invariably come from nations where there has been a breakdown of the political
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Constitutionality of Arizona Immigration Law SB 1070
Words: 2521 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Arizona SB 1070 On January 13, 2010 Senator Russell Pearce, representative of District 18 in Mesa, introduced Senate Bill 1070 which stated as it's intent to make attrition through enforcement the public policy of the state of Arizona. In support of this goal, the state would seek to enforce all federal immigration laws in an effort to deter "the unlawful entry and presence of illegal aliens and economic activity by illegal

Arizona Immigration Law SB1070
Words: 2391 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Arizona Immigration Law SB1070 This work in writing examines Arizona's SB1070 Immigration Law and how this law has impacted the state of Arizona, the citizens of Arizona, and the U.S. In its entirety as well as the conflicting views on SB1070 and seeks to determine is SB1070 is adherent to the tenants of federal immigration law. Arizona Immigration Law SB1070 The objective of this work in writing is to briefly explain Arizona's SB1070

Arizona Immigration Law Is One
Words: 2336 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

The hypothesis that certain black persons viewed racism as an all round phenomenon that occurs in many forms was tested. Other black persons viewed and experienced racism in many other different ways. This suggested that the act of racism is more in the mind of the specific victim than the actual fact in the objective reality. This highlighted out the fact that if white individuals were in the same

New Arizona Immigration Law Raises
Words: 620 Length: 2 Document Type: Article Review

Though the specter of racism will continue to underscore the current controversy, many Democratic politicians will avoid making such strong accusations at such an early stage. The mid-term elections are approaching and the Democrats want to preserve or increase their thin majority in Congress. The Democrats are poised to achieve important objectives such as financial regulation and energy policy in the coming year. An eruption of racial tensions at this

Education Law, Policy and Social Justice
Words: 3232 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Education Law Policy and Social Justice Mother Tongue Instruction The population of students receiving their instruction in another language apart from their mother tongue is increasing as a consequence of the increased migration. Indeed, as Bingol (2012) points out, “migration and language are clearly linked issues…. because the language of instruction in the schools is different from the language spoken at home, some arrangements must be done for these children in

Immigration Policy Discussion and Argument
Words: 1143 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Another state in the U.S., Utah, after the law enforcement which was delayed by the Arizona court, this state has adopted another option regarding the immigration policy for the state. The governor of the state said that Utah is not a state where the illegal immigrants can move and have jobs without having the fear for being deported, this is how should be (MSNBC, 2010).The Utah has a different model

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now