This paper presents a clinical case study of a 13-year-old male student who sustained a complex Salter-Harris type II fracture of the proximal right tibia during a Physical Education class. The paper examines the incidence of this injury among young athletes, relevant genetic and weight-related risk factors, the pathophysiology of tibial tuberosity fractures and their relationship to Osgood-Schlatter's disease, and the patient's clinical manifestations. It further analyzes the laboratory and diagnostic tests ordered, including X-ray and MRI, and reviews the standards of care applied, including Open Reduction Internal Fixation (ORIF) surgery, pain management, and post-operative protocols. Potential long-term complications and outcomes are also discussed.
The paper models evidence-based clinical reasoning by consistently linking patient-specific findings to published literature. Each clinical observation — from the mechanism of injury to the choice of diagnostic tests — is validated against a cited source, demonstrating how nurses and clinicians use research to support individualized care decisions.
The paper follows a structured clinical case format with eight clearly delineated sections. It opens with patient history and presentation, then moves progressively from epidemiological context and risk factors through pathophysiology, symptom analysis, diagnostics, and treatment, before closing with prognosis and long-term complications. This organization mirrors the standard clinical reasoning sequence used in nursing and medical education.
A 13-year-old male middle school student was admitted to the hospital complaining of severe pain in the right knee sustained while playing football during Physical Education class. As the patient turned to run for a pass, he twisted his right knee and fell to the ground. He reports immediately feeling a snapping and popping sensation at the right knee, followed by severe pain. The knee began to swell and deform following the fall, and he was unable to bear weight.
The Physical Education coach called 911, and the patient was transported by ambulance to the emergency department. X-rays taken in the Emergency Room revealed that the patient had sustained a right proximal tibia fracture. A basic metabolic panel, blood cell profile, PT/INR, and PTT were all completed. Lab results were within normal limits, with the exception of the white blood cell count, which was slightly elevated at 14.1 × 10⁹/L. No past traumas or pre-existing conditions were reported prior to the knee injury.
X-rays showed that the patient had sustained a complex Salter-Harris type II fracture involving the anterior aspect of the proximal right tibia, with elevation of the tibial tubercle and anterior epiphysis. Adirim and Cheng (2003) report that the areas of the body most commonly injured in young athletes are the ankle and the knee, followed by injuries to the hand and wrist, elbow, shin and calf, head, neck, and clavicle. The incidence of emergency department visits for sports-related injuries peaks at roughly 2.6 million for individuals aged 5 to 24 years (Adirim and Cheng, 2003). Experts estimate that approximately 34% of all middle-school-aged youth will sustain a sports-related injury that will need to be treated by a doctor or nurse (Adirim and Cheng, 2003).
With respect to apophyseal injuries in young athletes, the insertion of the patellar tendon on the tibial tubercle is one of the most common sites of injury (Adirim and Cheng, 2003). The mechanism of injury for ankle injuries and Salter-Harris type I and type II injuries is the same, which should trigger consideration of these injury types in cases involving open physes (Adirim and Cheng, 2003). Acute tibial tubercle avulsion fractures are uncommon in adolescents who engage in sports when they have reached the end of their growth phase between the ages of 14 and 17 (Zrig et al., 2008). This type of injury occurs in approximately 3% of proximal tibial fractures, and the incidence rate is about 1% of all physeal injuries (Zrig et al., 2008). The injury sustained by this patient aligns with available data regarding incidence by age group and activity type.
There is some evidence of an association between patellar femoral pain syndrome (PFPS) and slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) of the hip in pre-adolescent and early adolescent age groups, with incidence rates higher for boys who are overweight and who are African American (Adirim and Cheng, 2003). Two considerations regarding the possibility of an underlying condition are relevant to this case: the patient weighs 190 pounds, which is heavy for a 5-foot, 4-inch frame, and the patient is Hispanic. The family history does not present any conditions — such as osteoporosis, genetic disorders, or bone-affecting cancers — that would be of concern. Beyond his disproportionate body weight, reflected in a body mass index of 32.6, there is no evidence that the patient had a pre-existing condition that would have significantly increased his risk of this type of knee injury.
It is important to note that the histological changes occurring during Osgood-Schlatter's disease can alter the biomechanical qualities of cartilage and predispose it to disruption (Zrig et al., 2008). Meniscal damage is the most common injury that occurs in combination with an avulsion fracture of the anterior tibial tuberosity and patellar tendon disruption (Zrig et al., 2008).
Commonly, fractures may present a constellation of manifestations, including pain, loss of function, deformity, swelling, bruising, abnormal mobility and crepitus, neurovascular changes, muscle spasm, tenderness, and shock (Black and Hawks, 2009). Patients who sustain a complex Salter-Harris type II fracture involving the anterior aspect of the proximal tibia with elevation of the tibial tubercle and anterior epiphysis are likely to manifest a number of common symptoms. Invariably, the patient will report severe pain in the proximal tibial metaphyseal area (Zrig et al., 2008). The patient will also be unable to bear weight on the injured leg (Zrig et al., 2008), and the area around the knee will be diffusely swollen (Zrig et al., 2008).
Upon admission, the patient manifested the following signs and symptoms: pain, deformity, swelling, abnormal mobility, tenderness, intact distal capillary refill, right knee skin intact, and the ability to dorsiflex (DF) and plantarflex (PF) the toes. Upon examination, the patient was unable to move his right knee, as any movement caused sharp and severe pain; nor was he able to bear weight on the right extremity. Swelling of the right leg was evident, with capillary refill of less than 3 seconds and all lower extremity pulses intact. The right leg was tender and warm to the touch. The patient was able to wiggle his toes and perform both dorsiflexion and plantarflexion of the toes and foot.
Fractures of the tibial tuberosity frequently occur as a result of sports-related injuries (Zrig et al., 2008). Commonly, there is a direct mechanism — such as an abrupt contraction of the patellar tendon or a violent extension of the leg from a jump impulse — or a more indirect mechanism, such as reflex contraction against abrupt knee flexion (Zrig et al., 2008). The patient's description of the mechanism of injury during his football activity aligns with the mechanisms reported in the literature in association with a complex Salter-Harris type II fracture involving the anterior aspect of the proximal right tibia with elevation of the tibial tubercle and anterior epiphysis.
An X-ray of the right knee was ordered to verify the diagnosis of a complex Salter-Harris type II fracture involving the anterior aspect of the proximal right tibia with elevation of the tibial tubercle and anterior epiphysis. Radiography is a reliable, noninvasive test for detecting abnormalities in bone and was essential for determining the extent of trauma sustained during the injury. However, because radiography does not reveal abnormalities in soft tissues, tendons, or ligaments, an MRI was also ordered.
An MRI utilizes large magnets to create detailed images of both soft tissue and bone. Since the fracture typically involves the anterior aspect of the physis and the tibial tuberosity apophysis, MRI was indicated to determine whether the tibia and/or fibula had been injured. The MRI revealed that the apophysis was not fractured and that the patellar tendon remained attached to the apophysis.
Neither computerized tomography nor laminagrams were ordered for the diagnosis of this patient's injury (Dias et al., 1983). Computerized tomography is a type of X-ray that provides cross-sectional "slice" images of a body area, enabling a more detailed view of a joint with a complex break (Dias et al., 1983). Laminagrams are X-rays in which the tissues above and below the level of the break are blurred in order to emphasize a particular area; they can be useful to identify bone fragments and to verify that reduction is adequate (Dias et al., 1983). However, given the patient's age and the adequacy of information obtained through X-ray and MRI, additional imaging was neither indicated nor warranted.
You’re 61% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 4 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.