Plant Relocation Confidential We Have Essay

Length: 2 pages Sources: 2 Subject: Literature - Latin-American Type: Essay Paper: #83275865 Related Topics: Philippines, Minimum Wage, Mexico, South Africa
Excerpt from Essay :

Plant relocation *** CONFIDENTIAL ***

We have discussed previously the issue of relocating one of our plants. I have received back from the consultant a report that outlines what she thinks are our best options. This report will present her findings.

Fact Summary: The consultant identified Mexico, the Philippines and South Africa as potential sites. Her findings are summarized in the following table



South Africa





Living wage?


Union strength


Moderately strong

Scandal risk




Environment Regs




Environment Cost




Env. Scandal risk




This table illustrates the issues on the table that form part of the ethical dilemma. South Africa has environmental regulations and union strength more akin to a developed country, but with lower wages and abundant labor supply. Philippines is basically anarchy, with no regulations, no enforcement, and rock bottom labor costs. Mexico sits somewhere in between, but in a border town we are more exposed to scandal than in a far-flung country on another continent.

Ethical Dilemma: Do we close an American plant, knowing that we can cut costs,...


If so, what level of trade-off is acceptable?

Ethical Issues: The human issue is with respect to wages. In Mexico and Philippines, the market rates are below living wage, which means high turnover (and its attendant problems) and potential scrutiny. We know labor groups will be watching us if we cut American union jobs. In South Africa, the jobs are union there as well, and $10/day is above the minimum wage for a laborer in an urban area (, 2014). It is still not really a living wage, but it is closer and subject to union negotiation.

The other ethical issue is the environment. The unions again will be watching us. The three countries differ considerably in terms of environmental policy, but the less we spend on protections the more competitive we can be -- the problem is that cutting back on protections could harm a lot of people given the chemicals that we work with.

Recommendation: The status quo is not acceptable. Mexico is recommended. We can do more than the minimum, for example with respect to the environment. We do not need to locate by the border, either, but can take…

Sources Used in Documents:

References (2014). Minimum wages in South Africa, "area a." Retrieved November 29, 2014 from

Cite this Document:

"Plant Relocation Confidential We Have" (2014, November 29) Retrieved August 8, 2022, from

"Plant Relocation Confidential We Have" 29 November 2014. Web.8 August. 2022. <>

"Plant Relocation Confidential We Have", 29 November 2014, Accessed.8 August. 2022,

Related Documents
Ethics of Plant Relocation to 3rd World
Words: 1908 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 75819725

Ethical Dilemma and Corporate Responsibility Board of Directors RE: Response to Ethical dilemma created by the relocation program I am writing this memo to inform the directors that this company is faced by an ethical dilemma. The ethical dilemma presented in this report is based on challenges of balancing corporate loyalty and corporate responsibility. This report advises the Project Management office (PMO) on the possibility of applying Workers Adjustment and Retaining Notification (WARN)

Ethics and Plant Closure Situation Analysis --
Words: 831 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 57079204

Ethics and Plant Closure Situation Analysis -- ABC/DVD Manufacturing, Inc. must decide whether to close its plant in Anytown, MA. The plant closure would result in the lay-off of 50 employees. Management has asked for a brief outlining the ethical issues surrounding plant closures, and the questions apparent on profit vs. ethical behavior. At the heart of the decision are several questions that must be considered prior to a decision. Each question

Outsourcing and Relocation As Our
Words: 1453 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 34462421

The likes of service oriented companies like America Online (AOL) is a prime example of how relocation and outsourcing has changed the way service oriented businesses function in this global economy. AOL continues to be one of our nation's most intelligent economic organizations as they take advantage of the outsourcing for the majority of their customer oriented operations. When an AOL customer calls in to have his password reset

Business and Political Argument Against
Words: 2773 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 68048959

The government has rather low environmental expectations. In fact, the consultant found that they are about as lenient as the Mexican restrictions, though the Philippines presents no public relations nightmare as protestors are not rallying against health concerns, as they were in Mexico. Although the conditions in the Philippines may seem even more ready for outsourcing then the conditions in Mexico, the ethical costs of operating the company in the

Ethical Problem With Exporting Pollution
Words: 306 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 89076763

That particular ethical concern may be harder to define precisely, simply because it may be too restrictive and no different from the types of decisions considered appropriate in the U.S. In that regard, provided it violates no domestic or foreign laws and that it is not undertaken for the purpose of shifting the environmental risk (Rosenstand, 2008), the relocation is no different from situating a similar plant in any local

Access Group Executive Overview: The
Words: 3211 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 52349279

The third alternative offers the initial benefits of the first alternative. It also allows for focusing on core competencies and maintaining a smaller organization to promote personal corporate culture of the second alternative. However, this option will have a disruption as the organization changes to an autonomous entity that may be counter-productive. The fourth alternative of no entry has the benefit of not subjecting TAG to the risk of a new