Philosophy - Economic Ethics The Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Black Studies - Philosophy Type: Essay Paper: #58863265 Related Topics: Philosophy, Philosophy Of Education, Charity, Analogy
Excerpt from Essay :

Further Consideration of the Issues:

Actually, Singer's use of the term absolute affluence is not perfectly analogous (because the corresponding analog to the conditions of absolute poverty are those of extravagant wealth not working class wealth), but the idea itself is still valid just the same. The point is simply that once human society in part of the world reached the point where even most of those considered "poor" receive adequate nutrition, shelter, and the most basic emergency medical care (etc.), a moral duty arises whereby helping the less fortunate should be more important than self-centered concerns about increasing one's wealth relative to others in the manner that different levels of affluence are defined in wealthier nations.

It is important that Singer acknowledges the difference between ideals that people should uphold and ideals that people must uphold, because it is likely impossible to establish a logical justification for compelled charity, regardless of the moral imperative.

In fact, U.S. law also recognizes that distinction as well. To use Singer's first example of the rescue of the drowning child, there is absolutely no legal duty to conduct any such rescue, provided that the non-rescuer is not related to or in charge of the child and had no part in causing the child to fall into the water in the first place. However, there certainly is a moral duty to assist the child whether or not that duty is enforceable at law.

Likewise, charity in the form of assisting the poor of other nations cannot be mandated. However, from an objective moral perspective, the situation is analogous to the individual faced with the obvious moral duty to intervene to prevent the child from drowning. Singer correctly points out that the lifeboat ethics theory is inapplicable simply because none of the assistance to Third-World nations at issue poses any threat to the welfare of more affluent nations. Similarly, the notion of caring for the poor of this country is specious on two different levels: first, by virtue of the faulty comparison between...


The author acknowledges the logical soundness of the conclusion but challenges the premise that overpopulation today will necessarily continue at the same rate or increase after the receipt of aid from outside.

Specifically, Singer points out that high infant mortality is the main reason that impoverished people tend to have large families. In fact, Singer presents evidence that as starvation and poverty decrease and basic medical care becomes more available, less impoverished people tend to reduce the size of their families proportionately. Therefore, it is not the case that providing assistance today necessarily perpetuates or exacerbates the problem in the future. Singer also suggests that assistance need not be restricted to providing money or food, but in the same manner of the proverb about teaching a man to fish instead of merely feeding him a meal, Singer outlines some of the other approaches to charity that could conceivably solve many of the problems of the absolute poor, or at least improve their living condition considerably. In that regard, Singer emphasizes the importance of encouraging governmental reform where institutional problems contribute to the problem, in addition to providing education and redressing age-old cultural limitations on the role of women in some of the most impoverished societies where women are believed to serve only one purpose: to bear children.

Possibly the most crucial point made by Singer is the importance of providing effective contraception to address the overpopulation issue that only worsens many of the problems of the absolute poor. For that reason, Singer would undoubtedly have been horrified by the nonsensical position taken by the most recent Right-Wing-oriented presidential administration of George W. Bush that specifically prohibited federal funding for charitable efforts if they included contraception or education in their use.

Cite this Document:

"Philosophy - Economic Ethics The" (2009, March 21) Retrieved November 27, 2021, from

"Philosophy - Economic Ethics The" 21 March 2009. Web.27 November. 2021. <>

"Philosophy - Economic Ethics The", 21 March 2009, Accessed.27 November. 2021,

Related Documents
Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues
Words: 2355 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 60832484

That may be particularly true in contemporary American society where the cumulative costs associated with healthcare could potentially bankrupt the nation (and/or bankrupt many individuals and families) by virtue of the ever-increasing costs generally attributable to the very flawed third-party payer system in which most medical services are furnished through for-profit health insurance companies with much of the remainder funded by the funds and other resources of federal and

The Foundations and Philosophy of Ethics
Words: 353 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Ethics / Morality Paper #: 27131263

Personal journal entries: The Foundations and Philosophy of Ethics. Observation Philosophy has been one of the most interesting subjects to me since it helps stretch the imagination as well as the creativity of the reader to see the various perspectives to a subject. I set out to understand the arguments made in this article and it came out that Lawrence Kohlberg emphasizes on the importance of moral reasoning in decision making process.

Ethics in My Sisters Keeper
Words: 2090 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 21493939

Ethics, Morality, & Medicine in My Sister's Keeper Ethics & Morality Ethics, Morality, & Medicine in My Sister's Keeper Ethics, Morality, & Medicine in My Sister's Keeper Both ethics are morality of topics of philosophical discourse. Ethics is sometimes also referred to as moral philosophy. Moral philosophy or ethics may defend, recommend, and/or systematize behaviors that are right and wrong. Morality could be explained as the context within which ethics are codified. Morality is

Ethics Statement I Base My Personal Ethics
Words: 985 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 30423727

Ethics Statement I base my personal ethics on the rights and responsibilities lens from the Four Ethical Lenses. This lens focuses on the key questions such as: What rules and duties must we follow? And What rights are relevant? This standard of ethics is rooted in deontological ethics, where our actions are guided by our sense of right and wrong, and that sense is in turn guided by society's standards. Consider the aspect

Ethics in the Study of
Words: 318 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 51822369

It is this 'fluidity' in meaning and interpretation that makes ethics not only interesting as a branch of philosophy. Ethics is interesting because it is value-laden and time-dependent: changes in these factors highly influence the ethical interpretation of an event, action, or human behavior. A set of values considered to be deviant ten years ago might no longer be applicable today, and 'progressive thinking' paved the way for these perceived

Ethics Mcdonald's
Words: 872 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 76048851

Ethics With the Starbucks code of conduct, there are a few goods things. First, it touches on a wide range of subjects. There are actually several different reports such as human rights, social responsibility, health care, animal welfare and supplier code of conduct (, 2014). Second, I like the fact that it addresses the farmers from whom the company buys its beans -- these are people doing manual labor in hot