Medical Dilemma Court Case Essay

Length: 1 pages Sources: 2 Subject: Medical / Medicine Type: Essay Paper: #92635451 Related Topics: Therapy, Nursing Practice, Healthcare Providers, Healthcare Delivery
Full Free Essay :

Case Involving a Medical Dilemma

Nurses usually experience ethical dilemmas while carrying out their work of providing care to different patient populations. Ethical dilemmas arising during nursing practice are largely attributable to the complex processes involved in healthcare delivery. An example of a landmark case involving a medical dilemma is the case of a 17-year-old girl in Connecticut, Cassandra C, who refused to continue receiving chemotherapy. Cassandra was diagnosed with Hodgkin lymphoma at Connecticut Children’s Medical Center in September 2014. Following her diagnosis, doctors recommended chemotherapy as a suitable treatment approach that would help save her life. However, with her mother’s support, Cassandra refused this treatment approach for her potentially curable cancer resulting in a medical dilemma that ended up at the Connecticut Supreme Court. In a unanimous decision, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled that the teenager cannot refuse chemotherapy on the premise that she is not mature (Viale, 2015).

Cassandra’s case is an example of a scenario involving patients’ refusal of therapy, which ultimately generates medical dilemmas for healthcare providers. While it is entirely appropriate for patients to refuse care or reject aggressive therapies, there are various factors that should be taken into consideration before such decisions are made. The Connecticut Supreme Court considered these additional factors prior to making the ruling on whether Cassandra’s refusal of therapy is appropriate. According to Hevia & Schnidrig (2016), some of the dimensions to the right to health that shape such decisions include the responsibility of states to safeguard people’s health, patient decision-making, the right to free development of the individual, and the right to autonomy. The ruling in this case reflected the responsibility of the state to protect people’s health and consideration of the right to autonomy and individual decision-making. It was an appropriate outcome since the patient was not mature enough to refuse treatment.


Hevia, M. & Schnidrig, D. (2016, December). Terminal Patients and the Right to Refuse Medical Treatment in Argentina. Health and Human Rights Journal, 18(2), 247-250.

Viale, P.H. (2015, March-April). Refusal of Therapy: When Is It Appropriate? Journal of the Advanced Practitioner in Oncology, 6(2), 96-97.

Cite this Document:

"Medical Dilemma Court Case" (2020, December 18) Retrieved May 8, 2021, from

"Medical Dilemma Court Case" 18 December 2020. Web.8 May. 2021. <>

"Medical Dilemma Court Case", 18 December 2020, Accessed.8 May. 2021,

Related Documents
Treatment Approaches to Autism the
Words: 2599 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 55816910

(Stacey, 2003. Indeed, her child's therapist explained the experience was "painful," in that the child was incapable of eye contact or close contact, and this experience was painful, rather than helpful. Holding therapy is not being used as much as it was in the past, and many experts believe it should be discontinued because of its controversy and seemingly negative effect on at least some autistic patients. CRANIOSACRAL THERAPY CranioSacral Therapy is

Treatment Approaches for Addictions
Words: 519 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Sociology - Human Services Paper #: 59048474

Addiction is one of the major issues in today’s counseling practice that occurs in various forms and continues to affect many people. Kottler & Shepard (2015) define addiction as behavioral patterns that are not only applied to substances but to activities as well. This paper provides an addictions chart that provides different kinds of addictions that clients might seek services for and treatment approaches for the addictions. Types of Addiction /

Treatment Approaches for Neurological Disorders
Words: 900 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Speech Paper #: 81376506

Neurological disorders are disorders that affect the spine, brain, and nerves that connect them. There is a wide range of neurological disorders and more than 600 disorders that affect the nervous system. As a result, the treatment of neurological disorders has attracted significant attention and been the subject of numerous studies. The studies have focused on various issues relating to these disorders, particularly the development and use of various methods

Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow Treatment Approach for Out Patient...
Words: 2609 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 55179211

Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow Treatment Approach for Outpatient Therapy Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow treatment approach for out-patient therapy. The study of human psychology is important in understanding personality of individuals. One can study personality of individuals, but there is no scientific method of studying personality of the whole humanity. Human are different from person to person and vey unique to some degree. This paper prompts a thesis, and it digs

Analyzing an Opinion Paper Best Treatment Approach to Adolescent...
Words: 743 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 78401098

Treatment Approach to Adolescent Substance Disorders All over the world, the issue of substance abuse among adolescents is worrying many parents and governments. Substance abuse not only has long-term negative effects on an adolescent's brain but it may also interfere with the individual's school performance, and the relationships they have with their families and friends. The good news is no matter what one is addicted to, he or she can

Psychology - Treatment Approaches Major
Words: 623 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 63918182

Paranoid/Schizoid personality disorders are difficult to treat via insight-oriented therapeutic approaches, mainly because the patient is prone to doubt the motives of the therapist by virtue of the nature of the symptoms of the disease itself: namely, paranoid delusions that convince the patient that the therapist is part of a larger "conspiracy" against the patient (Shapiro 1999). Narcissistic, histrionic, borderline, and antisocial disorders are treatable via several insight-oriented, one-on-one psychoanalytic psychotherapeutic