Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues Essay

Length: 8 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Healthcare Type: Essay Paper: #60832484 Related Topics: Bioethics, Moral Relativism, Against Abortion, Genetic Code
Excerpt from Essay :

That may be particularly true in contemporary American society where the cumulative costs associated with healthcare could potentially bankrupt the nation (and/or bankrupt many individuals and families) by virtue of the ever-increasing costs generally attributable to the very flawed third-party payer system in which most medical services are furnished through for-profit health insurance companies with much of the remainder funded by the funds and other resources of federal and state budgets.

In that respect, universal healthcare through government-provided healthcare services might be thought of as a right, to the extent it evolves as a means of ensuring that the American economy is not threatened by ever-increasing costs associated with a for-profit third party payer health insurance system.

Ultimately, any right to healthcare in the U.S. would be predicated on the principle of equal rights and equal opportunity established by the U.S. Constitution and other laws designed to protect the concepts of civil rights and social equality. There is not necessarily any pre-existing right to healthcare; there is only a right to the same benefits as are available to others in society and against discrimination in access to healthcare that is available to others through the government.

4) Analyze an argument in favor of abortion. Analyze an argument against abortion. Cite the benefits and limitations of each argument.

The argument for reproductive rights (i.e. abortion and birth control) is predicated on the fundamental concept of individual autonomy (Vaughn, 2009). In that regard, there is no legitimate basis for interfering with the private decision of a woman to prevent pregnancy or to terminate an unwanted pregnancy after inception. According to that point-of-view, a woman has the autonomous right to make medical decisions that only affect her and there is no legitimate basis for prohibiting the decision to prevent or terminate pregnancy that justifies overriding her autonomous right. The contrary argument (against abortion rights in particular) is that a woman may have an autonomous...

...

According to that point-of-view, the woman's right to autonomy (reproductive autonomy or otherwise) ends where the corresponding rights of the unborn fetus begin (Vaughn, 2009).

Both positions have merit. Undoubtedly, there is a period during human gestation where the fertilized ovum (or "zygote") cannot reasonably or objectively be said to have any autonomous rights simply because it does not yet possess any of the characteristics of a human being other than in its genetic code (Vaughn, 2009). On the other hand, there is also undoubtedly a period of human gestation where the fetus is sufficiently developed to have its rights recognized just the same as those of any other person or infant. It is very difficult to justify protecting the "rights" of a centimeter-sized human zygote fertilized only days (or hours) earlier simply because it has the potential to develop into a fully formed human being. However, at the opposite end of the spectrum, there must be some limitation to the autonomous rights of the woman who wishes (for the sake of example) to abort a fetus one day before full-term delivery.

In principle, the moral absolutism approach would either prohibit all abortions (including hours after conception) and even abortions that are medically necessary to save the mother's life. Meanwhile, the moral relativism approach could either allow or prohibit all abortions regardless of extremely relevant factors. In fact, only the moral objectivist approach provides a means of reconciling the respective rights of the woman and of the unborn fetus. More specifically, moral objectivism as applied to the abortion issue involves identifying objectively valid criteria and circumstances that can be used to determine whether to err on the side of the autonomous right of the woman to decide medical issues or on the side of the rights of the unborn fetus to live.

The most relevant factors in that analysis would be the degree of fetal development, sentient ability, and the medical consequences to the mother. In that regard, medical necessity for the life or well-being of the mother would be a valid objective criterion to justify abortion in almost any circumstance (Vaughn, 2009). Likewise, the fact that the fetus is sufficiently developed to sense pain or to survive outside of the mother's body are relevant factors that justify recognizing certain fundamental rights of unborn individuals that outweigh the respective importance of the mother's autonomous rights to make decisions about her medical care.

As long as the basis of moral decisions about abortion reflect the analysis of objective criteria, abortion may be ethically justified in some situations but not in others. The fundamental problem with the anti-abortion position in U.S. is its direct connection to religious beliefs about when life begins. Unlike fetal sentience and viability, religious definitions are not objective criteria and, therefore, have no place in…

Sources Used in Documents:

Sources Cited

Vaughn, Lewis. Bioethics: Principles, Issues, and Cases. Oxford University

Press. 2009.


Cite this Document:

"Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues" (2010, June 12) Retrieved June 13, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/philosophy-medical-ethics-issues-10929

"Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues" 12 June 2010. Web.13 June. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/philosophy-medical-ethics-issues-10929>

"Philosophy -- Medical Ethics Issues", 12 June 2010, Accessed.13 June. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/philosophy-medical-ethics-issues-10929

Related Documents
Medical Ethics Is a Topic That Is
Words: 1627 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Medicine Paper #: 82997992

Medical Ethics Ethics is a topic that is nearly as old as the human race. Ethics is sometimes referred to a branch of philosophy called moral philosophy. Ethics is often conceptualized as a code or a system meant to categorize or otherwise classify as well as recommend behavior that is right and behavior that is wrong. Ethical codes often describe what right and wrong is in general as well. The practice

Medical Ethics Interview Medical Ethics Interview Healthcare
Words: 1637 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 66479252

Medical Ethics Ethics Interview Medical Ethics Interview Healthcare providers include nurses, doctors, social workers and a number of other professions that seem to exist on the periphery of the helping field. One of those on the outside, that many do not consider when looking at the healthcare profession, are professional counselors. Since the term "counselor" has been diluted by everyone from friends to lawyers, it is unclear what one is talking about when

Medical Ethics How Does the Study of
Words: 683 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 42525609

Medical Ethics How does the study of medical ethics impact decisions in social services & healthcare? In the peer-reviewed Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, Professor Paul Adams explains that social work ethics "…focuses on the behavior required or expected of members of a profession," and like ethical principles in the medical profession, there are "…rules, obligations, and dilemmas" to confront in social work (Adams, 2009, p. 83). By studying medical

Medical Ethics of Providing Healthcare
Words: 2973 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 97758408

In 2004, Arizona's Proposition 200 wanted state and local governments to verify the identity and immigration status of all applicants for certain public benefits, and to require government employees to report violations (Wood pp). Attitudes about the problem have hardened in recent years in some states, both out of concern about the economic impact, particularly in a time of slow job growth, and out of concern about the security threat

Medical Ethics: Euthanasia Is Probably
Words: 1727 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Death and Dying  (general) Paper #: 60645476

If a person is incapacitated, the family should be allowed to make whatever decision they feel will cause the least harm. All such decisions should be underlined with full consultation with legal and medical professionals. I believe the best solution is therefore to firstly adhere to the four principles mentioned above. These principles should be underlined by legislation, and include ethically challenging issues such as euthanasia. To prevent indiscretionary approaches

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe
Words: 1347 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Medicine Paper #: 92103454

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe Medicine? Does Jerry's medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or why not? Generally, LPNs and medical assistants are qualified to dispense medication prescribed by a physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). A medical assistant is a trained medical professional who works under the supervision of a board-certified physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). Typically, a medical assistant's work is administrative, but it may also include clinical