Burden of Dreams: Colonialism and Herzog's Ambition
This paper analyzes Les Blank's 1982 documentary Burden of Dreams, which chronicles the tumultuous production of Werner Herzog's film Fitzcarraldo in the Amazonian jungle. The paper argues that both Fitzcarraldo and its making-of documentary illustrate persistent colonial attitudes — particularly a sense of European entitlement and paternalism — imposed upon indigenous peoples and environments. Through close reading of key scenes, the essay examines how Herzog's obsessive ambition, symbolized by his insistence on hauling a real ship over a mountain, became a burden to his crew, his cast, and the native population. The paper also considers Blank's admiring yet subtly critical portrayal of Herzog as a man simultaneously aware of and complicit in a colonial legacy.
- Introduction: A Dream Within a Dream: Herzog's Fitzcarraldo mirrors its own colonial production
- The Ship Over the Mountain as Colonial Symbol: The ship as symbol of egotism and colonial ambition
- The Burden Imposed on Cast and Crew: Herzog's obsession harms cast, crew, and production
- Herzog's Paternalism and the Indigenous Peoples: Segregation and animalistic language toward natives
- Self-Awareness and Irony in Herzog's Vision: Herzog's self-critique within a colonial framework
- Blank's Admiration and Its Limits: Blank admires Herzog but exposes the human cost
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay sustains a clear central argument — that Herzog's filmmaking process mirrors colonial attitudes — and returns to it consistently throughout each section.
- It uses the film's own central symbol (the ship over the mountain) as an analytical lens, grounding abstract claims about colonialism in a concrete, recurring image.
- The paper balances critique with nuance: it acknowledges Herzog's self-awareness and genuine respect for indigenous peoples while still holding him accountable for the harm his ambition caused.
- Direct quotations from the documentary are deployed effectively to support the argument without overwhelming the analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic close reading of a documentary film, treating visual motifs, character behavior, and spoken dialogue as textual evidence. The writer connects on-screen content to broader historical and cultural frameworks — specifically colonialism and manifest destiny — without losing sight of the specific documentary being analyzed.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by establishing the parallel between Fitzcarraldo's plot and its production context, then introduces the colonial theme. Subsequent sections develop the argument through increasingly specific evidence: the ship metaphor, the burdens placed on the Western crew, the treatment of indigenous peoples, and finally Herzog's self-critical moments. The conclusion weighs Blank's admiration against a sober accounting of who paid the price for Herzog's dreams.
Introduction: A Dream Within a Dream
In 1979, German filmmaker Werner Herzog set out to produce a movie about a rubber baron who dreamed of bringing opera to the jungles of South America. Herzog's film, eventually titled Fitzcarraldo after its protagonist, took four years — as well as literal blood, sweat, and tears — to make. The plot of Fitzcarraldo eerily parallels the actual process by which Herzog made his film. Both depict a European man hauling his pride and ambition into a world where he remains sorely out of place, imposing on the indigenous society and environment a set of foreign ideals.
American documentary filmmaker Les Blank followed Herzog and his crew through the harrowing production of Fitzcarraldo, and the result was the Academy Award-winning feature-length documentary Burden of Dreams. The aptly titled "making of" documentary captures the near-insanity of Herzog's ambition and also subtly illustrates the various levels of culture clash that have resulted from colonialism.
The Spanish effectively helped decimate the native cultures of the Amazon, who are still being systematically persecuted and whose land continues to be exploited. Although Herzog's attitude is respectful in many ways, the making of his film demonstrates the lingering colonial attitudes held by persons of European descent — attitudes that mainly entail a sense of entitlement. Burden of Dreams depicts Herzog's own brand of "manifest destiny." While the documentary is largely neutral in its portrayal of Herzog, Blank cannot help but use his film to express a certain admiration for the obsessively driven German filmmaker.
Works Cited
Blank, Les. Burden of Dreams. Documentary film. 1982.
"Burden of Dreams." IMDB.com. Online at <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0083702/>.
"Burden of Dreams." New York Times. 1982. Online at <
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.