Learning Reading Comprehension Strategies Article Critique

Length: 4 pages Subject: Sociology - Social Work Type: Article Critique Paper: #45111792 Related Topics: Learning Styles, Learning, Reading, Learning Experience
Excerpt from Article Critique :

¶ … Technology-Based Teacher Training and Teacher-Led Classroom Implementation on Learning Reading Comprehension Strategies

Summary of Article and Meaning

This study was done to examine the efficiency of an expertly advanced comprehensive reading comprehension strategies program. The purpose was to compare it to the traditional reading comprehension instruction which was offered to over 800 fourth and fifth graders. The study was done using 34 classrooms in the United States. Also, the treatment involved a strong, technology-founded teacher training component in addition to extremely encouraging materials that would be used for 53 classroom-delivered student instructions. The study utilized a research design which was a randomized trial performed at the classroom level. It was done with classes unsystematically apportioned to either the treatment which (classroom n=16) or the control made up of (classroom n=17) circumstances. Hierarchical Linear Modeling was executed on student success statistics, nested inside classrooms within treatment situations, for the classes that were intact. Hierarchical Linear Modeling analyses using experimenter-designed achievement tests as the result variable was able to display an important effect for disorder. However, the students in the treatment condition were the ones that scored higher than those students who were in the control condition through all the different student groups which were comprised of gender English Language proficiency and ethnicity. The article tried to make the point that there are a lot of U.S. students that are not doing that well in reading. It points out that students are not developing the proper sophisticated reading comprehension skills needed in order to be successful in the 21st century. The article explains that the U.S. economy is demanding a more universally higher level of learning achievement than at any previous point in history, and it is rational to believe that literacy stresses will increase in the future.

On the other hand, the article stresses the fact that while the demand for a more sophisticated reading comprehension skills is in demand and increasing, the reading abilities of U.S. students have not been doing that well. Their comprehension skills stayed these same, they hardly changed and they stayed unchanged for over the past 30. The article talks about the specific issue that is motivating the research talked about in the study which is that fact that there are not many U.S. students which are being taught the reading comprehension policies they need in order to do the classy reading essential in today's world. The article supported this claim by mentioning that teaching reading comprehension strategies to students was not a part of the entire language program, which seriously dominated in U.S. classrooms during the course of most of the previous decade, and as a result teaching comprehension strategies was just not an urgency during that time....


The article also stressed that teachers have not been sufficiently trained when it comes to teach reading comprehension tactics. Also with the training, teaching comprehension is extremely stimulating. For most teachers, positively teaching comprehension policies is dependent on having proper and influential materials in order to use in teaching the policies.

The authors even talk about how over the past 15 years, there has been a considerable body of concept and research which has reinforced two methods to teaching comprehension strategies. The authors call them the "direct explanation of strategies" and "transactional strategies instruction." The article explains that both of these strategies have been effective but that direct explanation of strategies has been recurrently authenticated and recommended over the past two decades.

The Critique

1. Citation in APA

All of the citations were done in APA style and they were also referenced correctly.

2. Key points in Abstract

The abstract did mention some key points which were that the research design was a randomized trial at the classroom level and Hierarchical Linear Modeling was performed on student achievement data.

3. Introduction

The authors sort of stated the research problem in a vague way so it needed to be re-worded. There was not any theoretical perspective mentioned in the paper. Also, there were no existing or research gaps in the article. The authors clearly specify their hypotheses concerning the results of the research. There were three research questions written as hypothesis.

4. Method

a. Research design and variables

i. Research design

The design of this research study is openly specified as "being quasi-experimental with a pre-test, post-test control group design."

ii. Independent variables

The independent variables in this study are clearly engaged in that the in servicing of each of the control groups was methodologically assumed. Moreover, each treatment was piloted freely of the other and even though each of them allocated with metacognitive skills, for each was developed in order to attain those skills using very diverse methods.

iii. Dependent Variables

It did not mention anything about dependent variables.

b. Description of Sample

i. Sampling Procedure

The technique of sampling involved by the authors appears less than useable. That is to say, the authors made no effort to control the analyzing of matters into the three sample groups. What appears to be worse is the authors permitted the subjects themselves to select among the groups.

ii. Sample Size

Thus, the sample size is fairly disrelated to the instant population from where it all started from. iii. Attrition However, there was not anything mentioned about attrition.

c. Measures

i. Rationale for selection

When it came down to rationale for selection the authors did not make any comment in regards to it.

ii. Evidence of Reliability/Validity

The idea that both of the experimental groups were given totally different materials has grave effects on the validity of the study findings. The internal validity of the test appears to be fairly positive. Certainly, the researchers take great pains to make certain this and they openly outline their exertions in the development of their observation as well.

iii. Description of Measures

The authors put together a survey style type of observation tool which was used four times for to each experimental group…

Cite this Document:

"Learning Reading Comprehension Strategies" (2015, October 18) Retrieved January 18, 2022, from

"Learning Reading Comprehension Strategies" 18 October 2015. Web.18 January. 2022. <

"Learning Reading Comprehension Strategies", 18 October 2015, Accessed.18 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Reading Comprehension There Is an
Words: 2948 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 3116509

One counterargument to the practice of teaching vocabulary is that children learn the meanings of many words by experiencing those words in the actual world and in text without explicit instruction. Unfortunately, such incidental learning is filled with possible problems. The definitions learned range from richly contextualized and more than sufficient, to incomplete to wrong. Children do develop knowledge of vocabulary through incidental contact with new words they read. This

Reading Comprehension Among Middle School
Words: 1667 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 30253806

The Title I reading instructor will become familiar with the Plato Learning content library. The Title 1 reading instructor will begin supplementing classroom instruction with the mini classroom lab using software from Plato Learning. Title I reading instructor will assess classroom performance and modify lab use accordingly. The STAR Reading test results will be evaluated. Survey results on student attitudes towards reading and learning will be compared to April 2007 results. The state standard scores

Reading Literacy in the Content Areas
Words: 1074 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 72885298

Instructional Strategies Question answer strategy (QAR) teaches students how and when to use their texts when answering comprehension questions. Collaboration, specifically co-teaching, has been shown to be effective with special education teachers and content-area teachers in the general education classroom. The QAR strategy can enhance comprehension across different content areas. Fenty, N.S., McDuffie-Landrum, K., and Fisher, G. (2012). Using collaboration, co- teaching, and question answer relationships to enhance content area literacy.

Improving Reading Comprehension Education Is
Words: 4005 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 30914450

Recent reviews of research on summer school show that high quality programs can make a difference in student learning (Harrington-Lueker, 2000). Results of the research point to programs that focus on corrective or accelerated learning have a positive consequence on student learning. There is significant evidence that summer school can help bring many struggling students up to grade level and prevents loss of learning with many others (Denton, 2001;

Improving the Reading Comprehension of
Words: 597 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 77030524

The study focused on an urban middle school and two particular classes of 34 learning disabled students. Researchers broke the two classes down into two groups, the intervention group and the comparison group. The intervention group was introduced to the strategic lesson plans and collaborative techniques found in the computer administered CACSR. This program consisted of lessons on how to use the program and also informed students how to then

Music on Vocabulary Competence, Writing, Reading Comprehension
Words: 7250 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 1305508

Music on Vocabulary Competence, Writing, Reading Comprehension and Motivation in English Language Learning in High-School EFFECTIVENESS OF MUSIC ON VOCABULARY The Effectiveness of Music on Vocabulary Competence, Writing, Reading Comprehension and Motivation in English Language Learning in High-School Most English language learners in high schools show poor vocabulary competence. The main reason for this is the limited level of exposure to the language. It is generally understood and practically acknowledged that words