Plato, A Platypus, And The Enlightenment Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Black Studies - Philosophy Type: Essay Paper: #47560104 Related Topics: Enlightenment, Age Of Enlightenment, Candide, Epistemological
Excerpt from Essay :

Plato and the Platypus

Philosophers in the Enlightenment era would come up with various new means to popularize ideas. Denis Diderot conceived the first encyclopedia in this period, which was an attempt to systematize all world knowledge in an accessible way. But also, in another innovation, Voltaire would offer as a refutation of the optimistic philosophy of Leibniz -- which held that "this is the best of all possible worlds" -- a new form of philosophical argument: the extended comedy (Cathcart and Klein, 17). Voltaire's short book Candide is essentially an extended refutation of Leibniz's view of God (or perhaps any view of God), but it makes its points through satirical humor. In some sense, Thomas Cathcart and Daniel Klein are following in the footsteps of Voltaire by attempting to shed light on philosophical ideas through the medium of humor in their work Plato and a Platypus Walk Into A Bar. However, it is worth noting that their methodology also combines Diderot's encyclopediac approach: the book attempts to be a basic introduction to the essential concepts of philosophy, but explores these concepts by use of jokes.

A useful entry into Cathcart and Klein's work is provided by their discussion of the somewhat forbidding topic of epistemology. Their joking tone provides a definition of this very concept which makes it clear what is at stake: "How do you know the stuff you think you know? Take away the option of answering 'I just do!' And what's left is epistemology." (Cathcart and Klein, 52). Obviously epistemology is basic to any Enlightenment-inspired enterprise: when Diderot constructed his first encyclopedia, it was done on the basis that the knowledge being collected in this format was actually reliable. There were plenty of philosophical schools that existed before the Enlightenment: obviously the entirety of Western philosophy in the medieval period was essentially based on the worldview of Christianity,...


Cathcart and Klein acknowledge this by noting that the epistemological question "in the Middle Ages…boiled down to whether divine revelation trumps reason as a source of human knowledge or vice versa" (Cathcart and Klein 53). However the knowledge of the Enlightenment was not likely to endorse these sorts of beliefs about what happens after death, on the precise basis that we have no actual evidence regarding what happens after death: this is a basic epistemological stance, which reveals that we do not "know" but rather "believe" in various alternatives about what happens to a person after death. In some sense, therefore, knowledge comes to us by way of doubt. This is a point that Cathcart and Klein make usefully in their discussion of Descartes as they introduce the concept of epistemology:

Descartes arrived at the cogito through an experiment in radical doubt to discover if there was anything he could be certain of; that is anything he could not doubt away. He started out by doubting the existence of the external world. That was easy enough. Perhaps he was dreaming or hallucinating. Then he tried doubting his own existence. But doubt as he would, he kept coming up against the fact that there was a doubter. Must be himself! He could not doubt his own doubting. (Cathcart and Klein, 53)

As a result, Cathcart and Klein joke that perhaps Descartes should have said "dubito, ergo sum" -- although the reason why he did not is not explained by Cathcart and Klein, if we have followed the book thus far, we should be able to understand. To doubt ("dubito") is merely a subset of the general action of thinking ("cogito"). We might very well imagine that Descartes was thinking about how delicious his eggs had been at breakfast in flashes during his long sessions of epistemological skepticism -- or thinking about anything at all, in the way that human thought proceeds. The real point is that it is possible to doubt the evidence of the senses, but it is not possible to doubt the existence of an internal thought process which permits the action of "doubting." In other words, this is the only basic form of epistemological certainty, and Descartes would build the rest of his philosophy starting from that premise.

What is amusing is the way that Cathcart and Klein demonstrate the transition in epistemological approaches from the period of belief in the Middle Ages to the period…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Cathcart, Thomas and Klein, Daniel. Plato and a Platypus Walk Into A Bar: Understanding Philosophy Through Jokes. New York: Penguin Books, 2008. Print.

Cite this Document:

"Plato A Platypus And The Enlightenment" (2014, April 02) Retrieved May 12, 2021, from

"Plato A Platypus And The Enlightenment" 02 April 2014. Web.12 May. 2021. <>

"Plato A Platypus And The Enlightenment", 02 April 2014, Accessed.12 May. 2021,

Related Documents
Post-Enlightenment Period We See the
Words: 3970 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 82396447

Marx set the anti-religious tone of twentieth century political ideologies, in particular, anti-Semitism. Defenders of Marx will take scholars to task who question Marx on alleged anti-Semitism, claiming that the critics are quoting Marx out of context. Whether or not Marx is or was anti-Semitic (which this author is maintaining is the case), he was perceived so in his time and his writings were used by later Soviet regimes to

Enlightenment and Scientific Method Robert Hollinger, in
Words: 2056 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 99623034

Enlightenment and Scientific Method Robert Hollinger, in his essay "What is the Enlightenment?," notes the centrality of science to the "Enlightenment project," as he defines it, offering as one of the four basic tenets that constitute the "basic ideas of the Enlightenment" the view that "only a society based on science and universal values is truly free and rational: only its inhabitants can be happy." (Smith 1998, p. 71). As Smith

Enlightenment Thinkers: Galileo, Bacon, Descartes
Words: 1099 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Physics Paper #: 5940586

82) because he had to find a bridge from the old paradigm to the new one. He argued that science could restore man to the dominion he enjoyed before the "Fall" (caused by ignorance). Some scholars argue that Bacon never saw any environmental change as undesirable and viewed all science as good. Rene Descartes also profoundly influenced the modern idea of nature. He argued that mind and matter are distinct

Enlightenment and the French Revolution
Words: 2092 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 4587879

Rather, corruption continued and the widespread execution of revolutionaries by Maximilien Robespierre and Louis de Saint-Just of the Committee of Safety was largely justified with the radicalized views of Enlightenment philosopher Rousseau with regard to the revolution (Church; Lefebvre; Rude). Robespierre's distorted perception of Rousseau's views lead to an adamant and unwaivering desire to drive the revolution forward at any cost, including that of substantial human life. Robespierre was

Enlightenment Upon the Colonies Enlightenment As May
Words: 677 Length: 2 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 23713967

Enlightenment Upon the Colonies Enlightenment As may be common knowledge by people raised, educated, and living in America for many years will know, during the American Enlightenment period, many people were inspired. There were ideas abound. It was an era of relative tolerance and humanist thinking. Documents such as the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution were composed and ratified during this period as well. Clearly, the American Enlightenment

Enlightenment in the Late 17th and Early
Words: 881 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 45302378

Enlightenment In the late 17th and early 18th centuries, a scientific revolution occurred which gave humankind a much better understanding of the universe and its functioning than ever before. One of those scientists was Isaac Newton, who, in addition to his work with gravitational laws, also developed principles of light and refraction. From this revolution in science came an intellectual and cultural movement who's name came from a metaphor based in