Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Disclosure of errors is an express ethical obligation in the medical profession. “Non-disclosure of medical errors to patients and/or their families is a violation of ethical principles and cannot ever be justified,” (Edwin, 2009, p. 34). The American Medical Association underscores the importance of honesty in the physician-client relationship, and that relationship is tacitly extended to include the healthcare institution’s relationship with the surviving family. In “One Small Cut That Killed,” Dr. Contadina is doing what has actually become normative, common practice in healthcare. As Tabler (2013) points out, “in a subsequent civil suit by the patient, the apology could be admitted into evidence against the physician, and it wouldn’t be excluded on the grounds of hearsay,” (p. 1). Therefore, Dr. Contadina is acting logically, out of self-interest. If the healthcare institution’s ethical standards are patient-centric, ascribing to the basic principles of honesty and integrity, then the hospital administrator needs to disclose what happened, requiring Dr. Contadina to directly communicate with and apologize to the family.
Indeed, many institutions in the United States have begun to develop cohesive protocols for error admission. Encouraging honesty and a climate of respect for all patients and families, the policies...
Some states have even ensconced apology protocols into law. According to Tabler (2013), there are two categories of apology laws. One type completely protects the physician from legal liability, essentially making it so that the apology cannot be used as an admission of guilt or wrongdoing. The other type of apology law protects the physician only if there is an apology but not if doctor admits to actual error (Tabler, 2013). Clearly, the main reason why physicians and even their presiding institutions may disclose information is to preserve their self-interest in avoiding costly lawsuits. These laws recognize the financial incentive to withhold information, while also encouraging the higher ethical standard of honesty, integrity, and respect for others. Edwin (2009) also states that disclosure protects patient autonomy by empowering the person and the family with information; avoids maleficence by refraining from lying, and of course provides for the principles of justice and fidelity.
Disclosing and apologizing, as well as making amends, serves several ethical purposes; withholding information or refusing to apologize actually serves no real ethical function with the exception of ethical egoism. One ethical function of disclosure is to promote…
References
Bohonik, L. (n.d.). One small cut that killed. Center for Practical Bioethics. http://practicalbioethics.org/case-studies-one-small-cut-that-killed
Detsky, A.S., Baerlocher, M.O. & Wu, A.W. (2013). Admitting mistakes: ethics says yes, instincts say no. Canadian Medical Association Journal 185(5): 448.
Edwin, A.K. (2009). Non-disclosure of medical errors an egregious violation of ethical principles. Ghana Medical Journal 43(1): 34-39.
Tabler, N.G. (2013). Dealing with a medical mistake: should physicians apologize to patients? Medical Economics. http://medicaleconomics.modernmedicine.com/medical-economics/content/tags/apology-laws/dealing-medical-mistake-should-physicians-apologize-pati
Medical Ethics Terrance Ackerman, in his article Why Doctors Should Intervene, presents some of the complicated affective influences that enter into the doctor -- patient relationship when a patient is facing a life threatening situation. Patient autonomy has been the watchword of the medical community. Serving as the Magna Charta by which doctors have operated in their associations with terminal patients, honoring patient autonomy has been the guidelines by which doctors
Ethics, Gross National Products Ethics Gross National Product Tariff barriers Ethics Ethics is a branch of Philosophy and deals with the basics questions about right and wrong, virtue and vice, as well as good or bad nature of things human beings do in their daily lives. Thus, ethics is essentially related to the moral aspect of things. A thing, act, or idea of practice might be legally correct but may not be morally sound in
Ethics Plastic The Ethics of Plastic Surgery Funding Based on the Reason for Surgery and Other Factors: A Literature-Based Briefing Since the beginnings of recorded history at least, and indeed even earlier from what archaeologists have been able to ascertain, human beings have been obsessed with their own bodies. This is evident in the earliest works of art and in some of the earliest texts, and can also be seen in certain
Ethics The Dowd Model of Ethical Decision Making in Medical Imaging: Two Dilemma Scenarios Radiologic Alcoholic An ethical dilemma is raised in a situation where two "right" courses of action are found to be mutually exclusive of each other; that is, when doing one "right" thing necessarily leads to leaving the other "right" thing undone or even contravening this "right" and doing the opposite (Towsley-Cook & Young, 2007). A scenario in which an
All these charters that have clearly defined the boundaries of what both the positive i.e. natural rights and negative i.e. The unjust exploitative rights of the people are and how no institution or research domains have the right or power to violate them (Dierkes, Hoffmann and Marz, 1996). Based on the above fact, we have to consider all the concerns related towards security of an individual as well as his
1). Of course, anyone who recalls the popularity of cocaine and opium during the late nineteenth-century knows that the historical use of a drug is not, in itself, a testament to that drug's safety or efficacy, but this long legacy of marijuana use for medicinal purposes is important due to the relative absence of clinical studies. The three important treatments that marijuana can offer cancer patients is pain relief, appetite