America's Education Crisis: Barber's Call for Reform
This essay examines the state of American education through the lens of Benjamin R. Barber's 1993 Harper's Magazine essay "America Skips School." Drawing on Barber's argument that Americans pay lip service to education while prioritizing materialism, the paper reviews data on U.S. consumer spending habits and international education expenditure rankings. It argues that the collapse of the social contract around public schooling has produced a genuine crisis, then surveys Barber's proposed remedies — higher teacher salaries, better school facilities, reduced class sizes, an extended academic year, and less bureaucracy — while adding a call to leverage information technology and performance-based compensation as complementary reforms.
- Introduction: Words Without Action: Americans praise education but act otherwise
- Consumer Spending vs. Education Investment: Data shows spending on goods dwarfs education
- The Roots of the Education Crisis: Democratic failure drives the schooling crisis
- Barber's Proposed Reforms: Salary increases, smaller classes, longer school year
- Bureaucracy, Autonomy, and Classroom Priorities: Excess administration pulls teachers from classrooms
- Technology and Performance-Based Solutions: Virtual teaching and merit pay as modern fixes
- Conclusion: Shifting Values Toward Excellence: Reform requires shifting from consumerism to learning
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds its argument in a credible primary source — Barber's well-known Harper's essay — and uses direct quotation effectively to support each major claim.
- The paper moves logically from diagnosis (low spending, consumerist values, collapsed social contract) to prescription (salary reform, class size, technology), giving the argument a clear cause-and-effect shape.
- It acknowledges counterarguments — economic crisis, absent funds, public distrust of institutions — before reaffirming the core position, which demonstrates balanced reasoning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates how to use a secondary critical source as a structural backbone. Rather than simply summarizing Barber, the student integrates his claims with independent statistical evidence (GDP spending rankings, consumer expenditure percentages) and then extends the argument by proposing technology-based solutions Barber did not address, showing how to build on a source rather than merely report it.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a framing quotation and thesis, then moves through three analytical phases: (1) an evidence section presenting spending data to establish the crisis; (2) a reform section surveying Barber's specific proposals; and (3) a forward-looking section adding the student's own technology-based recommendations. A brief conclusion ties democratic stakes to the need for excellence in education.
Introduction: Words Without Action
According to Benjamin R. Barber, "Americans pay lip service to the idea of quality education, but they continue to place a higher value on materialism than on knowledge and civility. Improved teaching conditions and increased parental involvement in education are necessary" (Barber, 1). Our politicians, our government, and even the citizens of the United States speak of the importance of education, but our actions do not convey those words. When it comes to education, our words must be followed by action.
Much is said about education in contemporary society, and everybody agrees on its importance. However, factual data suggests that this appreciation exists solely at a verbal level. The American people spend a small fraction of their overall income on education, and the United States ranks 10th in the world in educational spending. It is safe to assume that the way in which we invest our economic resources reveals our most important priorities. According to these numbers, neither the country as a system nor individual citizens are genuinely committed to education. A Department of Education study cited by Barber found that "more than 90 million adult Americans lacked simple literacy." If education is not what we spend our money on, then what is?
Bibliography
Barber, B. R. "America Skips School: Why We Talk So Much About Education and Do So Little." Harper's Magazine, Nov. 1993, v287, n1722, p. 39.
"Where Does the Money Go? How the Average U.S. Consumer Spends Their Paycheck." Visual Economics. Retrieved September 30, 2010, from http://www.visualeconomics.com/how-the-average-us-consumer-spends-their-paycheck/
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.