Richard Anderson vs. Jeff Smisek: Airline CEO Leadership Styles
This paper compares the leadership styles and executive records of two prominent U.S. airline CEOs: Richard H. Anderson of Delta Air Lines and Jeff Smisek of United Airlines. The paper examines each leader's background, management philosophy, and approach to major airline mergers. Anderson is characterized as a strategic, open, and composed leader whose stewardship of the Delta–Northwest merger produced significant financial gains and industry-wide consolidation. Smisek is described as a pragmatic, culture-focused leader whose United–Continental merger encountered operational difficulties and ultimately ended with his resignation amid a federal corruption investigation. The paper evaluates both leaders' overall effectiveness and draws conclusions about their contrasting executive styles.
- Leader Backgrounds and Credentials: Career histories and education of both CEOs
- Comparing Leadership Styles: Open communication vs. pragmatic culture-focused management
- Evaluating Each Leader: Good or Bad?: Anderson's successes versus Smisek's failures and scandal
- Approaches to Leading Their Respective Mergers: Delta-Northwest consolidation compared to United-Continental integration
- Conclusion: Summary judgment on both leaders' overall effectiveness
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The parallel structure — applying the same evaluative categories to both leaders — makes comparison clear and systematic throughout.
- The paper draws on primary source material, including a direct interview with Smisek in Fortune magazine, giving concrete grounding to leadership claims.
- It moves logically from biography to leadership style to effectiveness to merger management, building a cumulative argument about executive quality.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative analysis as a rhetorical and organizational strategy. By holding each analytical category constant across both subjects — background, style, effectiveness, merger approach — the writer creates a structured basis for judgment rather than simply narrating each CEO separately. This technique allows readers to draw direct inferences without the writer always making them explicit.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with brief professional biographies of each leader, then transitions into a direct comparison of their leadership philosophies. A dedicated section evaluates whether each qualifies as a "good" or "bad" leader based on outcomes and conduct. The merger section forms the analytical core, contrasting Anderson's deliberate, strategically successful consolidation with Smisek's culturally ambitious but operationally troubled merger. A reference list closes the paper.
Leader Backgrounds and Credentials
Richard H. Anderson, CEO of Delta Air Lines
Richard H. Anderson holds a Bachelor of Science degree as well as a Juris Doctor degree. Anderson served as Chief Executive of Northwest Airlines between 2001 and 2004 — his overall tenure at Northwest spanned from 1990 to 2004. He subsequently held the CEO position at Ingenix (now OptumInsight, Inc.) from 2005 to 2007, before becoming Executive Vice President at UnitedHealth Group Inc. from 2004 to 2007. He also served as President of the New Commercial Services Group at UnitedHealth Group from 2005 to 2007. Having accumulated numerous executive roles since entering the field in 1990, Anderson developed the leadership skills he would later use to drive organizations forward. He has served as Delta Air Lines' CEO since September 1, 2007 (Bloomberg, 2016).
Jeff Smisek, Former CEO of United Airlines
Jeffery (Jeff) A. Smisek graduated in 1976 with a Bachelor of Arts in Economics (summa cum laude) and earned his Juris Doctor degree (magna cum laude) from Harvard Law School in 1982. He served as President and CEO of both United Continental Holdings and United Airlines (formerly Continental Airlines, a United Continental Holdings subsidiary) from October 1, 2010 through September 8, 2015. Prior to that, he served as an officer at Sybase, Inc., and as President, Chairman, and CEO of Continental Airlines from January 1, 2010 through September 2010 (Bloomberg, 2016).
References
Bloomberg. (2016). Delta Air Lines Inc. (DAL:New York). Bloomberg.
Bloomberg. (2016). United Continental Holdings. Bloomberg.
Carey, S. (2016, February 3). Delta Air Lines CEO Richard Anderson to retire, become executive chairman. The Wall Street Journal.
CF. (2016, February 9). Delta CEO Richard Anderson's retirement caps a remarkable nine years for the airline. Cranky Flier.
Chimoff, H. (2011, June 28). Leadership tips from United CEO Jeff Smisek. HarveyChimoff.com.
Hartung, A. (2015, September 11). Smisek's United ouster — were you really surprised? Forbes.
Johnson, J. (2014, July 29). Tips for success from Delta Air Lines CEO Richard Anderson. Airline Reporter.
Reed, D. (2015, September 8). Smisek's ouster as United CEO linked to alleged corruption of Christie-appointee at Port Authority. Forbes.
Smisek, J. (2011, April 21). Jeff Smisek: United Continental's king of the skies [Interview]. (G. Colvin, Interviewer). Fortune.
Walsh, T. (2002, February 25). Detroit Free Press Tom Walsh column. Knight Ridder-Tribune Business News.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.