Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Special Needs Assessment: A Review of Recent Literature on Testing Students with Special Needs
One of the most difficult and controversial issues in education today is the question of identifying, testing and educating students with potential special needs and different learning styles. On one hand, individuals within the system of education wish to be inclusive in nature. They do not wish to label students permanently to the detriment of their educational advancement. However, ignoring the special challenges some students face can be just as detrimental as tracking students too early into a special education niche. Furthermore, the increased demand for testing students of all levels of innate ability to verify the competency of individual instructors and the performance of students within particular districts on the whole means that the issue of testing students with special needs is unlikely to go away soon. It is a problem that all educators must take a stand on. (Airasian, 2001)
The educator Alba Ortiz, in her article "English Language Learners With Special Needs: Effective Instructional Strategies" from the 2001 ERIC Digest tackles the specific issue of students with dual special needs, namely those who do not speak English as their primary language. This gives Ortiz a unique and surprising perspective upon the subject. She suggests that the current system of special education assessment is faulty. The over-representation of English language learners in special education classes is a clear indication, in her view, that educators have a demonstrable difficulty in distinguishing students who truly have learning disabilities from students who are...
(Ortiz, 2001)
The author quotes Valdes & Figueroa's 1996 study that indicates "students learning English are disadvantaged by a scarcity of appropriate assessment instruments and a lack of personnel trained to conduct linguistically and culturally relevant educational assessments." (Valdes & Figueroa, 1996) In other words, the learning disabled and ESL are dismissed as merely poorly functioning in an English linguistic and cultural environment, rather than having learning difficulties. Also, "English language learners who need special education services are further disadvantaged by the shortage of special educators who are trained to address their language and disability related needs simultaneously." Thus when a special needs student is identified, if English is not his or her primary language, which can teach the student in a way to cope with both the language and the educational difficulties?
The danger, Ortiz views, comes from under rather than over assessment and tracking. Better to identify a problem early on, even to the point of eschewing mainstreaming, than to allow a student to flounder in a classroom where he or she cannot understand what is being said, and his or her needs as both an ESL student and a specialized learner are overlooked. This is a surprising position, given that one might think a person acting as an advocate for students of alternate cultural and linguistic backgrounds might be concerned about the over-identification of students as learning disabled.
Similarly, the educator and author Antoinette Dudek agrees that early assessment is of…
Works Cited
Airasian, Peter. Classroom Assessment: Concepts and Applications. (2001). Fourth Edition. New York: McGraw-Hill.
College Board. (2004)
http://www.collegeboard.com.
A de La Paz, Susan; Graham, Steve. (1997) "Screening for Special Diagnoses." ERIC Digest.
Thus, efforts aimed at helping teachers to avoid harmful stereotyping of students often begin with activities designed to raise teachers' awareness of their unconscious biases." (1989) Cotton goes on the relate that there are specific ways in which differential expectations are communicated to students according to the work of: "Brookover, et al. (1982); Brophy (1983); Brophy and Evertson (1976); Brophy and Good (1970); Cooper and Good (1983); Cooper and
In their study, "Thinking of Inclusion for All Special Needs Students: Better Think Again," Rasch and his colleagues (1994) report that, "The political argument in favor of inclusion is based on the assumption that the civil rights of students, as outlined in the 1954 decision handed down in Brown v. Board of Education, which struck down the concept of 'separate but equal,' can also be construed as applying to special
It would not only be time consuming and expensive for each classroom teacher to develop an effective basic reading skills curriculum but such a curriculum is also fraught with a high degree of error. There is compelling evidence that supports the use of scripted programs rather than teacher-developed approaches to teach complex skills (Benner, 2005). Second, apply positive behavioral supports to manage the behaviors of students with behavioral difficulties during
Student Assessment What is the most appropriate way to assess student achievement? The commission of the National Middle School Assessment of student achievement suggests "authentic assessment refers to evaluation that makes use of real life tasks instead of contrived test items." (NMSA, 2000) In other words, rather than focus on testing students more, a greater interest and study of effective teaching practices are better employed in further research regarding education.
While some suggest that high-stakes testing is an inadequate way of measuring the academic achievement and learning of most students, many also agree that high-stakes testing has severe disadvantages for special education students. Kymes points out that high-stakes testing may be a discriminatory assessment method for special needs students, placing an "unfair burden" on these students. The scholar argues that testing plans cannot be created for each and every student,
As a result, children within the middle class and above receive adequate attention and treatment for special education needs at an early stage. Young children of educated parents are read to more consistently, and are encourage to read by themselves at an early age. Statistics show that most children with parents who have college degrees are read to on a daily basis before they begin attending kindergarten. In application