Restructuring The Public Works Department In Carlsbad, California Case Study

Length: 14 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Business Type: Case Study Paper: #20579861 Related Topics: Petroleum, Professionalism, Disruptive Innovation, Hr Practices
Excerpt from Case Study :

Organizational Development for a Family Owned Business

Organization: Hightowers Petroleum Company

Hightowers Petroleum Company is a private company owned by Stephen Hightower. The company is an offspring of a string of family businesses originally started by Yudell Hightower, who relocated to Middletown Ohio in the 1940's, from the cotton fields in Mississippi. Yudell would eventually sell his janitorial business and invest the proceeds in his son, Stephen Hightower's business. Today the company employs three generations of Hightower's and continues to distribute gasoline, diesel, biofuels and related products and services throughout the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Africa.

The Mission/Purpose

The company's mission statement reads "Fueling America's Needs one Customer at a Time" and this is born from the fact that the owner started with one contract and one client. He knew that if he really concentrated all his efforts of delivering excellent service to that one client, who happens to be the State of Ohio, he could convince other clients (States) to give him work. He went about meeting with the various state department buyers in an effort to understand their frustrations with managing their fuel supply. He then went back to his office and worked on solutions for each problem and won the hearts of these procurement officials by being proactive and attending their individual needs. Today the company is still focused on being that "big supplier with a small feel to it" differentiator.

1. The Issues

Most businesses in the United States are family owned. Their contribution to the economy as well as to the immediate community cannot be ignored. The consumers of products and services offered by these businesses are fully appreciative of their efforts, however not all family businesses manage to continue to operate across family generations as most of them do not last long. Just a third of them manage to make the generational transition. This is made even more challenging given the complex dynamics that have to be considered in the running of family businesses (Andrews, 2010).

Performance in innovation is often considered crucial for a family business to compete favorably in the market. With growing competition, product cycles getting shorter and increased market segmentation, family owned businesses face the need to constantly innovate or they risk being out-competed. Strategic posture is used to refer to the way the management in an organization responds to demands from the external environment (Ozgener, Oout, Kaplan & Bikes, n.d).

An active posture denotes these people taking efforts deliberately to ensure good management of expectations of the key stakeholders. A passive posture is the complete opposite and the management does not take any measures to meet these expectations. Without a doubt, the two strategies greatly affect innovation performance in any family business (Ozgener, Oout, Kaplan & Bikes, n.d). Furthermore, it is absolutely essential that succession planning is paid attention to, in a family business so that there is smooth transition to the following generation.

Organizational Diagnostic Factors Analyzed

This case study seeks to analyze the 1) ownership; 2) structure; 3) politics; and 4) culture of the family owned business, Hightowers Petroleum Company. These are the most critical factors to be considered for the longevity and success of this business, and with the right interventions in these key areas, the necessary change can take place to develop a strong and prosperous organization.

1. Ownership

1. Assumption(s) and why it is critical to analyze

Bolman & Deal's theory is to assume that the organization represents a family and that the central concepts seek to examine assumptions around needs; skills and relationships. It further looks at the image of leadership to empower and the basic leadership challenge to align the organization's needs with the needs of the people. In this case-study its critical to understand how the metaphor of a family fits into an actual family business and how this impacts the family members and non-family members of this "family."

Areas like ensuring that the family maintains control of the business and the satisfaction of both the financial needs of the family and the business must be given attention. Family businesses that get to succeed from generation have open and clear ownership structures -- for instance, regulation on the trading of the shares. These regulations are often carefully crafted and can last for as long as 20 years (Caspar, Dias & Elsdrodt, 2010).

Some of these family owned entities are holding money is channeled back into the company. This is advantageous as the issuance of new stock is likely to dilute ownership (Caspar, Dias & Elsdrodt, 2010).

Actually, a number of families make the decision to completely not accept external investment. The growth of the companies is fully fueled by reinvested profits. Some of them make the decision to bring in private equity to inject the much-needed capital into the company and to improve their corporate governance strategy. While deals of that nature may bring value to the company, the control the family wields ends up diluted. Some other companies choose to issue an IPO. To ensure that their control is significant, several family businesses have restrictions on the share trading (Caspar, Dias & Elsdrot, 2010).

The first step should always be to approach siblings and cousins. Further, the holding can purchase shares from current family members. The payout policies often have a long-term perspective so that the business is not recapitalized. Because of the low dividends and the restrictions on exit, some of these businesses have adopted "generational liquidity events" so that the cash needs of the family are met. Such activities can include selling holdings that are publicly traded or the selling of family shares to the company or employees. Proceeds from such activities are channeled to the family members (Caspar, Dias & Elsdrot, 2010).

1. Recommendation & Intervention

For navigating through the developmental stages within the context of Ownership in High towers Petroleum Company, authors suggested three key guidelines. Firstly, shareholder meetings should be held as they provide a platform for conducting discussions about specific ownership- related issues. Secondly, instituting directorial and advisory boards serves a long-term purpose, assisting the president broaden his/her view. With development of the organization, the role of these boards becomes ever more significant, particularly in the Formalization / Expansion and Sibling Partnership developmental stages. A board must constitute a group of fair and neutral individuals who incur no benefits from the specific decisions the board makes. Finally, business planning must take place in the following four ways -- the strategic business plan, business contingency plan, management development unit, and continuity plan. The board is in charge of assisting the president with development of all the above plans (Andrews, 2010).

HR Intervention

Competency mapping

In handling family business issues, it is imperative to include some method of obtaining objective assistance. The numerous facets of competent conduct in a profession against dimensions of competency, like quality, strategic capability, and resource management are determined by competency mapping. This process enables a methodical scrutiny, collection and assessment of behavior, providing a systematized means of making decisions with regards to an employee in the organizational structure of High towers Petroleum Company. This helps boost employee morale, improve organizational culture, maximize individuals' fit with their jobs enhance communication, assist personnel in managing and alleviating stress levels, promote teamwork, recognize training needs, facilitate skills improvement of managers, etc. This sort of intervention, in case of family-owned companies, offers the required objectivity essential for resolving issues impartially (Sharma, 2012).

Succession planning

Several assessment tools are available that can reveal the key traits of an individual, remarkably constant in different circumstances and over time. Hightowers Petroleum Company's human resource professionals must convince the company to take advantage of employee promotion, and even selection tests, in order for achieving improved talent management, more accurate assessment of members of the family keen on joining the company, and more effective development planning all through the organization. However, the business must also offer opportunities to outsiders (Sharma, 2012).


Nepotism remains a key threat to family business performance. Therefore, leaders in all family businesses have to decide whether employment in the firm has to be earned or is, for family members, a privilege. While the just and fair human resource (HR) policies require employment of competent personnel, in some instances, family members who do not have the appropriate qualifications can get employed or promoted. Such employees often prove to be idlers, not contributing to the company's growth and performance. One example of a problem individual in the company is the chief executive's son accorded the responsibility of an important portfolio, but being slack and incompetent. One cannot complain and get these people to follow directions; the best option is…

Sources Used in Documents:


Andrews, J. (2010). Managing Growth: Best Practices of Family-Owned Businesses. Honors Projects in Management. Retrieved from

Caspar, C., Dias, A., & Elstrodt, H. (2010). The five attributes of enduring family businesses. Retrieved August 1, 2015, from

Ceja, L., & Tapies, J. (2011). Corporate values guiding the world's largest family-owned businesses: a comparison with non-family firms (No. D/916).IESE Business School.

Dyer, W.G. (1988). Culture and continuity in family firms. Family Business Review, 1(1), 37-50.
Ozgener, S., Oout, A., Kaplan, M. & Bickes, M. (n.d).the effects of organizational politics and strategic posture on innovation performance. Retrieved 1 August 2015 from effects-of-organizational-politics-and-strategic-posture-on-innovation-performance.pdf
Stalk, G., Foley, H. (2012). Avoid the Traps That Can Destroy Family Businesses. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved 17 August 2015 from:
Strategy, Structure and Organizational Culture.(n.d.). Retrieved 2 August 2015 from

Cite this Document:

"Restructuring The Public Works Department In Carlsbad California" (2015, August 18) Retrieved February 8, 2023, from

"Restructuring The Public Works Department In Carlsbad California" 18 August 2015. Web.8 February. 2023. <>

"Restructuring The Public Works Department In Carlsbad California", 18 August 2015, Accessed.8 February. 2023,

Related Documents
Biofuels to Dissect Locust Guts
Words: 3671 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 9348571

Importance of locust guts for this Study Prediction of the increase in the worldwide energy consumption by 54% between 2001 and 2025 has led to the considerable interest in the production of bioenergy to meet the future needs. Energy derived from biofuels is converted from the metabolism of living organisms. Typically, biofuels has been identified by scientist and environmentalist as the most promising alternative to petroleum and fossil fuels. Biofuels are

Biofuel the Search for Alternative Energy Has
Words: 2302 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 62009908

Biofuel The search for alternative energy has been a major issue over past 30 years. In recent months there has been an increased amount of urgency concerning reliance upon fossil fuels. The purpose of this discussion is to examine biofuel as a source of alternative energy. The research will focus on determining the impact that biofuel may have on the current energy crisis. Let us begin this discussion by defining the

Biofuels the Department of Agriculture
Words: 807 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 88084247

Biofuel from corn is, at presently, relatively inefficient. Surveys indicate that at best biofuel generates 1.3 times the energy it costs to product (Jaffe, 2007); several studies indicate it generates less than what it costs to produce (Wald, 2007). Moreover, natural gas is the standard fuel required in ethanol production and our production already does not match our consumption (Ibid.). As a result, we do not see biofuel as a

Renewable Energy Biofuels Are Becoming
Words: 2483 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 60664576

Thus, the sole remaining major precursor to success is economic utility, which is a function of the cost of second generation biofuel production compared with the production costs of alternatives. Gasoline is the main competitor of concern, given the stated objectives of both American and European governments of using second generation biofuels to displace gasoline consumption in the coming years and decades. At current crude oil prices, there is a

Brazil Biofuel This Work Will
Words: 2030 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 80783226

The economy may be strong in some areas but weak in others as the fuel industry seeks to deprive the culture of traditional food bearing crops, in exchange for fuel bearing ones, and decreases the biodiversity of the nation in the process. "... with ethanol and biodiesel as a springboard, Brazil's President...Lula da Silva aims to turn his country into an energy superpower --...environmentalists warn that although bio-fuels reduce

Environmental Science: Biofuels Biofuels: Environmental
Words: 374 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 97413626

The technique used in this process is quite simple and reported to be that as follows: "The fish would gobble up the algae and then be harvested, cooked and pressed to extract fish oil -- a method already used to produce omega-3 fatty acid dietary supplements." (Gold, 2009) p.1 Presently there is a testing on fish mixtures for the best production quality at a testing site owned by LiveFuels in San