The Biomedical Debate According To Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Physics Type: Essay Paper: #51543077 Related Topics: Bioethics, Pastoral Care, Stem Cell Research, Human Cloning
Excerpt from Essay :

With the emergence of new technologies and procedures
has occurred the emergence of new experts. According to Rose, "around these
experts of the soma cluster a whole variety of new pastoral experts-genetic
counselors are perhaps the best exemplars-whose role is to advise and guide
to care and support, individuals and families as they negotiate their way
through the personal, medical and ethical dilemmas that they face. And,
perhaps, most remarkable has been the rise of a novel expertise of
'bioethics.'" (Rose, 6)
This is the subject which commands perhaps the greatest importance in
Rose's text, striking relevance into every other aspect of the debate by
suggesting that this essentially subjective lens has come to dominate a
field traditionally ruled by empiricism. To this point, optimization has
been distinctly impacted by this false or self-proclaimed sense of somatic
Indeed, in his dealing throughout the text with this issue of
optimization, Rose finds that it generally applies to all debates today,
whether relating to the ability to manipulate genetic materials
preemptively or to the interest in controlling various conditions or
'abnormalities' through the use of drug treatment. The result is that new
opportunities to alter the course of medical deterioration or 'abnormality'
have created questions about that which should be considered desirable. As
Rose shows, to those who would consider optimization to be largely a matter
of taking to their logical next evolutionary step all apparent avenues of
progress. Rose indicates that "their proposition is that we are on the
cusp of a new age, in which we are no longer content with the restoration
of sickened bodies and souls to their organic, vital norms. In this new
age, it seems, we are able to reshape key aspects of the functioning of our
bodies and souls more or less at will." (Rose, 97-98)
Of course, Rose contends this with the understanding that there are a
great many who would view such unbridled innovation as potentially
extremely dangerous and discrediting of the sanctity of human life. This
produces the outcome of his


It is clear that Rose enters the discussion
without the prejudices that often account for religious, political or
ideological obstruction where bioethical debate is concerned. Though this
allows him to endorse an optimization which allows for the procession of
technological and biomedical evolution but which seeks to identify the
specific areas in which use should be applied, it also demonstrates
something unrealistic in his text. Namely, the various obstacles to
achieving any kind of consensus on the subject will often be derived from
deeply entrenched native views on both sides.
The result is the realization through consideration of this text that
some degree of resolution will never truly be achieved. Moreover, it also
demonstrates that Rose is inherently biased toward the type of progressive
technological and scientific innovation that would be considered anathema,
even blasphemy, to so many who have interjected loudly on the subject.
This allows his work to resonate with those already camped on his side of
the discussion but also tends to cause it a shortfall from its proposed
ambition to invoke balance and compromise. Ultimately, the conversation on
optimization demonstrates, as an example of this shortcoming, that Rose is
essentially dismissive of those whose bioethical expertise have caused them
to reject the prospects of innovation in favor of moral turpitude. To this
point, Rose inserts the most important aspect of his opinion into the
conversation of moral dogma, a matter which he argues has adversely
impacted the speed of innovation for people in the medical and scientific
Based on this clear position on the matter, the outcome of his study
is Rose's endorsement of biomedicine as the way forward, seeking only to
use the objections raised by its opponents to shepherd the process
ethically and responsibly. Though it is certain that this type of balance
would be of little consolation to those viewing an ethical conflict in
something such as stem-cell research, for instance. However-and Rose's
perspective indicates this to be the far more important accomplishment-this
balance would likely prove most beneficial to the improvement of medical
options for the bettering and lengthening of human life.

Works Cited:

Rose, N.S. (2006). The Politics of Life…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited:

Rose, N.S. (2006). The Politics of Life Itself. Princeton University

Cite this Document:

"The Biomedical Debate According To" (2009, June 06) Retrieved June 15, 2021, from

"The Biomedical Debate According To" 06 June 2009. Web.15 June. 2021. <>

"The Biomedical Debate According To", 06 June 2009, Accessed.15 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Biomedical Ethics
Words: 1250 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Death and Dying  (general) Paper #: 17759625

Biomedical Ethics: Euthanasia Mercy killing continues to elicit debates on the moral and ethical aspects involved in conducting the act. Mercy killing, which is also called euthanasia, is a practice that medical professionals consider to assist the terminally ill patients (Huxtable 21). Terminal illnesses do not have a cure, or such conditions that have terminal consequence are irreversible. For instance, the case of Paul Mills, who was terminally ill due to

Biomedical Ethics
Words: 1599 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 55163989

Child Limit Laws Biomedical Ethics The debate regarding the right of having children against the importance of national family planning has raged for years. In the late 1960s, many strongly believed that a decline in fertility rates would slow population growth, especially in developing countries and thus reduce poverty. This was the popular view at the time but in the 1980s, there emerged a fresh thinking about the right to bear children.

Personhood Debate Vs. IVF in
Words: 2253 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 71572460

Additionally, the utilitarian position presents the advantage of objectively quantifying the interests of everyone affected by the decision, for the sole purpose of promoting common welfare. Thus, harvesting, fertilizing, genetically screening, implanting and researching human embryos at the risk of damaging or destroying them - is entirely justified from this perspective, and any progressive endeavor is encouraged. Nevertheless, this approach might involuntarily discourage many IVF clients as it appears to

Ethical Issues Raised by Biomedical
Words: 1736 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 62814486

As the narrow policy discussions regarding Physician-Assisted Suicide continue, we ought to encourage all presently existing and legal methods of reducing the painful sufferings during the last phase of life. References Drickamer, Margaret, a; Lee, Melinda. a; Ganzini, Linda. (1997, Jan 15) "Practical Issues in Physician-Assisted Suicide" Annals of Internal Medicine, vol. 126, no. 2, pp: 146-151. Emauel, Ezekiel. (1997, Mar) "Whose right to die?" The Atlantic Monthly, vol. 17, no. 2,

Social Interactions Between Alternative Therapists
Words: 4392 Length: 14 Pages Topic: Medicine Paper #: 99447605

There are a variety of approaches to diagnosis and treatment in American acupuncture that incorporates medical traditions from China, Japan, Korea, Tibet, Vietnam, and France. " (2002) The American Medical Association additionally reports: "Acupuncture has been used by millions of American patients and performed by over 5,000 U.S. physicians, dentists, acupuncturists, and other practitioners for relief or prevention of pain and for a variety of health conditions. After reviewing the

Iran Bioethics and Biotechnology Issues
Words: 2576 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Technology Paper #: 43708520

Executive summary Contemporary Biotechnology has produced considerable contribution to the global farming and health sector. Advancement of several medicines, numerous pharmaceuticals, vaccines making use of recombinant DNA technology has made biotechnology a multibillion dollar global industry. Additionally, PCR centered diagnostics has additionally materialized as a crucial element of the health industry. Because vast majority of the Islamic nations have their economies centered on farming, biotechnology has therefore enormous potential to improve