Verified Document

Plato's Idea Of Ethics In Socrates Vs Euthyphro Essay

Related Topics:

Euthyphro Questions

1. I agree that belief in God is the only basis for morality. The rightness or wrongness of an action has to be predicated on something outside of ourselvessome objective truth or law. If there is a law, there must be a law giver. This objective rule or law or standard or ethic is what could be called the universals or the transcendentals. They can be understood by all people. Obviously, different cultures are going to have different beliefs about what is moral to some degree because human beings are always influencing one another and shaping their societies in their own ways rather than conforming to the universal law that one can understand if one applies reason to the issue, the way Plato and Aristotle did. Just because a culture has a certain position on an action being moral and another culture has a different position on it does not in any way lessen the truth that universals exist. People can refuse to acknowledge them or argue against them all they like, just as Euthyphro does. The point is that a moral society works towards knowing the truth rather than running from the labor. Euthyphro runs from it because he senses that it might end up making him question his own sense of righteousness, and he would rather not do that. Ultimately, however, it does come back to God, for there has to be a higher power that has authored this rule that people can ascertain with their reason. This is why Socrates directs the discussion with Euthyphro toward the will of the gods, because it is a matter of conforming oneself to the will of the divinity that established the moral order or law in the first place. Euthyphro wants to twist the law to conform to his own will. That is not morality, as far as Socrates is concerned.

2. Socrates is on...

…the gods. However, it is also subject to criticism, as Socrates continues to probe its implications and consistency in the dialogue.

9. Socrates criticizes Euthyphro's second definition by introducing a philosophical dilemma that is now known as the Euthyphro Dilemma. He asks whether the gods love the pious because it is pious, or whether it is pious because the gods love it. The first option would suggest that there is a standard of piety independent of the gods, while the second would suggest that piety is arbitrary and based solely on the gods' whims. This puts Euthyphro in a difficult position and effectively dismantles his second definition. What Socrates is able to do here is show that the stories the Greeks have of the gods are an inconsistent representation of the divinity or rather the divine law of goodness that must characterize God. Knowledge of the stories of the gods is insufficient if one is truly seeking the truth about…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Socrates and the Apology Socrates and Death
Words: 1181 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Socrates and the Apology Socrates and Death in the Apology In The Apology, Socrates contrasts his ability to address the crowd against more skillful speakers stating that he offers truth over eloquence (17b). In essence, he infers that others use the power of persuasion and slick words to sway others vs. The truth. He postulates that there are others who will always present a skewed depiction of the facts in order to

Socrates Both Comedy and Tragedy Are Related
Words: 1171 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Socrates Both comedy and tragedy are "related to emotional needs and religious longings that became crystallized and structured in ritualistic celebrations and festivals," (34). Both can be framed as "catalysts" that force "some sort of conversion" in the individual (34). Moreover, both comedy and tragedy reflect the "eternal spectacle of human nature and its weaknesses," (35). Both art forms use imitation or mimicry of a political figure or idea. However, there are

Socrates Plato and Aristotle
Words: 1204 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Socrates is one of the most renowned philosophers of all times. His dialectic method is used in a number of ways and has vital importance in literature and deliberation. In the contemporary era, Socratic or Dialectic Method is the term that is used to point out a conversation between two or more people who might have opposing views about an issue but they come to a conclusion after trying to

Socrates and Virtue Comparing and Contrasting Virtue
Words: 2619 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Socrates and Virtue Comparing and Contrasting Virtue in Taoism and Socrates' Philosophy The idea of virtue in Taoism may be compared and contrasted to the idea of virtue in the teachings of Socrates. For Socrates, virtue is related to the pursuit of wisdom through philosophy, and is ordered to that which is true and good. Taoism similarly calls upon the practitioner to devote himself to the Way, which is the order that

Socrates in the Apology and
Words: 1358 Length: 4 Document Type: Reaction Paper

As a result, Plato is demonstrating social disobedience, by highlighting how anyone who questions authority will face a similar fate as Socrates. (Plato, 2007) In Crito, Socrates has been found guilty of his crimes and is awaiting his death sentence in an Athenian prison cell. On an early morning, his friend Crito pays him a visit and offers to help him escape. He feels that if Socrates is able to

Socrates and Plato Greek Philosophy Held a
Words: 1909 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Socrates and Plato Greek philosophy held a preeminent place in the middle ages among scholastics like Thomas Aquinas, whose Summa Theologica was an attempt to reconcile faith and reason. The faith aspect was supplied by the Church, but the reason came from classical (pagan) ecclesiology -- notably from Greek philosophers like Plato and Aristotle. The latter was the pupil of the former, and the former was the pupil of the first

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now