Lying in Public Life: Bok's Ethics of Deception Examined
This paper examines Sissela Bok's book Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life through the lens of public administration, exploring the ethical tensions civil servants and politicians face when considering deception. The paper surveys Bok's key arguments — including the Nazi ship captain example, Plato's noble lie, and political lying — while applying them to real-world cases such as the Iraq War, the Enron scandal, and George H.W. Bush's tax pledge. It concludes that although lying may sometimes appear necessary for institutional survival, Bok's framework ultimately discourages deception as corrosive to democratic trust and public accountability.
- Introduction: Conflict and Deception in Public Administration: Lying as a tool in public institutions
- When Lying May Be Morally Justified: Bok's examples of morally defensible lies
- The Noble Lie and Political Deception: Plato's noble lie and political manipulation
- Civil Servants, Self-Preservation, and Institutional Lies: Lying to protect programs and positions
- The Long-Term Cost of Lost Credibility: Enron, McDonald's, and credibility tradeoffs
- Bok's Ethical Framework: Truth, Falsity, and Moral Choice: Kantian ethics and Bok's code against lying
- Conclusion: Lying as a Last Resort: Deception as final option for civil servants
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper consistently grounds its ethical analysis in direct quotations from Bok, allowing the source text to anchor each argumentative move rather than relying on paraphrase alone.
- It moves fluidly between abstract philosophical claims and concrete real-world examples — the Iraq War, Enron, and George H.W. Bush's tax pledge — making the theoretical discussion accessible and credible.
- The paper maintains an honest, nuanced stance: it neither condemns all lying outright nor endorses it, mirroring Bok's own measured ethical framework and demonstrating sophisticated moral reasoning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied philosophical analysis — taking an abstract ethical argument from a canonical text and testing it against real institutional scenarios. By juxtaposing Bok's framework with cases from politics and business, the writer shows how theoretical ethics translates (or fails to translate) into practical public-sector decision-making.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by contextualizing lying within the pressures of public administration, then systematically works through Bok's major arguments: justified lies, the noble lie tradition, civil servant self-preservation, and the cost of lost credibility. It closes by summarizing Bok's Kantian-inflected ethical code and offering a personal normative conclusion — that lying should be a genuine last resort for public administrators.
Introduction: Conflict and Deception in Public Administration
The role of a public administrator is often beset by conflicts. These conflicts, as in all organizations, stem from the vested interests of various individuals pursuing personal objectives while working within a public institution. In private companies, performance is driven by imperatives to meet fiscal objectives — generating revenue and maintaining the ability to borrow money to finance new projects. No such natural restraint exists in the public sector, where monetary success can elevate one leader while destroying another. One method of getting ahead, in any situation, is to tell outright lies about others. This is the central subject of Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life by Sissela Bok.
Lying is sometimes considered appropriate in one's role as a public administrator. The life of a public institution — as well as its funding — depends on political patronage. It is always critical that public administrators maintain the appearance of institutional viability, lest they jeopardize their positions. This creates a kind of prisoner's dilemma: because lies exist, they must be considered as an option, even if mutual honesty is preferable to the possibility of mutual deceit.
When Lying May Be Morally Justified
According to Bok, ruling out all lying is ludicrous. He offers the following example: "A captain of a ship transporting fugitives from Nazi Germany, if asked by a patrolling vessel whether there were any Jews on board would, for Kant's critics, have been justified in answering No." (p. 40) Here we see an instance where lying is not merely permissible but a moral obligation — one that protects human lives. Bok extends this reasoning: "If to use force in self-defense or in defending those at risk of murder is right, why then should a lie in self-defense be ruled out?" (p. 41)
Sometimes such lies become institutionalized due to the nature of the law, particularly when laws are obscure, culturally antiquated, or indefensible. For example, in the state of Pennsylvania it is — or has been — illegal for two or more people to engage in oral sex. One would nonetheless expect a law enforcement officer to refrain from acting on overheard accounts that such acts had occurred. In cases like these, the gap between legal obligation and practical moral judgment creates space in which a measure of deliberate non-disclosure becomes socially tolerated.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.