Political Inquiry Dissertation Or Thesis Complete

Length: 4 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Government Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete Paper: #34320208 Related Topics: Welfare Reform, Political Science, Welfare, Example
Excerpt from Dissertation or Thesis complete :

Political Inquiry

Utility of Political Inquiry Models: Scientific vs. Interpretive

Scientific methods of inquiry, also called empirical, positivist, or rational approaches, are used by the vast majority of researchers in the social sciences (deLeon, 1998). The scientific approach has largely relied on a behaviorist approach, which defines human behavior as following the laws of nature and therefore inherently predicable. The logical conclusion from this is that the goal of political research is being able to predict the behavior of humans as they engage in politics. As Douglas Torgerson stated in 1986, "… knowledge would replace politics" (as cited by deLeon, 1998, p. 148).

In contrast, the interpretive school of political inquiry advocates for a more nuanced approach, one that recognizes that human behavior, whether by individuals or groups, is far too complex to render it reducible to quantitative measures (deLeon, 1998). Rather than having a goal of being able to predict human behavior, interpretive inquiry seeks to gain beneficial insights into the political process. These scholars would even go so far as to claim that a scientific approach which excludes the influence of human traits, such as patriotism or free will, does more damage than good.

One example of a political issue that received a lot of attention in the recent past is the welfare and welfare-to-work programs (WWP) that swept the country in the mid-1990s. Writing in the New York Times, Steven Manos (1994) argued that WWP merely shifts welfare recipients to jobs by displacing others who would have otherwise taken those jobs. From his perspective, WWP does not result in a net savings by reducing the number of welfare recipients or increasing the amount of income taxes paid, because WWP does not actually create jobs. In other words, WWP does nothing more than churn the welfare rolls. This cost-benefit analysis would represent a scientific approach to this policy issue; however, Manos' argument...

...

President Clinton touted the Indiana program as the most successful WWP in the country based on the magnitude of welfare roll reductions. What Coffield and Indiana welfare recipients discovered was that the "work first" program in Indiana emphasized gainful employment to such an extent that efforts to overcome persistent poverty were formally marginalized. Of the policies that contributed to this trend was a prohibition on state support for training programs lasting longer than a month and the pursuit of college degrees taking longer than a year to complete. The outcome of these policies was a drop in the number of welfare recipients enrolled in training and college programs from 68% to 28%.

The case study presented by Coffield (2002) is about an African-American mother (Bridgett) with five children in her late 20s. With a history of being on and off welfare and working low-wage jobs, the WWP case workers had declared Bridgett hostile because she refused to reveal intimate details about her personal life or engage in activities needed to meet the program's requirements. Bridgett had also 'voluntarily' refused benefits so that she could continue attending college classes towards a nursing degree. Apparently the "work first" program in Indiana placed so much emphasis on getting any job that Bridgett would have been required to attend classes in life skills and job search strategies, instead of attending her nursing classes. The effective goal of these WWP classes was getting Bridgett off welfare by finding her another low-wage job. As Bridgett declared with conviction: "I can't work some stupid minimum wage job and end up screwing up my chances with my schooling & #8230;, and I'm not sticking my kids in some fifth-rate child care center to…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Coffield, C. Ditmar. "Welfare Reform in Indiana: The Political Economy of Restricting Access to Education and Training." Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 23.3 (2002): 261-284. Print.

Connolly, William. The Terms of Political Discourse, 3rd ed. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell, 1993. Print.

deLeon, Peter. "Models of Policy Discourse: Insights vs. Predictions." Policy Studies Journal, 26.1 (1998): 147-161. Print.

Manos, Steven S. "From Welfare to Work and Vice Versa." New York Times 30 June 1994: A22. Web. 27 Feb. 2013.


Cite this Document:

"Political Inquiry" (2013, February 27) Retrieved June 22, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-inquiry-103632

"Political Inquiry" 27 February 2013. Web.22 June. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-inquiry-103632>

"Political Inquiry", 27 February 2013, Accessed.22 June. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-inquiry-103632

Related Documents
Political Persona: Joseph Stalin Political
Words: 3921 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Communication - Journalism Paper #: 23639258

Domestically, Novosti disseminated information on life in other countries and on life in the Soviet Union. All of these institutional structures fell under the authority of the Party. The television system in the Soviet Union was centrally controlled through the State Committee for Tele- vision and Radio (Gostelradio), which coordinated the communication of the ideological message sent down from above. The reorganization and elevation of this committee to the all-union

Political Science the Republican Party Triumphed a
Words: 2265 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 76568997

Political Science The Republican Party triumphed a majority in both houses of the Congress in the fall of 1994. This was the first time since the 1952 landslide of Eisenhower. It was believed by many that the Republicans had achieved the partisan realignment in the end. It also came to be believed that the prophesied Republican majority by Kevin Phillips in the late 1960s had come to reality. The Republicans under the

Political, Economic and Social Environment
Words: 2569 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 15131948

(Committee on Public Education and Professional Practice, 1993) the conclusion of the Council states that "...it is essential that the profession act concertedly to bring about the changes that they know to be necessary for effective education in the province's classrooms. Specific recommendations of the Council are those as follows: (1) Development of a comprehensive position on public education and professional practice must take place on the foundations as

Political Influence Over Stem Cell
Words: 2905 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 14376102

Going back further, the same religious principals also inspired opposition to organ transplants and blood transfusions; before that, the Catholic Church strictly forbade any forensic scientific research, necessitating the need to dissect cadavers for medical education entirely in secret (Levine, 2008). Just as the news media are partially at fault today for their failure to distinguish legitimate concerns from ludicrous fears in connection with the ongoing political debate over American

Political Science Rousseau's Doctrine of
Words: 2859 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Black Studies - Philosophy Paper #: 19227637

- these actions are not punished by the law because, while immoral according to many, they do not cause injury to the rights of others. Adam Smith further emphasizes the centrality of property rights. For Smith, the ownership and acquisition of private property is an essential right that contributes to and maintains individual well-being. Individuals who do not own property are individuals with no real say in their own affairs,

Political Science-James Scott James Scott
Words: 599 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 13780608

Because concealment is provided, hidden transcripts, which in most cases are contrary to the public transcript, are unrestrained performances within the safety provided offstage and the assumed like-mindedness of the audience. The difference between the public vs. The hidden transcript is the "impact of the domination on public discourse" (5). Thus, Scott illustrates the contradiction between the public and the hidden transcripts as he illustrates George Orwell's experience in colonial