Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 2,441 words

Biblical Theology and Philosophy: Relationship and Definitions

~13 min read 6 sections Religion · Theology
Abstract

This paper examines the complex and evolving relationship between biblical theology and Western philosophy, tracing debates from early church figures such as Tertullian, Justin Martyr, and Augustine through medieval scholasticism and into contemporary analytic theology. It identifies three foundational Christian doctrines — the Trinity, the Atonement, and the Incarnation — as particularly significant for philosophical inquiry. The second half of the paper defines biblical theology as a discipline, drawing on scholars including J.P. Gabler, Geerhardus Vos, D.A. Carson, and Stephen Wellum, and distinguishes it from systematic theology on the basis of its historical, progressive, and narrative approach to divine revelation.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Philosophy and Biblical Theology: Overview of philosophy–theology relationship and paper scope
  • Early Christian Thinkers on the Relationship Between Philosophy and Theology: Tertullian, Justin Martyr, Augustine on philosophy and faith
  • Medieval Scholasticism and Modern Analytic Theology: Aquinas, scholasticism, 20th-century separation and revival
  • What Is Biblical Theology?: Definition, Gabler's founding role, hermeneutics
  • Defining Biblical Theology: Key Scholars and Frameworks: Vos, Carson, Wellum, Schreiner define biblical theology
  • Conclusion: Convergence of philosophy and biblical theology today
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It surveys a broad intellectual history efficiently, moving from patristic debates through medieval scholasticism to contemporary analytic theology without losing coherence.
  • It integrates multiple authoritative perspectives — Tertullian, Augustine, Aquinas, Vos, Carson, and Wellum — and clearly contrasts their positions rather than simply listing them.
  • The transition from the relational discussion to the definitional section is well-structured, using the question "What is Biblical Theology?" as an explicit pivot point.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates effective comparative analysis across historical periods. Rather than treating each thinker in isolation, it groups figures by their stance on the philosophy–theology relationship (separation vs. complementarity) and traces how those stances evolved, creating a coherent intellectual narrative across more than two millennia.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a broad framing of the philosophy–theology relationship and narrows progressively: early church debates (Tertullian vs. Justin Martyr and Augustine), medieval scholasticism (Aquinas), 20th-century separation and revival, and finally a dedicated definitional section on biblical theology drawing on Gabler, Vos, Carson, and Wellum. The conclusion synthesizes both halves, asserting that the two disciplines have converged in modern academic practice.

Essay 2,441 words

Introduction: Philosophy and Biblical Theology

Historically, biblical theology and philosophy have had much in common and have often complemented each other. At the same time, philosophers and theologians have in certain cases considered themselves mortal enemies. Most Christian doctrines carry critical implications or presuppositions for philosophy. This paper begins with an examination of the relationship between philosophy and Christianity, then defines biblical theology based on three Christian doctrines that influence philosophy: the Trinity, the Atonement, and the Incarnation. Other doctrines — such as those concerning God's attributes and providence — are excluded because they are not unique to Christianity. Unlike the doctrine of Christ's Real Presence in the Eucharist and the origin of sin, these three doctrines have long been discussed and applied in relation to philosophy (Amanze, 2012).

The debate on Christian traditions and the relationship between philosophy and biblical theology continues. An influential apologist and Christian theologian of the early church, Tertullian, did not believe any relationship exists between philosophy and theology. According to his argument, the intrusion of secular philosophical thought into biblical theology was not in order. Therefore, even though some theological claims seemed reasonable to certain philosophers, a true Christian should never waver (McLean, 2012). According to Tertullian, philosophy tends to corrupt biblical theology and generate beliefs grounded in neither orthodox tradition nor the early customs of Christians. He famously asked what Athens has to do with Jerusalem — Athens representing Hellenistic philosophy, and Jerusalem symbolizing Christianity as the early church's intellectual center and a location of critical importance (Legaspi, 2010).

With the coincidence between the two disciplines, philosophy can easily fall under biblical theology, and the converse may also be true. People who do not accept divine revelation as expressed in religious texts are more likely to be persuaded through philosophical arguments. For example, an atheist who rejects religious authority may be persuaded through philosophical reasoning to believe that God exists. Philosophical techniques can also help a theologian to clarify ambiguity or errors in theological arguments. Theology may offer enough information to conclude that Jesus Christ possessed both divine and human natures, yet fail to explain the precise relationship between those two natures (DeWeese, 2011).

This is where philosophy can assist the theologian — helping to discern logically inconsistent models and to better comprehend Christ's nature as both human and divine. Based on the view that a relationship exists between philosophy and biblical theology, arguments drawn from revelation render a discussion theological, while arguments not grounded in biblical concepts remain philosophical. This is one way the two disciplines can be clearly differentiated. However, when one scholar reaches a conclusion, others with different views are likely to offer contradictions. Those who advocate for an integrated model perceive such conflicts as merely apparent, since the claims made by one thinker cannot be genuinely contradicted by another unless the former has made some error — a position grounded in the belief that God created the world and revealed truth both through scripture and through natural reason (In Bartholomew, 2011).

5 Sections Hidden · 1,550 words
Early Christian Thinkers on the Relationship Between Philosophy and Theology320 words
Other theological leaders were more open to relating philosophy with biblical theology. According to Justin Martyr, figures such as Socrates and Heraclitus possessed…
Medieval Scholasticism and Modern Analytic Theology380 words
Thomas Aquinas, for example, drew most of his key concepts from Aristotle. During the Middle Ages, scholasticism was an important dimension of both…
What Is Biblical Theology?310 words
The study of biblical doctrines in their chronological and historical context as they are organized in the Bible is known as biblical theology. Unlike systematic theology, which organizes doctrines by topic, biblical theology analyzes…
Defining Biblical Theology: Key Scholars and Frameworks420 words
According to Geerhardus Vos, widely regarded as the grandfather of biblical theology, it is a sub-category of Exegetical Theology that deals with God's self-revelation as recorded in the Bible. This means that biblical revelation is not focused on the individual…
Conclusion120 words
Clearly, philosophy and biblical studies were treated as distinct disciplines in the early centuries. The two fields have been regarded as related and complementary in…

References

Addinall, P. (1991). Philosophy and biblical interpretation: A study in nineteenth-century conflict. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Amanze, N. (2012). Biblical studies, theology, religion and philosophy: An introduction for African universities.

Carson, D. A. (2012). Christ and culture revisited. Grand Rapids, MI; Cambridge: Eerdmans.

DeWeese, G. J. (2011). Doing philosophy as a Christian. Westmont: InterVarsity Press.

Hamilton, J. M. (2010). God's glory in salvation through judgment: A biblical theology. Wheaton, IL: Crossway.

Hamilton, J. M. (2014). What is biblical theology?: A guide to the Bible's story, symbolism, and patterns.

In Bartholomew, C. G. (2011). "Behind" the text: History and biblical interpretation.

Johnson, D. (2014). Biblical knowing: A scriptural epistemology of error. Havertown: James Clarke & Co.

Legaspi, M. C. (2010). The death of scripture and the rise of biblical studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

McLean, B. H. (2012). Biblical interpretation and philosophical hermeneutics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Velde, M., Visscher, G. H., Van, V. J., Kamphuis, B., Venema, C. P., Anderson, R. D., Visser, A. J., & Kwakkel, G. (2014). Correctly handling the word of truth: Reformed hermeneutics today.

Vos, G. (2003). Biblical theology: Old and New Testaments. Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock Publishers.

Wellum, S. J. (2016). God the Son incarnate: The doctrine of Christ.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Biblical Theology Divine Revelation Analytic Theology Systematic Theology Christian Doctrine Hermeneutics Scholasticism Trinity Incarnation Atonement
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Biblical Theology and Philosophy: Relationship and Definitions. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/biblical-theology-philosophy-relationship-2174717

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.