This essay argues that the formal compositional structures of the Baroque and Classical eras—such as the sonata form and the oratorio—did not suppress creativity but instead provided a framework within which composers like Handel and Beethoven could innovate and emotionally engage their audiences. Drawing a parallel to the formulaic constraints of the modern music marketplace, the paper contends that structural conventions heighten the impact of musical deviation and surprise. The essay concludes that the greatest composers across all eras succeed by simultaneously satisfying listener expectations and subverting them.
Creativity is associated with freedom from constraint and defiance of accepted norms in modern American culture. Thus, it is easy to dismiss the formal compositional requirements of the Baroque and Classical eras as obstacles to innovation. Yet composers like Handel and Beethoven were able to use the order and structure of forms such as the oratorio and the sonata to express something new and to emotionally move their listeners. A modern critic might note that even a quick scan of the radio dial is a reminder that, despite the American cultural emphasis on individual creativity, the modern marketplace has dictated a highly formulaic style for popular music — perhaps even more formulaic than anything produced in the Baroque or Classical era.
Without some structure on which to hang a composition, rebellion and innovation are not noticeable to a listener, regardless of the age in which the music was composed. For example, the sonata form favored by Beethoven introduces a mood or emotion in the first section, then alters it slightly — usually by slowing the tempo — and finally returns to the first movement at the original tempo, with a difference that reflects the emotional and musical progression of the middle movement ("Sonata," The Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition, Columbia University Press, 2003). The nature of this structure and the conventions of the form highlight the change that has taken place within the music, and thus the composer's ability to innovate is brought to light. A joyful ending sounds all the more joyful when paired with a somber middle section.
The sonata form exists as a kind of frame on which to demonstrate the composer's unique style and reflective use of musical vocabulary — fast and slow, minor and major keys — and to invite listeners to think about music in a different way. Likewise, the earlier Baroque period made frequent use of sharp contrasts in mood between successive musical movements. The composer's use of the listener's expectations of such contrasts enabled the composer both to draw the listener in and to take the listener by surprise when the convention was deviated from — or put to brilliant use, as in the burst of joy in Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus" ("Baroque Music," Musopen, 2007).
"Shared constraints in historical and modern music"
"Listener expectations and the impact of musical surprise"
You’re 57% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.