This paper examines the relationship between historical environment and musical composition across the major periods of Western classical music. Beginning with the Baroque era's reflection of absolute monarchy and divine authority in the works of Bach and Handel, the paper traces how shifting social conditions gave rise to the ordered precision of the Classical period in Mozart, Haydn, and Beethoven. It then considers how Romantic nationalism, industrialization, and emotional expressionism shaped composers such as Wagner, Tchaikovsky, and Berlioz. Finally, it addresses how the upheavals of the twentieth century—the Industrial Revolution, the Great War, and rapid technological change—drove innovators like Bartók and Stravinsky to break with tradition entirely.
"No man is an island" — so goes the old saying. It is equally true of music as of so many other aspects of the human experience. Just turn on the radio and listen. What you hear today is not likely to have been the same as what you heard ten or twenty years ago, nor what you will be likely to hear ten or twenty years hence. The anti-war ballads of the 1960s were shaped by the effects of the Vietnam War. The electronic rhythms of the 1970s were musical reflections of a world of discos and lounge lizards. By the same token, the harmonious and balanced compositions of the latter part of the eighteenth century gave audible form to the rational schemes of the philosophes. Each great change in musical tastes can be traced back to corresponding developments in society and civilization.
Western classical music breaks down into a handful of major periods. The Baroque found its expression in the polyphonic compositions of a Bach; the Classical in the mathematical precision of a Mozart; the Romantic in the highly charged works of Tchaikovsky — and so on. The music of every composer is shaped by the world in which he lived.
The works of Bach and Handel belong firmly in the Baroque era. The late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries were, in Europe, the heyday of the grand absolute monarchies. Europe's kings and princes ruled mostly by Divine Right. J. S. Bach's Cantata No. 140, "Wachet Auf," encapsulates the importance of religion at the time. "Wake up," the listener is exhorted — it is as if to say that one need merely be alive to understand the eternal truths, namely that the power of God and the power of princes are inextricably linked. Georg Friedrich Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus" is intimately associated with a particular tale: England's king stood when he first heard those words. It is entirely appropriate — an earthly king reverencing a composition that pays homage to the one and only Heavenly King. Baroque music is the ultimate expression of the idea of a single, unified world that is nonetheless composed of many variant parts.
As Maconie (1997) observes, "A music of constant change of harmonic reference is accommodated in baroque architecture, whose curved surfaces and disturbed symmetries are acoustically adapted to varying harmonies. We therefore discern a connection… [with] the spatial rhetoric of the great baroque palaces" (p. 177).
Mozart, Haydn, and Beethoven belong to a rather different era. As the eighteenth century wore on, the excesses of the Baroque began to disappear in a quest for simplicity and naturalism. Artists and architects looked back to Ancient Greece and Rome. Much of the music of this period is mathematically extremely precise and orderly. Still, the eighteenth-century notion of a well-regulated world is reflected in the increasing preference for all-encompassing works.
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart wrote the music for Don Giovanni, an opera that combined within it virtually all of the known arts. The story's secular theme also speaks to an era that was no longer overly religious and was in fact given to some degree of frivolity. Yet the careful melodies call to mind a still hierarchical and unchanging society. Haydn wrote many compositions for his princely patron. Among the most famous is his Surprise Symphony, the very name of which reveals the playfulness of life in the small German courts. Haydn wrote for an aristocratic audience in a Europe still almost completely dominated by a centuries-old nobility. The strongly cerebral quality of Beethoven's earlier works, such as the Fifth Symphony, likewise demonstrates the often rarified tastes of this highly stratified world.
The custom of numbering instrumental compositions rather than giving them meaningfully descriptive titles reflects the absolute quality sought by composers of the period. Beethoven did not wish to hint at anything that might influence his listeners' appreciation of his music. Classical music stands on its own — a piece is only associated with other arts if the composer wishes it to be so. Thus Mozart can write instrumental pieces for operas, while Beethoven can compose works that are complete worlds in and of themselves.
It is therefore interesting that Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven also represent the very beginnings of a new trend in music — the age of the Romantics. As Taruskin (1995) notes, "Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven, who were universally regarded as the first musical Romantics by the generation (that of E.T.A. Hoffmann) who defined the Romantic aesthetic, the very same generation that first had the notion of 'absolute' music" (p. 224).
"Wagner and Tchaikovsky channel national emotion"
"Industrial change drives Bartók and Stravinsky's innovations"
Gillies, M. (2000). Analyzing Bartók's works of 1918–1922: Motives, tone patches, and tonal mosaics. In E. Antokoletz, V. Fischer, & B. Suchoff (Eds.), Bartók perspectives: Man, composer, and ethnomusicologist (pp. 43–56). Oxford University Press.
Maconie, R. (1997). The science of music. Oxford University Press.
Taruskin, R. (1995). Text and act: Essays on music and performance. Oxford University Press.
You’re 49% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.