Wolfgang Borchert's The Man Outside: War Guilt and Isolation
This essay analyzes Wolfgang Borchert's expressionist play The Man Outside as a vehicle for exploring post-war German psychological trauma, guilt, and moral ambiguity. The paper examines how Beckmann's confrontation with his former commanding officer dramatizes the unequal burden of war guilt, while allegorical figures — the Other, the River, Death, and God — represent the existential forces that shape human conscience. The essay argues that Borchert uses surrealism and magical realism not to moralize but to stimulate honest dialogue about accountability, denial, and the cost of willful ignorance in the aftermath of the Nazi era.
- Introduction: Post-War Zeitgeist and the Play's Central Concerns: Play's themes of truth-telling and post-war trauma
- Beckmann, Suicide, and Shared Responsibility for Atrocity: Beckmann confronts Colonel over shared war guilt
- Allegorical Figures and the Search for Existential Peace: River, Death, and God as existential symbols
- The Other: Moral Ambiguity and the Human Psyche: The Other as moral enabler and psychological force
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Close textual analysis: the essay grounds its interpretive claims in direct quotations from the play, then unpacks the significance of specific word choices — such as Beckmann's ironic use of "sir" — with precision.
- Thematic coherence: all four allegorical figures (the Other, the River, Death, and God) are tied back to a single unifying argument about the consequences of facing or evading moral truth.
- Concise argumentation: the essay avoids over-summarizing the plot and instead moves quickly to interpretation, keeping the focus on what the drama means rather than merely what happens.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates symbolic close reading — systematically identifying recurring symbols (the River, the Other, Death) and explaining their function within the play's larger moral framework. Rather than treating each symbol in isolation, the author shows how they work together to dramatize the psychological and ethical aftermath of wartime complicity.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis framing the play as a stimulus for honest dialogue rather than moral instruction. It then examines Beckmann's confrontation with the Colonel as a concrete case study in shared guilt. The third section broadens outward to the play's allegorical figures, and the final section focuses specifically on the paradoxical character of the Other. This movement from the particular (a single scene) to the universal (the human psyche) gives the essay a clear sense of intellectual progression.
Introduction: Post-War Zeitgeist and the Play's Central Concerns
Wolfgang Borchert's play The Man Outside captures the self-hatred and angst of the German post-war zeitgeist. Surreal and filled with magical realism as much as German expressionism, the play symbolizes the difficulty of articulating the tremendous psychological struggles endured by Germans immediately after the Nazi crisis. Borchert does not moralize so much as he stimulates dialogue on the importance of facing the truth — even when that truth is too shameful and painful to confront.
Beckmann, Suicide, and Shared Responsibility for Atrocity
Suicide plays a major role in The Man Outside, and the title itself captures Beckmann's total isolation from his countrymen and kin. Beckmann at times seems the only character in the play willing to feel the pain and sorrow, the guilt and horror, felt after fighting on behalf of the Nazis consciously and willingly. One of the play's key moments occurs when Beckmann faces his former commanding officer, the Colonel. In conversation with the Colonel, and able to reflect on his service and speak his truth, Beckmann claims he came to "give back" the responsibility of killing eleven men (Borchert, p. vii). Beckmann has been living with the burden of those deaths, and while he does take responsibility for obeying orders, he also wants to show the Colonel that the war's atrocities are shared by all participants. "I'm bringing you back the responsibility. Have you completely forgotten, sir?" (Borchert, p. vii).
The Colonel's response indicates that he had either forgotten or had justified the situation by evading the truth. Beckmann's use of the word "sir" — a formality of the hierarchical military organization — is strikingly ironic. The term recalls the Colonel's former power and station in the army, authority that is no longer legitimate. Even though they are no longer bound by military formalities, Beckmann uses "sir" to stress the fact that people in positions of power can be the most ignorant of all: the cruelest and the most responsible for large-scale atrocities that feed Death.
Allegorical Figures and the Search for Existential Peace
The personification of broad universal powers — the Other, the River, Death, and God — shows how human beings must boldly contend with major existential issues in order to find peace and gain insight. Alienation and isolation, denial of truth, and running from the self all lead to profound loneliness and the only true evil: acting without considering the consequences. By remaining willfully ignorant of the truth, the Colonel and others like him avoid the emotional and psychological struggle that Beckmann endures. Yet Beckmann is the hero of the play precisely because he is willing to admit his wrongdoing. He wants to obliterate himself and all memories of the war because the truth is too hard to face while still remaining comfortable with oneself. Even alive, Beckmann has fed Death, and Death waits for him willingly, hungry for as many souls as it can claim.
The River represents hope and change, as rivers continually move and symbolize the passage of time. A river only appears the same from moment to moment; in reality, its water flows and is never in the same place twice. It makes sense, therefore, that Borchert would cast the River as the most compassionate figure in the play — the one that most fervently hopes Beckmann will choose to stay alive.
Works Cited
Borchert, Wolfgang. The Man Outside. New Directions, 1949.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.